Reeds Vandoren reeds, are they stiffer than other brands?

If you want to pick at nits, the characteristic that is measured is stiffness (as measured by deflection of the tip in response to an applied force).
I sometimes say "hardness" when I should say "strength "
I think we (mostly) all use the term hardness incorrectly in regard to reeds. Hardness sort of implies it does not compress, whereas strength more correctly describes its flexibility or more precisely the resistance it offers to being bent either by your lower lip or by the machine which they use to gauge it.

The discrepancy in numbers for the reed strength is as confusing as the discrepancy for numbers given to tip openings.
 
Huuummmm. Just for my own interests... As I see it

The things is, as I see it, we ask the reed to do three things (none of which are vibrate like a tuning fork!)
1/ close the gap swiftly and cleanly when the pressure inside the MP tip falls
2/ open the gap swiftly and cleanly when the pressure is close to / just before maximum
3/ provide an edge to accelerate the airflow

Given that the air pressure is oscillating inside the MP with the tip as a node (means maximum and minimum pressure); the job is to inject a pulse of fast, high pressure air just as the inside pressure is maximum to add driving energy. Too early or too late and you'll distort the oscillation pattern.

For 1, stiffness works against you - and the bigger the MP gap, the more so. But you don't want it closing too soon, so it has to be a bit stiff.
For 2, stiffness works for you. A stiff reed will open quickly and not flap around. But you don't want it to be too stiff otherwise it'll open too early.

Seems to me, reeds are built to be non-linear. To start soft and get stiffer the more they're bent, to arrive at a compromise. They're made of long cellulose fibers which aren't very elastic; but connected across by Lignin so they can slide past each other a bit. Of course that all has to work equally across the width of the reed tip. And water loosens lignin bonds.. and we know how wetting a reed affects things.

The manufacturers "hardnes" measurement measures the integral work required to bend a certain amount... Across these regimes, so can't tell the whole story. So, different shapes of the core / heart really matter... As does everything that defines the profile are pressure oscillations - different MPs, volume, embouchure etc.
 
I think we (mostly) all use the term hardness incorrectly in regard to reeds. Hardness sort of implies it does not compress, whereas strength more correctly describes its flexibility or more precisely the resistance it offers to being bent either by your lower lip or by the machine which they use to gauge it.

Perhaps a better approach is not to use a word that fails to accurately describe mechanical properties.

How ‘bout rating reeds on a scale of “Obstinance”?
 
Huuummmm. Just for my own interests... As I see it

The things is, as I see it, we ask the reed to do three things (none of which are vibrate like a tuning fork!)
1/ close the gap swiftly and cleanly when the pressure inside the MP tip falls
2/ open the gap swiftly and cleanly when the pressure is close to / just before maximum
3/ provide an edge to accelerate the airflow

Given that the air pressure is oscillating inside the MP with the tip as a node (means maximum and minimum pressure); the job is to inject a pulse of fast, high pressure air just as the inside pressure is maximum to add driving energy. Too early or too late and you'll distort the oscillation pattern.

For 1, stiffness works against you - and the bigger the MP gap, the more so. But you don't want it closing too soon, so it has to be a bit stiff.
For 2, stiffness works for you. A stiff reed will open quickly and not flap around. But you don't want it to be too stiff otherwise it'll open too early.

Seems to me, reeds are built to be non-linear. To start soft and get stiffer the more they're bent, to arrive at a compromise. They're made of long cellulose fibers which aren't very elastic; but connected across by Lignin so they can slide past each other a bit. Of course that all has to work equally across the width of the reed tip. And water loosens lignin bonds.. and we know how wetting a reed affects things.

The manufacturers "hardnes" measurement measures the integral work required to bend a certain amount... Across these regimes, so can't tell the whole story. So, different shapes of the core / heart really matter... As does everything that defines the profile are pressure oscillations - different MPs, volume, embouchure etc.
Wow! How can you have all of these thoughts in mind and play?

I just blow and listen to what comes out of the bloody thing .. 😳
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,525
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom