Theory & Impro theoretical question

LOL...you don't need a C-Mel - play a note on you Alto (or Tenor) ask your guitar player to name that note and adopt that instead of the transposed one (then buy scores written in C not transposed in Eb or Bb) - transposition is a bad framework inside your mind (like a parasite)...get rid of that and kick away with outdated conventions for good...your scientific background is well suited for make such a bold move.
Check a thread I've started a while ago:


http://cafesaxophone.com/showthread.php?5469-transposition-please-do-justify-it-(once-and-for-all)

be prepared to being attacked by too many conventionalist musos out there - their reasonings are pretty naff and their logic a bit irrational and can't be justified but they'll try to demolish your attempts cos' they aren't brave enough...:thumb:

well the actual reasons for buying the c-mel were a)cheap fixer upper b)to play a long with direction scores, which I guess is being not able to transpose on sight...

but the c-mel also cancels out the guitar player (I dont have one laying around here anymore, maybe in my mouthpiece drawer..)

And well, I have made quite a few arrangements the last 4to5 years but I'm hitting the ceiling of my theoretical knowledge. In the Netherlands most people take private lessons from teachers belonging to an institute or music school.

after you reach a certain level, you'll have to take and exam which has a preceding theory program and you practice the saxophone for the practical part of the exam with your teacher. after you pass those 2 you'll have your A exam. this goes up to D when you are at conservatory entry level.

and I stopped after B at the age of 16 when I hade High school (?) exams and aftwerwards new schools, so I stopped taking lessons all together, and continued my amateur musical career with the concert band which payed for my instrument and partially the lessons.

so you can see that after 8 years of zero music theory is quite a drawback. But thanks for you advice and I can see quite some advantages in reading / thinking from C. (like not having to explain a drummer why my C isnt a piano C...)
 
so you can see that after 8 years of zero music theory is quite a drawback. But thanks for you advice and I can see quite some advantages in reading / thinking from C. (like not having to explain a drummer why my C isnt a piano C...)
...and then you get the fun of explaining to your fellow sax players why you call an F an Eb when you're playing tenor or sop but you call it a Ab when you're playing alto or bari, even though they have the same notation in your sax part and the same (realtively simple) fingering on your instrument.
 
well the actual reasons for buying the c-mel were a)cheap fixer upper b)to play a long with direction scores, which I guess is being not able to transpose on sight...

but the c-mel also cancels out the guitar player (I dont have one laying around here anymore, maybe in my mouthpiece drawer..)

And well, I have made quite a few arrangements the last 4to5 years but I'm hitting the ceiling of my theoretical knowledge. In the Netherlands most people take private lessons from teachers belonging to an institute or music school.

after you reach a certain level, you'll have to take and exam which has a preceding theory program and you practice the saxophone for the practical part of the exam with your teacher. after you pass those 2 you'll have your A exam. this goes up to D when you are at conservatory entry level.

and I stopped after B at the age of 16 when I hade High school (?) exams and aftwerwards new schools, so I stopped taking lessons all together, and continued my amateur musical career with the concert band which payed for my instrument and partially the lessons.

so you can see that after 8 years of zero music theory is quite a drawback. But thanks for you advice and I can see quite some advantages in reading / thinking from C. (like not having to explain a drummer why my C isnt a piano C...)

I see...conservatory = conservative institunionalization of music conventions (yawn).
I thought you were a budding engineer...
 
...and then you get the fun of explaining to your fellow sax players why you call an F an Eb when you're playing tenor or sop but you call it a Ab when you're playing alto or bari, even though they have the same notation in your sax part and the same (realtively simple) fingering on your instrument.

no need to explain anything - if you think in C your mapping of the fingering is focused on the sound they produce not on the position of the keys within the sax - in fact this piece of info is totally irrelevant for a guitarist and for the sax player as well - we enjoy music for its sound not for how high/low the finger is placed on the keyboard.
(go figure...someone even thanked you for your pointless remark?!)

another message for Koen88:
If you ear is good you can safely ditch transposition...
On the other hand if you rely on reading scores then changing your ways is more troublesome...
Then, if you are a budding engineer why do you bother taking music to a "conservatory" level? That's for musos who are going to play in classic music orchestras for the rest of their lives - sitting for decades behind a score!! Is that what you really really want from music? Keep it amatorial and enjoy it.
 
If you ear is good you can safely ditch transposition...
On the other hand if you rely on reading scores then changing your ways is more troublesome...
Then, if you are a budding engineer why do you bother taking music to a "conservatory" level? That's for musos who are going to play in classic music orchestras for the rest of their lives - sitting for decades behind a score!! Is that what you really really want from music? Keep it amatorial and enjoy it.

It would be really nice if you stopped being so patronisingly offensive.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
no need to explain anything - if you think in C your mapping of the fingering is focused on the sound they produce not on the position of the keys within the sax - in fact this piece of info is totally irrelevant for a guitarist and for the sax player as well - we enjoy music for its sound not for how high/low the finger is placed on the keyboard.
(go figure...someone even thanked you for your pointless remark?!)

There are more points of view than just yours.

And there's no need to be rude. Open discussion of all sides of a topic is encouraged here. You're welcome to disagree politely with someone else's point of view. But if you only want your point of view to go forward, then you're going against the primary purpose of a forum like this.
 
no need to explain anything - if you think in C your mapping of the fingering is focused on the sound they produce not on the position of the keys within the sax - in fact this piece of info is totally irrelevant for a guitarist and for the sax player as well - we enjoy music for its sound not for how high/low the finger is placed on the keyboard.
(go figure...someone even thanked you for your pointless remark?!)

another message for Koen88:
If you ear is good you can safely ditch transposition...
On the other hand if you rely on reading scores then changing your ways is more troublesome...
Then, if you are a budding engineer why do you bother taking music to a "conservatory" level? That's for musos who are going to play in classic music orchestras for the rest of their lives - sitting for decades behind a score!! Is that what you really really want from music? Keep it amatorial and enjoy it.

no i dont want to go to such level, I was merely explaining how it works here, and that it`s quite a while ago.
 
no need to explain anything - if you think in C your mapping of the fingering is focused on the sound they produce not on the position of the keys within the sax - in fact this piece of info is totally irrelevant for a guitarist and for the sax player as well - we enjoy music for its sound not for how high/low the finger is placed on the keyboard.
Try telling that to my big band leader when he puts a part in front of me which I've never seen for an arrangement which I've never heard. Perhaps I should ask him to sing everyone's part to them one by one so we can all learn it by ear and play it from memory. I'm sure he wouldn't mind that. And it would only take a few months for us to learn each piece.

(go figure...someone even thanked you for your pointless remark?!)
Hard to believe, isn't it?

If you ear is good you can safely ditch transposition...
On the other hand if you rely on reading scores then changing your ways is more troublesome...
But I don't want to change them. They work rather well.

Then, if you are a budding engineer why do you bother taking music to a "conservatory" level? That's for musos who are going to play in classic music orchestras for the rest of their lives - sitting for decades behind a score!! Is that what you really really want from music? Keep it amatorial and enjoy it.
Ever blasted away on an Eb clarinet over the top of a full symphony orchestra playing a Mahler symphony? No, I thought not. One of the most enjoyable experiences of my life. And I didn't get paid a penny.
 
Try telling that to my big band leader when he puts a part in front of me which I've never seen for an arrangement which I've never heard. Perhaps I should ask him to sing everyone's part to them one by one so we can all learn it by ear and play it from memory. I'm sure he wouldn't mind that. And it would only take a few months for us to learn each piece.

Get a C score then!!
Then all you need is retrain your brain and think in C and focus more on your ear and less on your fingers if you are juggling with different saxes (focusing more on your ear is also very beneficial for your music) - a tenor is a different instrument from an alto or a clarinet - why fixating in thinking they are the same? You can fit a square into a circle (full stop).

this stuff has been already churned endlessly in that other famous thread (so, I'm off).
 
Get a C score then!!
Ah, I see. "Give me half an hour, Mike, while I transpose this part using pencil and paper into something more diifficult to read."

Then all you need is retrain your brain and think in C and focus more on your ear and less on your fingers if you are juggling with different saxes
I never juggle with my saxes. I don't want to drop them. And I don't want to learn 2 or more sets of fingerings for the same written notes.

(focusing more on your ear is also very beneficial for your music)
Yes. I do that a lot. What's that got to do with how we write saxophone parts?

- a tenor is a different instrument from an alto or a clarinet - why fixating in thinking they are the same? You can fit a square into a circle (full stop).
We can discuss Euclidean geometry another time. Mr Sax went to the trouble of inventing a set of instruments which could all be played with the same fingering system (leaving clarinets out of it for now). He clearly thought that was important. Why throw away all his hard work by calling the same fingerings by different names?

this stuff has been already churned endlessly in that other famous thread (so, I'm off).
Bye!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
it's absolutism I have trouble with. There is no ultimate "right" answer. Each position is a set of compromises. Yes, transposing instruments seems odd in a way since we have had fully chromatic capability since the invention of keyed systems and valves. But, equally learning multiple fingerings for the different members of the sax/clarinet/trumpet etc families doesn't make much sense either. Then there's the minor matter of re-printing / re-writing all that music...

Ain't goin' to happen.... so why obsess about it? I'd also like my employer to pay me £50,000 a week, just a like a footballer...
 
I'd also like my employer to pay me £50,000 a week, just a like a footballer...

Is that all :w00t: I'd rather get a record contract where they give me a few million pounds in advance >:) Then fund my latest pop album consisting of just three chords, terrible vocals and to be proclaimed as the best album ever! :mrcool Then I could be in the "Hall of Fame" with all those other rather rich five minute wonders >:)

Ain't goin' to happen.... so why obsess about it

Where would the fun be in that :w00t::shocked:>:);}
 
Get a C score then!!

Right!
Shame for centuries of wonderful printed music that would become useless.

I have the strange feeling that we are trying to avoid one unpleasant issue:

We are supposed to be able to transpose by sight (reasonably).

Reading a part for Eb alto with an Eb alto is still the most comfortable way of doing it. No question, whatever the reason is.
If you are not just a reader you need to communicate with other musicians, and concert key becomes quite helpful.

If you find a part for F sopranino sax, you must know that such an instrument does not exist, so you pick up your soprano and read the part transposing a fifth up. (This example is not made up, it really happened for the first performance of Ravel's Bolero).

If you play with a female singer, she will ask you to transpose every single day. In any direction.

And about reading a C score... tenor saxophone is supposed to read in bass clef, while soprano in treble clef: not really an improvement....

Common practice wins: saxophones are transposing instruments.
If you want to be a musician, de-transposing is not enough: you must be able to transpose in any key. This is beneficial to your music.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom