Throat Tonguing

ogulkoker

New Member
Messages
1
I made a short video to show my neck:

http://www.metacafe.com/watch/1921749/am_i_doin_throat_tonguin/

Everybody says I do that throat tonguing thing and that is a bad thing. But I can't solve this problem, I read and tried everything to get rid of it. Any ideas?
 
i don't see a problem.. what ever works for you.. im sure eventually you will either carry on or move to standard tounging..but you sound good and if your enjoying it then blow man blow.
 
As Mr fox says
If it suits you go for it,but remember the way that it is taught by some teachers
The throat should remain open as if swallowing a hot potatoe
The breath comes from below the chest some call it diaphramatic breathing,
Exhale as if trying to steam up a mirror
And stop the reed (sound) with the tip of the tongue
rgds.
Clive
 
It may work right now, but, if you stick with playing, you will eventually run into a piece of music which will require you to articulate faster that your throat can move.

There are two main methods for articulation (playing each note separately i.e. NOT slurring) which require the tongue to momentarily stop the reed from vibrating.

One method (which I use for double and triple tonguing i.e. "tigida tigida tigida") requires the use of the tip of your tongue. This method makes your tongue get in the way of your air flow too much IMHO, and therefore I do not use it normally.

The second method which I do use is called "anchor tonguing" which is done by anchoring the tip of your tongue at the base of your bottom teeth, and using the "middle" of your tongue to stop the reed when articulating rapid single notes. I feel it keeps your air moving through the horn better and keeps your tongue out of the way.

The longer you enforce poor techniques and methods, the much more difficult it will be to break these habits down the road...

Remember, practice does NOT make perfect... Perfect practice does.

😉
 
TommyD69 wrote:

One method (which I use for double and triple tonguing i.e. "tigida tigida tigida") requires the use of the tip of your tongue. This method makes your tongue get in the way of your air flow too much IMHO, and therefore I do not use it normally.

Hi Tom,

Is your triple tongue similar to "Double tongue on flute - tuk ku tuk"? Am i right to say that your "gi" is from your throat not your tongue?
 
You Will need the open throat and the quicker tonguing as you advance to faster passages. Whilst it sound fine now you will restrict your advance later. Its better to practice correctly than hours and hours of frustration correcting problems that could have been avoided.
 
From one Tommy to another... the "gi" is not from the throat.

The "tigida" when pronounced gives you an idea of the articulation (the way your tongue rubs against the roof of your mouth) but not the technique.

With the sax, the mouthpiece protrudes into your mouth, while obviously on the flute, you have nothing to flick your tongue on.

The "tig" "i" "da" (pronounced with a SHORT i...) is the movement you want for your tongue as you flick the tip of your tongue "UPWARDS AND DOWNWARDS" across the very tip of the reed and mouthpiece. There is no throat involved at all, just the flicking of the tongue.

Hope I explained it better this time..... Good Luck....

🙂
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom