Theory & Impro theoretical question

Is that all :w00t: I'd rather get a record contract where they give me a few million pounds in advance >:) Then fund my latest pop album consisting of just three chords, terrible vocals and to be proclaimed as the best album ever!

You need some drum-machinery and a huge compressor to produce such an album.
 
Right!
Shame for centuries of wonderful printed music that would become useless.

I have the strange feeling that we are trying to avoid one unpleasant issue:

We are supposed to be able to transpose by sight (reasonably).

Reading a part for Eb alto with an Eb alto is still the most comfortable way of doing it. No question, whatever the reason is.
If you are not just a reader you need to communicate with other musicians, and concert key becomes quite helpful.

If you find a part for F sopranino sax, you must know that such an instrument does not exist, so you pick up your soprano and read the part transposing a fifth up. (This example is not made up, it really happened for the first performance of Ravel's Bolero).

If you play with a female singer, she will ask you to transpose every single day. In any direction.

And about reading a C score... tenor saxophone is supposed to read in bass clef, while soprano in treble clef: not really an improvement....

Common practice wins: saxophones are transposing instruments.
If you want to be a musician, de-transposing is not enough: you must be able to transpose in any key. This is beneficial to your music.

or you have to play along with a french horn in a concert band..
 
Of course if you have an "Apogee" system like my vintage Buffet soprano pictured below, you have the option of alternating between the L.H. pinky and the middle finger of the right hand (kind of like the clarinet).

Cool! I've never heard of this system before.
I'm just beginning clarinet and at first the vast array of alternate fingerings and trill keys is bewildering and frustrating but now almost 2 weeks in and I'm loving the flexibility.

I pick up my sax now and my fingers are bored! 😀
 
or you have to play along with a french horn in a concert band..

Yes, I hadn't realised until recently what a tough time horn players have :shocked: Because historically you plugged in a crook for whatever key you were playing, all horn parts until mid C19th are in C..... so a modern player reading say Beethoven has to transpose at sight...
 
Yes, I hadn't realised until recently what a tough time horn players have :shocked: Because historically you plugged in a crook for whatever key you were playing, all horn parts until mid C19th are in C..... so a modern player reading say Beethoven has to transpose at sight...
There are a lot of C clarinet parts from that period, too.
 
That's easy, get a C clarinet, but I realise this doesn't help.
Not really. They don't quite sound the same, and you'd have to have to get used to the intonation issues etc of a 3rd instrument (assuming you already have an A as well as a Bb). Easier to learn to transpose (up a tone for the flat keys, up a minor third for the sharp ones).

I've been out of classical music for 20-odd years now, so I don't know what's going on, but you'd think it wouldn't be too hard for music publishers to keep scores in digital form now (especially for often-performed stuff like Beethoven) so you could print parts for whatever flavour of clarinet you wanted.
 
you'd think it wouldn't be too hard for music publishers to keep scores in digital form now (especially for often-performed stuff like Beethoven) so you could print parts for whatever flavour of clarinet you wanted.

And share them on the internet for free!
 
OK, maybe not. but they could store them electronically in-house and sell/rent the printed versions.

I was joking... Unfortunately technology and copyright are quite in contrast nowadays. If you think that Mozart worked as a copyist when he was broke, and now you can have a whole big band chart for $20...
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom