Intonation Tuning woes!

Helen G

New Member
Messages
4
Location
Kent
Hello! I’m new to this forum and the the alto sax - after years of playing the clarinet pretty well, I’ve finally taken it up! I’m tuned ok, but even so, some notes I play sound really sharp or flat particularly in between registers. Is this normal? An emboucher thing, a quality/type of sax thing, just more practice needed? I’ve a Meyer mouthpiece, 2.5 reeds, vivace sax. I’m usually good at pitch and totality so this is really bugging me. Help and advice welcome.
 
Hello and welcome. Some more qualified will be along I’m sure.... but a few things...
Sax tuning can be tricky. Embouchure on sax is not the same as clarinet; mouthpiece position/angle in the mouth is also different. Some saxes require more adjustment as you play than others.
 
Hi @Helen G and welcome! I too am relatively new to the saxophone. I started on clarinet, played for a few months and then let about 60 years go by before picking up an alto. I believe the embouchure makes some adjustments on notes automatically, but someone more experienced will chime in soon. However, I have a question that will enlighten everyone.
Do you have a tuner that shows how for out of tune a note is in cents? It will definitely confirm what you're hearing and show how out the note is.
 
Right. I'm saying use it to see if individual notes are out of tune. I have two completely different ones and they agree to the cent.
 
Right. I'm saying use it to see if individual notes are out of tune. I have two completely different ones and they agree to the cent.
I don’t want to go down the temperament rabbit hole: i’ll just say that if tuner is set to ‘equal temperament’ it will not necessarily be ‘in tune’

@jbtsax has posted useful stuff on tuning - some very recently if you have a search @Helen G
 
@tenorviol yes, you are correct, but the relative difference is still visible. To my mind, that makes a difference, especially if she is hearing it playing solo voce. Or maybe you mean that you shouldn't want to be in tune, tempered? To Each His Zone, anyway 😛
 
Hello! I’m new to this forum and the the alto sax - after years of playing the clarinet pretty well, I’ve finally taken it up! I’m tuned ok, but even so, some notes I play sound really sharp or flat particularly in between registers. Is this normal? An emboucher thing, a quality/type of sax thing, just more practice needed? I’ve a Meyer mouthpiece, 2.5 reeds, vivace sax. I’m usually good at pitch and totality so this is really bugging me. Help and advice welcome.


For a clarinet player starting out, that's normal. On clarinet you set your embouchure pretty close to as sharp as it will go. Saxophone should be more in the middle. I found it quite disconcerting at first, like I'd nothing to lock on to. If you play like a clarinet and tune concert A (alto F#), your mouthpiece will be pulled out too far out, long tube notes will be flat, short tube notes sharp and you'll probably have wide octaves. Does that match what you're experiencing?

@jbtsax will probably be along soon to tell you what note a mouthpiece alone should play. I can't remember what it is but doing that will give you an idea of where your embouchure should be set.
 
Yes, this is the typical tale I have heard/read from clarinet players. Simply stated - if you are playing Sax with a Clarinet embouchure, there oftentimes will be both intonation and tonality issues.

Not a bad idea to have an Alto player play your horn to a tuner and see if he/she can play it without the issues you describe....just to cross of 'horn' as a possible issue.
 
On alto sax the pitch on the mouthpiece alone should be no higher than A = 880. The pitch on the mouthpiece + neck with the mouthpiece where you normally tune should be an Ab concert.

Be sure the mouthpiece goes straight into the mouth and not down at an angle like the clarinet.

I like to tune the sax to low F# (A concert) and then check the octave above both with and without the octave key. Then I finger low B natural and overblow to the 2nd harmonic which is F#2. When those three F#'s are in tune, the length of the saxophone is set correctly. From that point on additional "humoring" of the pitch to be in tune is done with slight changes in the embouchure and "voicing" inside the oral cavity.

Be aware that the saxophone basically uses the same embouchure from low Bb up to high F. Tightening for the high notes and loosening for the low notes simply exacerbates the intonation tendencies of the instrument to begin with.
 
For a clarinet player starting out, that's normal. On clarinet you set your embouchure pretty close to as sharp as it will go. Saxophone should be more in the middle. I found it quite disconcerting at first, like I'd nothing to lock on to. If you play like a clarinet and tune concert A (alto F#), your mouthpiece will be pulled out too far out, long tube notes will be flat, short tube notes sharp and you'll probably have wide octaves. Does that match what you're experiencing?

@jbtsax will probably be along soon to tell you what note a mouthpiece alone should play. I can't remember what it is but doing that will give you an idea of where your embouchure should be set.
Yes, that feels like my experience, thanks so much for your helpful reply.
 
On alto sax the pitch on the mouthpiece alone should be no higher than A = 880. The pitch on the mouthpiece + neck with the mouthpiece where you normally tune should be an Ab concert.

Be sure the mouthpiece goes straight into the mouth and not down at an angle like the clarinet.

I like to tune the sax to low F# (A concert) and then check the octave above both with and without the octave key. Then I finger low B natural and overblow to the 2nd harmonic which is F#2. When those three F#'s are in tune, the length of the saxophone is set correctly. From that point on additional "humoring" of the pitch to be in tune is done with slight changes in the embouchure and "voicing" inside the oral cavity.

Be aware that the saxophone basically uses the same embouchure from low Bb up to high F. Tightening for the high notes and loosening for the low notes simply exacerbates the intonation tendencies of the instrument to begin with.
Great advice and insight, lots for me to try here. Thanks, much appreciated!
 
Hi @Helen G and welcome! I too am relatively new to the saxophone. I started on clarinet, played for a few months and then let about 60 years go by before picking up an alto. I believe the embouchure makes some adjustments on notes automatically, but someone more experienced will chime in soon. However, I have a question that will enlighten everyone.
Do you have a tuner that shows how for out of tune a note is in cents? It will definitely confirm what you're hearing and show how out the note is.
Yes, The PiaScore tuner app has helped me understand what’s going on more. Especially where f4 has sounded v sharp and then e4 sounds flat so playing these after each other can sound really naff!
 
I Iike to tune the sax to low F# (A concert) and then check the octave above both with and without the octave key. Then I finger low B natural and overblow to the 2nd harmonic which is F#2. When those three F#'s are in tune, the length of the saxophone is set correctly. From that point on additional "humoring" of the pitch to be in tune is done with slight changes in the embouchure and "voicing" inside the oral cavity.
Yes, that is a great way to make the instrument in tune with itself. I often tune to F#2, and then listen how the B1/B2 and F#1/F#2 intervals sound to me.
Be aware that the saxophone basically uses the same embouchure from low Bb up to high F. Tightening for the high notes and loosening for the low notes simply exacerbates the intonation tendencies of the instrument to begin with.
But that is true for clarinet as well. The embouchure for the low and high notes should be firm, but open (no biting!). What changes is the tongue position, so the way you direct the air stream.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,384
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom