Saxophone beginners Up and down?

cappers

Senior Member
Messages
1,517
Location
Sussex, UK
Been practicing ~1-1.5 hours daily since the beginning of January (YAS-25, 4C mpc, Rico Royale 2.5). Enjoying it very much and coming along very well according to my teacher. (1 hr per week, now on 2 week break).

What is frustrating is that I have days where it all seems to flow then others where I feel and sound like it's my first go on the horn. One day I can't follow the dots or find the correct fingerings, the next I can but I squeak like a rusty door, another day I can't remember the phrase I thought I'd memorised, or remember the scales yet another day it all clicks. Today was the latter after a few days of wondering if I should have taken up the kazoo.

Is it normal or me?
TIA
 
Sounds pretty familiar. I'm not a neuroscientist but my understanding is your brain is taking in a lot of stuff and having to process it. Sometimes it's got other stuff to do, it falls behind and then it/you can't recall something. I find the "pomodoro" approach helpful to avoid overload. Practice 25 minutes, then rest for 5 minutes. I do a puzzle or read a book in the "rest" period. "Pomodoro" because the inventor had a timer that looked like a tomato.
 
Sooner or later someone is going to ask you what you’re covering in that 60 - 90 minutes per day (actually it’s me asking now..).

Agree with post above about the amount of processing the brain has to do, and for the “basics” not to fall over, that is where your focus is best aimed, so that they function with less conscious thought.

It’s entirely normal to have “off days “, but take a look at your practice regime in case it can be tightened up.
 
Sooner or later someone is going to ask you what you’re covering in that 60 - 90 minutes per day (actually it’s me asking now..).
.......

It’s entirely normal to have “off days “, but take a look at your practice regime in case it can be tightened up.
I start off with scales I know so far - C (2 octaves), G, F, E minor (natural, melodic and harmonic), do those slowly until I can go up and down each without error; ditto the arpeggios.

Then long tones - 'Pivot around C' exercise which I have found very helpful for breath control and tone.

Followed by working through the songs in the learners' book (Abracadabra for Sax) set by my teacher, maybe supplemented with some from O'Neill's Jazz Method which is more to my liking. Both of course helping my sight reading etc.

Usually try to play a few simple tunes I want to learn e.g. Fly Me To The Moon, Can't Help Falling in Love, Isn't She Lovely, Misty. One each day, phrase at a time slowly; it might all gel eventually.

If not too tired or over my agreed 'limit' (neighbourly considerations) I might just noodle around, sounding the notes, trying to improvise, seeing what sounds good/right next.

Usually finish by redoing the scales.

Any suggestions appreciated.
 
take a look at your practice regime in case it can be tightened up.

I think this is a great point. After a year and a half of practicing I now can see things that I was doing that probably weren't productive. For example, scales. I've probably gone through three or four ways of practicing scales, I finally hit upon a method that I think is working well but I could have just started it this way from the beginning.

On the other hand, I guess approaching things from different angles is also probably good. So I guess the answer is, keep practicing 😀
 
I think this is a great point. After a year and a half of practicing I now can see things that I was doing that probably weren't productive. For example, scales. I've probably gone through three or four ways of practicing scales, I finally hit upon a method that I think is working well but I could have just started it this way from the beginning.

On the other hand, I guess approaching things from different angles is also probably good. So I guess the answer is, keep practicing 😀
I actually enjoy doing scales :rolleyes: I might vary them by doing C CD D DE E etc or CDE DEF EFG.......or bop style as suggested by my teacher.

I do like the harmonic minors with that oriental sounding 5-6-7#-1-7#-6-5
 
Usually try to play a few simple tunes I want to learn e.g. Fly Me To The Moon, Can't Help Falling in Love, Isn't She Lovely, Misty. One each day, phrase at a time slowly; it might all gel eventually.
I think sticking to a single tune would be more productive than trying a tune a day. Maybe a song a week, or longer - as long as it takes to be able to play a song before moving on to the next one.
 
I think sticking to a single tune would be more productive than trying a tune a day. Maybe a song a week, or longer - as long as it takes to be able to play a song before moving on to the next one.
If I could add - from my experience and everyone is different - I found memorising a tune and playing with the metronome (and/or backing track) excruciatingly hard when I started. But both are important; and acquirable skills, with practice... good for developing the music brain.
 
Scheduled a least a day off each week and
think about something other than saxophones.

Have you considered breaking up your practice time? Maybe in four 15 minutes durations?
For each practice session focusing on one or two aspects of playing.
Thank you @Gendreau1
I might consider a day off but the urge to pick it up and play every day is strong.
Personally it takes me about about 10min to loosen up and get into things; perhaps two 1/2 hour sessions would be more productive. I do try and make each practice worthwhile i.e. concentrate on my sound, really listen to the notes etc.

I think sticking to a single tune would be more productive than trying a tune a day. Maybe a song a week, or longer - as long as it takes to be able to play a song before moving on to the next one.
Thanks @atwl77
I realised yesterday that concentrating on one tune and getting that down correctly is better than attempting several tunes badly! Otherwise I'll end up with a collection of snippets but nothing solid.

Really enjoying the journey despite the ups and downs!
Thanks to all for the advice and support.
 
"I realised yesterday that concentrating on one tune and getting that down correctly is better than attempting several tunes badly"

The above demonstrates, why a course of study, outlined by a competent music teacher, with weekly lessons, to evaluate the progress, then giving instructions for the following week, is important, if learning to play properly, in tune, is your goal.
Daily practice is best.
Composition and improvisation, are separate studies.
 
The above demonstrates, why a course of study, outlined by a competent music teacher, with weekly lessons, to evaluate the progress, then giving instructions for the following week, is important,
Had my first one-to-one lesson on Monday.

Which demonstrates that working things out oneself is important. Teacher or not - own your own development.
 
"I realised yesterday that concentrating on one tune and getting that down correctly is better than attempting several tunes badly"

The above demonstrates, why a course of study, outlined by a competent music teacher, with weekly lessons, to evaluate the progress, then giving instructions for the following week, is important, if learning to play properly, in tune, is your goal.
Daily practice is best.
Composition and improvisation, are separate studies.
Fortunately I have a very good teacher with weekly sessions, six since beginning of January.
I follow his advice including working through Abracadabra for Sax, not my ideal but it does have a logical step-by-step approach even if some of the tunes aren't what I want to play. He encourages me to 'play around' and practice songs I like once I have done my scales, long tones and exercises.
 
Which demonstrates that working things out oneself is important. Teacher or not - own your own development.
As I mentioned above, one of the songs I'm trying to learn is Can't Help Falling In Love.
Two reasons, 1. I like it, and 2. a while back I was just playing around, going up and down trying different notes. I went GDG ABC BA and recognised it and stumbled to DEF G ABC BAG after singing it. Later found a full song notation on youtube and changed the F to F# etc.

Today I did most of it from my head, far from perfect but recognisable, so I am happy. A month ago I hardly knew which end to blow down!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,402
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom