Reeds Vandoren Red Inconsistencies

The cane variety must make a difference.
Are D'Addario grown in USA?
I believe Vandoren are grown in France.

Gonzales are South American and always taste sweet to me.

How long is it between harvesting and machining? I believe there's quite a convoluted drying process in between.

So many stages for discrepencies and flaws to creep in.

Then there's the wholesaler/shop storage. Boxes cooking on shelves won't help.

When problems occur I go back to Vandoren blue for a while.
 
D’Addario has plantations in both France and Argentina. This was actually started by Rico; I think Rico was the first to have a specific cane growing plantation in the Var region. Vandoren followed soon after. The Argentina farm was started by Rico, but fell into disuse, and was revived after D’Addario bought the company.

They don’t say which batches or sub-brands of reeds use French or Argentinian cane. I suspect they mix…. The original idea was to ensure a continuous supply, avoiding seasonal fluctuations.

Rico did try growing cane in California, but they abandoned the attempt after a few years. The cane was not good.
 
Having posted about a box of soprano RJs I just bought 10 tenor #3 Red Javas and I have to say the strength variation is wider than I would expect.
Two are like hard 3.5s, four are like bright 2.5s, four seem like the strength I would expect. So it seems that maybe there is some fluctuation in the qualities of the cane. It happens, I've experienced it with most brands, but with D'Addarios more recently. Although why, with modern grading machines, is another matter.
I'm going to go through the same process with these tenor Java Reds as I did with the sopranos, so I'll post back in a few weeks and let you all know how it went.
 
In 50 or so years of playing I've never experienced any consistency throughout any reeds straight out of the box
However I recently bought a box or Vandoren Red Java soprano reeds and went through the breakin process described in this video: at the end of 3 weeks I can happily play every reed from that box of 10.
Tedious? Yes. Great results? Yes.
My take is that to achieve a really consistently good result one has to submit to a proper break-in process, which is not exactly a new idea, but one I have until now sadly ignored!
That's incredibly interesting, thanks for that link. It rings true for me regarding break in periods. Between break in and flattening with a lathe mini bit, and clipping most of them a mm or two once they break in enough, I get maybe 4 good to very useable reeds out of 5 consistently. But maybe only 1 in a box will be great. I keep 20 or so reeds somewhere in the break-in process all the time.

I could hear a difference between the ones he thought were too stiff (he said airy), and the ones that he thought were too soft (he said fuzzy), but barely. All the ones in the middle sounded great to me. I figure his feedback on them is about how they PLAY. His remarks about reed strengths rings true with me too. Striking a balance between reeds that respond well in the ranges I want/need with a tone that speaks at desired volumes is my personal challenge, new ones are often not loud enough for me, even though the tone is consistent. A lousy reed magically turning good after a couple of sessions resonates with me also.

When I open a new box I'm usually like, darn it, I have to deal with another new box. The video will help me reconcile that as SOP, that's just the way it is. I'll be doing it the Marcellus way for awhile, I won't have to change much to do it. Thanks!
 
All cane is variable. “Strength” is determined with just a simple deflection tester, after the reed is made. A 3 is always somewhere between a 2.5 and 3.5, so a wide range is to be expected.

Also, cane can easily vary in flexibility within a single reed. This is why I balance every reed so that the flexibility is the same side to side. This also gives me the opportunity to adjust the strength if the reed is too hard. Just a few minutes per reed lets me play 95% of the reeds in the box.
How do you "balance" a reed? 🤔
I know,... I'm hopeless 🙄😂🤗
 
Talking of reeds, did you try the Alexander NY?
They arrived in the post Friday ☺️ got a box of five in black Friday sale from Sax. Co 😁
I've literally just finished practising for the last hour but still using my blue box vandoren 2.5 so I was planning on trying one out tomorrow evening ☺️ I'm excited about it actually.
Wanted to look at and drool over a full new tin of reeds a little longer 😳😂😂 sad I know 😂😘
 
They arrived in the post Friday ☺️ got a box of five in black Friday sale from Sax. Co 😁
I've literally just finished practising for the last hour but still using my blue box vandoren 2.5 so I was planning on trying one out tomorrow evening ☺️ I'm excited about it actually.
Wanted to look at and drool over a full new tin of reeds a little longer 😳😂😂 sad I know 😂😘
The packaging is much prettier than others.
 
How do you "balance" a reed? 🤔
I know,... I'm hopeless 🙄😂🤗
I do this on the mouthpiece and neck alone. Start by putting the mouthpiece on the neck. Then…
  • Take a reed out of the box, soak it and optionally flatten the back (using a reed geek or lathe bit). Put it on the mouthpiece.
  • Play the reed in the normal way, a medium loud note for 4-6 seconds. A “long-ish’ tone…. Play loud to soft, so you can judge the overall response of the reed.
  • Tilt the mouthpiece in your mouth so that one side is jammed against your lower lip. Play the same tone.
  • Tilt it the other way and play again.
  • Note which side is harder or stuffier and sand that side of the reed until the two sides play the same way.
Couple of points:
  • The side that is NOT jammed against your lower lip is the side you are playing.
  • If both sides are too hard, sand them both, but make sure they are responding the same.
  • If the reed is too hard, most of this is due to the area along the side (the “rails”).
  • If it’s the right strength, but dull or stuffy, the area in the tip on that side needs some work.

Where to sand? See below:
ReedAdjustment-small.webp

Only sand in the triangle areas.
 
@skeller047 brilliant! Thank you and I'm glad you added the diagram too as I wouldn't have really known where to sand if needed 😁👍👍👍😘
It’s more important to know where NOT to sand…. the heart of the reed being the critical area. Sand there and it’s like termination with prejudice.

Go slow the first few times you do this until you learn to judge what’s what. That is, a few strokes and re-test.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,717
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom