Saxophone beginners Two mouthpieces? Or stick to one?

Taz, its great that your earlier success has not gone to your head! Good advice about "...keep walking..." especially as Dave doesn't drive!;}

Kind regards
Tom😎
Sorry Tom, took me a little while to respond, just had a little man in washing the lawn.
 
A sage old chap (formerly of Syd Lawrence's sax section) once told me, and I paraphrase;
"Horses for courses, lad". I was grumbling that the mouthpiece I used for everything (Link STM) was great, but after doing a 'pop' show I was knackered physically! He said I should get a 'pop' mouthpiece, I did, and suddenly I can get the tone I want without supreme effort. I still swap and change, using the STM for big band and jazz playing, and my Dukoff for the weightier stuff.

By comparison when I bought my bari mouthpiece (silver Yani, cost a fortune) I could do everything I wanted on it, and I spent an hour or so in the shop making sure of that before I bought it. I'm not sure three minutes really gives you the full picture, but if you were happy after that time that's a good sign.

Another helpful study might be a trumpeter friend of mine who keeps chasing a 'sound', and chopping and changing mouthpiece or horn every few months. None of this really changes the way he sounds to us when he plays (though he claims to hear a difference) - all it means is that he doesn't really learn to use the setup he has.

What I'm trying to say is, it's probably best to learn your stuff on a 'standard' middle of the road mouthpiece, then specialise when you know how you want to specialise. If you think you're at this stage, and the Brancher gives you the sound you want, then that's great.

To any other readers thinking about how maybe they should change mouthpieces - you only need to change if there's something you can't achieve by practice. If it ain't broke, don't try to fix it.

Cheers,

Nick
 
Frankly, this discussion is a bit unreal. Dave is a keen beginner engaged in coping with the basics. He should be encouraged to stick with the Yamaha 4C for some time to come, and gradually change from real beginner to advancing beginner.

I have heard many good things about the Rascher mouthpiece, but I have yet to hear anyone say that it is particularly useful for beginners, especially when combined with a Yamaha 4C.

It may well be that the Rascher is the better mouthpiece for David, but give his teacher credit for being able to work this out.

Another point: all this talk about a wider tip opening often being no harder to play than a narrow one is no reason for encouraging a beginner to try it out. It is in some way akin to chronic speedsters who argue that going faster will get them quickly out of troublespots.
 
Another point: all this talk about a wider tip opening often being no harder to play than a narrow one is no reason for encouraging a beginner to try it out. It is in some way akin to chronic speedsters who argue that going faster will get them quickly out of troublespots.

Why not? It's all part of the fun, won't do any harm. And - he's already got both mouthpieces, it's not as if we're encouraging more spending.
 
Frankly, this discussion is a bit unreal. Dave is a keen beginner engaged in coping with the basics. He should be encouraged to stick with the Yamaha 4C for some time to come, and gradually change from real beginner to advancing beginner.

I have heard many good things about the Rascher mouthpiece, but I have yet to hear anyone say that it is particularly useful for beginners, especially when combined with a Yamaha 4C.

It may well be that the Rascher is the better mouthpiece for David, but give his teacher credit for being able to work this out.

Another point: all this talk about a wider tip opening often being no harder to play than a narrow one is no reason for encouraging a beginner to try it out. It is in some way akin to chronic speedsters who argue that going faster will get them quickly out of troublespots.

Couldn't agree more. A saxophone is one of the easiest instruments to get a reasonably sounding note out of yet its a bugg@ to master and one of the biggest challenges is producing and maintaining a good tone - who wants to sound different every time they pick a sax up and then there's managing/balancing the sound across the registers, dealing with the harshness of C2 and C#2, the stuffiness of D2 and Eb2, then there's anything below D1 for yet another challenge, not to mention the above B3 and those damn palm keys. What about playing in tune across all registers, bending notes etc etc.

And that's all before we start looking at the technical side of playing.

It seems to me to be crazy to start experimenting with mps too soon. So don't make it any harder for yourself. Stick with one until you have developed your embouchure. You'll inevitably find you need a slightly harder reed as you progress and there will come a time when you'll want to start experimenting with mps to get the tone you really want. It's a slippery slope and yu'll end up with 10 mps if you aren't careful.

FWIW I just use one mp and have been using it for all the time I have been on tenor, almost 2 years. I experimented a bit with reeds initially but stuck with one make until a couple of months ago when I went to a synthetic Legere Signature reed. I'll not be changing that it a hurry either.

I played alto for just over a year before switching and I have maybe 6 mps and used 5 or 6 varieties of reeds. It didn't help me get the sound I wanted and in any case I ended up sticking with a 'Link 6* Tone Edge ebonite 90% of the time in the end.

My teacher who is a top jazz saxophonist tells me my tone is great and stable/consistent but improving all the time and I've managed that by good practice regimes and using my ears not by switching mps. I do appreciate some of you experienced musos who perform live need to be able to create different sounds and therefore swap mps as they need to but not us beginners - yep I still class myself as a beginner really.
 
I started on a Yammie 6 and now use a PPT 9 and an RPC 105.

Now realise that I must go back and start again on a 4.

Dave, play what you've got and do what you want, unlike me, you will learn what is right and wrong for you and there's the problem, we are all different, which is something some teachers should remember.

I know nothing about your case, and I was not discussing it. Up to you to decide whether you should use a Yamaha 4C. Lots of players much better than myself use it.
 
Good grief! Lighten up for gawd's sake.

The OP has got a new mouthpiece that he likes the sound of. All of you that throw your hands up in horror at this heinous act need to ask yourselves, "If I think I sound good, does that encourage my playing or make me think I'm cheating in some way?". If you're of the hair-shirt persuasion then perhaps sounding crap is what you want do just so you have the greatest opportunity to improve it. I buy a mouthpiece because I like the sound it gives me, and because I like the sound I think I play better. I don't see why I should deny my students the same pleasure. They can learn to play on whatever mouthpiece they damn well like.

Although I might advise against a different one every week. ;}

Every time I see the title of this thread I think, "Take two mouthpieces into the shower?..."
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Good grief! Lighten up for gawd's sake.

The OP has got a new mouthpiece that he likes the sound of. All of you that throw your hands up in horror at this heinous act need to ask yourselves, "If I think I sound good, does that encourage my playing or make me think I'm cheating in some way?". If you're of the hair-shirt persuasion then perhaps sounding crap is what you want do just so you have the greatest opportunity to improve it. I buy a mouthpiece because I like the sound it gives me, and because I like the sound I think I play better. I don't see why I should deny my students the same pleasure. They can learn to play on whatever mouthpiece they damn well like.

Although I might advise against a different one every week. ;}

Every time I see the title of this thread I think, "Take two mouthpieces into the shower?..."

I don't think anyone is suggesting 'cheating' and of course we are all different and we all have our own opinions, some informed, some less so. But that's it really isn't it...... we all have our own opinions and by asking a question on the forum, you might expect people when they reply to voice their opinion.

My recommendation, if I may be so bold would be to read someone's opinions/comments and make one's own decision as to the merit of any such post. My teacher has advised me against chopping and changing but that's just her opinion of course as well. Mind you I do trust her judgement when it comes to my playing. For those that don't already know, like the hunt and davhudson on here, my teacher is Karen Sharp.

Again, just my opinion but one I know others on the forum share is that they key to improving your sound is being able to hear/visualise what you want your sound to be like. You can't IMHO achieve that just by swapping mps.
 
Again, just my opinion but one I know others on the forum share is that they key to improving your sound is being able to hear/visualise what you want your sound to be like.

Yes, of course.

You can't IMHO achieve that just by swapping mps.

I can and my students can get closer by an appropriate choice of mouthpiece. And 'appropriate' is in the ear of the player. I can suggest to them that playing Bach cello suites on a Runyon Quantum 16 (I have been known to do this) may not give the sound that most people expect to hear and it may make the quiet low notes difficult to play. But, if they want to do that, why should I stop them? Or perhaps, if they really want to play load honky rock and roll and all they've got is a Yamaha 4C they might be a bit disappointed in the lack of oomph. The fact that I could do it (although I'd hate to) is neither here nor there - I've been at it nearly 40 years, they haven't. If they're not happy with the sound then they're going to practice less and progress more slowly. A decent noisy mouthpiece could get them closer to their goal and put a smile on their face. You don't have to practice on a crap mouthpiece to get good.
 
Hi HD!

Several good points, particularly about chopping and changing mouthpieces and the negative effect it can have on development. For me the biggest problem is getting the start right so that you find the right mouthpiece to kick off with - and the effect that it can have on sound, tone and motivation.

When I started trumpet the biggest recommendation was to start on a Vincent Bach 7C mouthpiece (16.3mm - trumpet mouthpiece size goes in reverse order compared to sax mouthpieces - from 15 up to size 1 usually). This I duly did, but just happen to buy a VB 1 1/2C (17.0mm) on eBay, and suddenly my whole sound opened up, higher and lower notes were suddenly possible and the sound was much more akin to what I wanted - I now play a 17.4mm mouthpiece (in sax terms nearer a 9*) so just want to challenge some assumptions about what size is best to start on, especially for adult learners. In an ideal world it might be better for beginners to have 2 or 3 pieces and choose the one they want to learn on, especially as this can detect any problems related to size, which may not be initially obvious.

Again, just a subjective viewpoint but I am a little wary of unquestioned assumptions in many areas, not just music.
Kind regards
Tom😎
 
So I asked for people's opinions about using more than mouthpiece at a time, not literally, and what I have is a long, though not uninformative, discussion about the nature of the mouthpieces I am using. It was already mentioned, I have two mouthpieces now. They are both bought and paid for, the discussion should not be on the rights and wrongs of which mouthpiece I am using.

What I am learning, and I appreciate we all learn differently, is that different mouthpieces can produce different sounds. I am listening to lots of sax music, and I am starting to hear two different sounds that I play, albeit only slightly. In time I expect I will start to prefer a certain sound and wish to emulate that. For now I enjoy playing/ learning/experimenting and acquiring an ear for what I am doing. My biggest teachers are the noises I make, and the people/responses on here.

I don't know what SOTW is and it doesn't sound good, so sorry if I have brought up bad vibes, but please do refer back to original question I posted.
 
Hi Dave!

SOTW = Sax On The Web, one of a number of US based discussion forums which can, at times, present as a little intolerant of others' views, and be a little bit scathing towards beginners' posts..........................:shocked:;}

Kind regards
Tom😎

Beware of the Sax Police!:w00t:
 
Hi Dave!

SOTW = Sax On The Web, one of a number of US based discussion forums which can, at times, present as a little intolerant of others' views, and be a little bit scathing towards beginners' posts..........................:shocked:;}

Kind regards
Tom😎

Beware of the Sax Police!:w00t:



A masterpiece of understatement....

Actually it's not all bad there - far from it, but when things do degenerate it's loud and ugly, something we don't stoop to here.



And a really diplomatic reply from Dave! :welldone
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,512
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom