Sorry Tom, took me a little while to respond, just had a little man in washing the lawn.Taz, its great that your earlier success has not gone to your head! Good advice about "...keep walking..." especially as Dave doesn't drive!;}
Kind regards
Tom😎
Sorry Tom, took me a little while to respond, just had a little man in washing the lawn.Taz, its great that your earlier success has not gone to your head! Good advice about "...keep walking..." especially as Dave doesn't drive!;}
Kind regards
Tom😎
Another point: all this talk about a wider tip opening often being no harder to play than a narrow one is no reason for encouraging a beginner to try it out. It is in some way akin to chronic speedsters who argue that going faster will get them quickly out of troublespots.
Frankly, this discussion is a bit unreal. Dave is a keen beginner engaged in coping with the basics. He should be encouraged to stick with the Yamaha 4C for some time to come, and gradually change from real beginner to advancing beginner.
I have heard many good things about the Rascher mouthpiece, but I have yet to hear anyone say that it is particularly useful for beginners, especially when combined with a Yamaha 4C.
It may well be that the Rascher is the better mouthpiece for David, but give his teacher credit for being able to work this out.
Another point: all this talk about a wider tip opening often being no harder to play than a narrow one is no reason for encouraging a beginner to try it out. It is in some way akin to chronic speedsters who argue that going faster will get them quickly out of troublespots.
I started on a Yammie 6 and now use a PPT 9 and an RPC 105.
Now realise that I must go back and start again on a 4.
Dave, play what you've got and do what you want, unlike me, you will learn what is right and wrong for you and there's the problem, we are all different, which is something some teachers should remember.
:shocked:;}Good grief! Lighten up for gawd's sake.
The OP has got a new mouthpiece that he likes the sound of. All of you that throw your hands up in horror at this heinous act need to ask yourselves, "If I think I sound good, does that encourage my playing or make me think I'm cheating in some way?". If you're of the hair-shirt persuasion then perhaps sounding crap is what you want do just so you have the greatest opportunity to improve it. I buy a mouthpiece because I like the sound it gives me, and because I like the sound I think I play better. I don't see why I should deny my students the same pleasure. They can learn to play on whatever mouthpiece they damn well like.
Although I might advise against a different one every week. ;}
Every time I see the title of this thread I think, "Take two mouthpieces into the shower?..."
Again, just my opinion but one I know others on the forum share is that they key to improving your sound is being able to hear/visualise what you want your sound to be like.
You can't IMHO achieve that just by swapping mps.
This thread's starting to sound like SOTW.

Hi Dave!
SOTW = Sax On The Web, one of a number of US based discussion forums which can, at times, present as a little intolerant of others' views, and be a little bit scathing towards beginners' posts..........................:shocked:;}
Kind regards
Tom😎
Beware of the Sax Police!![]()
