Playing the saxophone When can you call yourself a Jazz musician?

Well clearly I'd like to be a jazz musician, hence the question.

Does it matter if it's a hobby and not a profession? I do consider myself a photographer - I''d say I've been one for 35 years, mostly as an amateur but I have done a fair bit of semi professional work over the years (weddings, commercial, portraiture, sold a few prints etc). I don't consider myself less as it's not a full time job. But I'm not sure how one should define being a musician let alone a jazz musician.

Is this an important question? Maybe not, I just wondered what others' considered opinions might be.

As for playing like 'my heros', I'd have to be honest and say that I'm now trying to develop my own sound. Yes I try to imitate Sonny Rollins, Dexter Gordon and others but what I really want to do is sound like me, with some influences. I'm under no illusions about my lack of 'greatness' when it comes to playing sax let alone playing jazz.

I don't copy their sound, that's almost impossible. Just the way they play; Red Prysocks punch, Watts "story-telling-solos", Clemons energy and volume .... .
 
So my question is this.......... am I now a jazz musician or still some bloke who plays some jazz music on his sax?

What do you want to be?

I've been playing sax ,more or less, for over 40 years. I consider myself being a bloke trying to play sax like my heros; King Curtis, Red Prysock, Noble Watts, Lee Allen, Eddie Shaw, JT Brown, Gene Barge, Clarence Clemons ..... . The saxplaying is just a hobby for me.

I bet your pretty good really though but modesty prevents...john
 
Hmm... Styles of music I have played in public (and been paid for - but with varying degrees of success 🙂 ) include: folk, country and western, rock, pop, rock and roll, RnB (the proper stuff), soul, funk, blues, trad jazz, mainstream jazz, free jazz, swing, classical (from medieval to 20th C) and probably I few others I've forgotten.
I play sax. I don't really like limiting labels.

<edit>
Ok, before anyone queries it. I have been paid for playing free jazz - they just didn't realise that's what they'd get.🙂))

You'll also note the absence of bebop. I never quite managed the 8 hours a day practice required for that.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I do bits of DIY round the house - it doesn't make me a carpenter. I designed a house extension once - that doesn't mean I am an architect. I would be hugely flattered if someone called me a "musician" but at the same time, I don't believe the description should be de-valued.

My Dad was what I call a musician. A self-taught, skilled and dedicated semi-pro bass-player, he was out gigging 2-3 nights a week and often did dep jobs where he would get a call and be off an hour later playing a gig with a bunch a strangers, sometimes reading his part from a score he had never seen before, and that could be anything from playing in a pit orchestra to a strict-time dance band (playing for "prancing charlies" as he described ballroom dancers!).

You don't have to be pro to be that good - but on the other hand, if you play often enough to get to that level, you wouldn't be having a lot of spare time on your hands......
 
I never describe myself as a saxophonist. To me that describes some of you guy's with the qualifications and grades and things like that. To be a saxophonist you need a good knowledge of your instrument and of theory. I have neither, therefore I describe myself as a sax player/sax man/tenor man. I get paid quite well when I play with my main band but it's not my full time job and so I believe that makes me a semi pro musician.
I guess it's whatever you feel comfortable with. If you like to be referred to as a Jazz musician then that's how you should introduce yourself. Horses for courses I guess.
 
Wow, it's all go a bit philosophical :w00t:

I'm not looking for a label, I don't want to tout myself about as a jazz musician nor anything like it.

I was merely enquiring as to whether with my experience/competence I might consider myself a jazz musician. Simples.

I think I have enough feedback and comment to suggest that I am within my rights to do so, albeit relatively inexperienced. So thanks one and all.
 
Not yet jazz saxophonist as i still play other types of music.
Don't know what you were listening too at the workshop, seeing as i played sugar and my solo was blues in the night. Maybe your jazz ears need cleaning!! 🙂))🙂))

(Interesting that you suggest that I am a jazz musician yet that you are not. Why so? I think you play as well or better than I do, you have a stronger sound and I recall from your rendition of Black Orphius at the workshop that you played very well. I'd say you are a musician though we are yet to fully define jazz musician perhaps.)

Whatever you were playing it was good!
 
For me, it's a matter of feeling "accepted into the community". That can be the result of a formal process (eg an audition) but more often than not (especially in music) it's informal.

It's a sense of belonging, and of being comfortable playing with other members of that community, and that can take a while to build up (even if you have passed some formal test).

Of course there are all sorts of levels of community.......
 
So we like the term 'Musician', even with the qualifier 'Jazz-', but dislike the labelling of levels within this...

I do have to quite often add 'professional' to my job description though, since if people ask what I do, and I tell them 'musician' or 'saxophonist' their next question is usually 'so what's your real job then?'.

Yes, I do feel a bit poncy doing it, and no, I make no pretention to be a fantastic sax player or teacher. I do however know that I can do it, I've results to prove it, and sometimes I get paid!

Nick
 
I play sax. I don't really like limiting labels.

Well just stop limiting them and do something else........;}


So could you be described a "Label-phobic" or "Label-avoidant"?:shocked:
Being serious it sounds like some folks would feel proud to merit/justify a label
such as "musician" or "jazz musician", and others might feel that labels have a more negative/limiting quality.

I think that the pro/amateur distinction can be a good one - depends on how interested anyone is in whether we get paid or not. In the current debate the main concern seemed to be about when a person playing an instrument can feel that they have "arrived" and are not just a beginner, player or learner.

Kind regards
Tom😎
 
Don't forget there's also a certain snob value associated with it. One can imagine someone saying, "But I'm a jazz musician. I don't play that sort of stuff", when confronted with 'One Step Beyond'.

That reminds me, I forgot to add ska and reggae to my list of styles (how did I forget them? - I do them every bloody week).

Yes, I'm not a great fan of labels. They can be very useful, but some carry too much baggage with them. Especially when applied to oneself. Even after all this time I still struggle with calling myself a musician. It implies too much. "Call yourself a musician? You can't even rattle off 'Flight of the Bumble Bee' from memory." If you see what I mean. I'd rather stick with something straightforward like, "I'm a tall geezer with long hair who plays the sax a bit". Nothing beyond that implied.
 
Guys

All very nice but this was not about you or your mate or labels or owt else. It was just can I now call myself a jazz musician? I think I've got the answer I need to decide for myself. So

If someone asks me about my hobbies I would have said I'm a photographer and I play tenor sax. Now I might say .... and I'm a jazz musician ..or I might not. As a jazz musician I am not restricted from playing other forms of music equally well (badly really) - Smooth Operator, Your Latest Trick, Baggy Trousers, One Step Beyond etc etc.

Thanks again everyone for your comments.

Oh and I think Phil you are a jazz musician too if you want to be.
 
Guys

All very nice but this was not about you or your mate or labels or owt else. It was just can I now call myself a jazz musician? I think I've got the answer I need to decide for myself.

Being maybe a little pedantic Ian, the thread is entitled "When can you call yourself a Jazz musician?" and as a result maybe some of us mis-interpreted it as a general question rather than one specifically about your own personal qualifications.

Anyway, I am glad you have an answer!
 
Ian,

Only your heart will tell you if you are a musician, but my take on what a musician is might be different from others.

I think it's when the music is in your soul. Some people can't play the blues because it's not in their blood, they can mimic and put together 'blues' phrases but it doesn't speak on an emotional level. There are players who can perform music with such technical accuracy that they leave me cold, and others who may not be anywhere near technically but they can elicit and emotional reaction. I think music plays many different roles in our lives, in society and in different cultures, everything from 'lift' music, to a film score that enhances the emotional reaction of the audience to the scene being played out on the screen.

Perhaps a musician is someone who appreciates the music and recognises they are communicating something, either from within themselves or someone else's writing's but with their voice - maybe the level of skill or time spent doing it is secondary.

Anyway have a good weekend and enjoy playing your sax, it's a wonderful thing to be able to do.

Chris
 
Being maybe a little pedantic Ian, the thread is entitled "When can you call yourself a Jazz musician?" and as a result maybe some of us mis-interpreted it as a general question rather than one specifically about your own personal qualifications.

Anyway, I am glad you have an answer!

Pete

You are correct, the post title was as you suggest but in the first piece of text in my initial post I asked "So my question is this.......... am I now a jazz musician or still some bloke who plays some jazz music on his sax?"

I thought it amusing how the debate spiralled off about labels and restrictions and then went all philosophical 🙂

It's all a bit of a laugh really as I don't suppose any of it matters either way.

Ian,

Only your heart will tell you if you are a musician, but my take on what a musician is might be different from others.

I think it's when the music is in your soul. Some people can't play the blues because it's not in their blood, they can mimic and put together 'blues' phrases but it doesn't speak on an emotional level. There are players who can perform music with such technical accuracy that they leave me cold, and others who may not be anywhere near technically but they can elicit and emotional reaction. I think music plays many different roles in our lives, in society and in different cultures, everything from 'lift' music, to a film score that enhances the emotional reaction of the audience to the scene being played out on the screen.

Perhaps a musician is someone who appreciates the music and recognises they are communicating something, either from within themselves or someone else's writing's but with their voice - maybe the level of skill or time spent doing it is secondary.

Anyway have a good weekend and enjoy playing your sax, it's a wonderful thing to be able to do.

Chris

Chris

I love music - I love playing it, listening to records/CD/iTunes and especially live. I like what I like from a cappella through female vocals, jazz and heavy rock. No interest in Country though :w00t:

I'm still not sure that you need to communicate with others to be an artist or a musician though I see it makes sense to share ones talents if you have them. As I said earlier, I play music just for me though it was nice to get some positive feedback from a fellow saxophonist who's two mates thought I played well at my one and only proper live performance. My big problem if finding the time to play in a band. I would if I could but it's not likely to happen any time soon.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,333
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom