Weedy Reeds ! What's the best overall strength for tenor reeds

mark_whiteley

Member
Messages
46
I have recently had a tendency to use 2.5 or 3 strength tenor reeds at home for practising, but switch to 2's when doing my very basis jamming with the band, thinking that it will improve my confidence as some notes are clearly easier to get, expecially low 'C' and below.

However, this strategy has proved to be useless, because the sound I am getting from the 2 strength reeds when playing with the band seems to be far less powerful (weedy in fact) compared to the higher strength reeds, and also I believe that the strategy will work against improvements in building up my mouth muscles and embourche.

Any thoughts? Has anyone else tried switching reed strengths to suit different occasions and then deciding it's a bad move?

I'm using Vandoren Jazz reeds, and rarely use anything else.
 
Mark, I've tried changing reeds for exactly the same reasons as yourself, I wanted to play quiet soft melodies so I chose softer reeds. This policy was ok...ish but I found that my tone suffered. Now I'm back to using Vandoran 2.5 which I scrape with a sharp knife first to remove some of the thickness on the outer part of the reed. I can still manage screaming solo's or soft and mellow whenever required.
 
Thanks Taz. I'm going to stick on 2.5 strength for the time being.

Taz wrote:
Mark, I've tried changing reeds for exactly the same reasons as yourself, I wanted to play quiet soft melodies so I chose softer reeds. This policy was ok...ish but I found that my tone suffered. Now I'm back to using Vandoran 2.5 which I scrape with a sharp knife first to remove some of the thickness on the outer part of the reed. I can still manage screaming solo's or soft and mellow whenever required.
[/quote]
 
I like to use the softest reeds that I can get away with, ie so they don't close up when I push them.

Paradoxically I find soft reeds harder to play than hard reeds, you need exceptional diaphragm control to be able to use softish reeds and still get loudness. But a big tip opening helps. I use Rico Jazz select 2M or Vandoren 2.5
 
I play a Lawton 6* piece and use either Rico Jazz Select 2m or Plasticover 2 1/2s

My understanding is that the softer the reed the easier the low notes and the harder the higher notes. And vise versa.
One teacher I had when I asked him what strength reed he thought I should play said 'the hardest you can'.

As your embouchure develops and strengthens you will probably find that you want to use a slightly harder reed or use a wider tip opening. In reality going for a harder reed is going to be a lot cheaper than buying a new mouthpiece.

Essentially you just keep experimenting until you find what suits you.

In the past I've tried swapping reed strength for different occasions but I came to the conclusion that it was counter productive, and the only change I may make is between the RJs and the plasticover, and I rather think that my ratinale for that might not bear close scrutiny.
 
Greywolf wrote:
One teacher I had when I asked him what strength reed he thought I should play said 'the hardest you can'.

Sometimes this is a macho thing. My advice is "the softest you can play well"
 
Pete Thomas wrote:
Greywolf wrote:
One teacher I had when I asked him what strength reed he thought I should play said 'the hardest you can'.

Sometimes this is a macho thing. My advice is "the softest you can play well"

I've found that the hardest reed, macho approach seems to be the default setting for most players and teachers. musical machismo is a strange thing- when Ernie Watts did his masterclass at sax.co.uk he announced he used a 150 thou tip tenor mouthpiece (that's a 12 in Link sizing!) and stength 5 reeds- He sounded amazing with that set up but it's not exactly something that seems feasable for most of us mere mortals to aspire to.
Personally I'm quite happy with Vandoren V16 2.5 or 3s (if I've been gigging a lot)... slight feeling that altissimo screaming is easier to control on harder reeds but aside from that a 2.5 seems to do everything I require of it (if I'm lucky!)
 
Pete Thomas wrote:
I like to use the softest reeds that I can get away with, ie so they don't close up when I push them.

Paradoxically I find soft reeds harder to play than hard reeds, you need exceptional diaphragm control to be able to use softish reeds and still get loudness. But a big tip opening helps. I use Rico Jazz select 2M or Vandoren 2.5

This is the method I use too. I use 3-Soft Rico Jazz Select reeds, I did do a couple of gigs with the 3-Medium and found them to be much more powerful but it gave my sound a more shrill tone.

dan
 
it's what you want at the end of the day, you buy the reeds.
I personally play on a yani metal 7 on all my saxes, sop alt ten and bari, i use alto superials 2 on sop.. 2.5 superials on alto and tenor. rico plasti covers 2 on bari. i have no problem with low or high notes, but then again i have played for over 20 years and have lips of leather.
i used to always play a dukoff d9 on tenor with 2.5 reeds this is a very loud set-up for R&B rock & roll...

blow blow
 
nachoman wrote:
mfox wrote:

i used to always play a dukoff d9 on tenor with 2.5 reeds this is a very loud set-up for R&B rock & roll...
exactly the combo I used for years- works a treat (provisional to having decent monitoiring)

I played Dukoff (D8, X7 or LD10) with LaVoz MH or H. I think Dukoff becomes more stiff/less flexible over years and they get tarnish as well. I tried my oldest Dukoff D8 (from early 80's) the other day and it didn't play well. My new Dukoff D8 is better. That not the case with my Larsen metall. They are still in good shape. I bought a Rovner Deep-V ( #8,40D/ High Baffle) and I'm trying to replace Larsen and Dukoff on tenor. Powerful mpc.
 
I've found that the hardest reed, macho approach seems to be the default setting for most players and teachers. musical machismo is a strange thing- when Ernie Watts did his masterclass at sax.co.uk he announced he used a 150 thou tip tenor mouthpiece (that's a 12 in Link sizing!) and stength 5 reeds- He sounded amazing with that set up but it's not exactly something that seems feasable for most of us mere mortals to aspire to.
Personally I'm quite happy with Vandoren V16 2.5 or 3s (if I've been gigging a lot)... slight feeling that altissimo screaming is easier to control on harder reeds but aside from that a 2.5 seems to do everything I require of it (if I'm lucky!)

It is a wierd thing Nacho...

I kinda suspect I'm not alone in this, but I half expected to wake up one day with a 7* and 5 reed in hand telling someone I couldn't play anything less.

Thankfully sanity prevailed and I still "only" use a C* and 2.5 reed.

Harder reeds for Altissimo performance perhaps, I am happy at 2.5 on Vandorens/RJS.

I remember reading about Eddy "Lockjaw" Davis used to burn the tips of reeds to stiffen them up, I can't remember what tip opening he had on his piece, but would guess its massive like Ernie Watts'.

I used to burn the tips of old reeds to squeeze a bit more use out of them when I started out, but that was because I was poor!

Simon
 
i used to burn the tips when i was a poor student, when the reed got chipped you hold a 2 pence piece againt the reed and burn it down to the coin and the scrape and sand..now i just chuck them life is too short.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,521
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom