Mouthpieces Theo Wanne 'The Mantra' Tenor Sax

I think this is going to happen anyway, no matter how smooth the surface. People who do surface chemistry and such pay a lot of money for powerful vacuum pumps so they can study metal surfaces without a layer of adsorbed gas getting in the way. And on the first space walks (I keep mentioning this but I think it's really interesting!) they were surprised to find their gloves and boots sticking to everything they touched because said gas layer wasn't there to lubricate the contact.

I am half way reticulating a 1962 Mk VI. what should I do?

But there were no space walks. They want us to believe it.
 
Too late. You've wrecked it. I'll give you £50 for it as scrap.

Much easier and cheaper to send men into space than to maintain a hoax of that magnitude over 50 years. I'd be much more impressed if it was a fake.

I will keep it so I have a place for my umbrellas.

if we believe in half the gadgets we buy for our saxophones, we can believe anything.
 
I like "The Mantra" and "Eagle" saxes. Lots new solutions. Less mainstream. IMO it's just Keilwerth and R&C who is differnt in saxworld when it comes to tone/timbre.

I hope "The Mantra" and "Eagle" becomes successful. I've been waiting for a real American saxophone. Maybe Eagle is built with old B&S tools, but they can't use the drawn toneholes tech, because Eagle has silversoldered toneholes. Like the old Kings!

Thomas
 
I like "The Mantra" and "Eagle" saxes. Lots new solutions. Less mainstream. IMO it's just Keilwerth and R&C who is differnt in saxworld when it comes to tone/timbre.

I hope "The Mantra" and "Eagle" becomes successful. I've been waiting for a real American saxophone. Maybe Eagle is built with old B&S tools, but they can't use the drawn toneholes tech, because Eagle has silversoldered toneholes. Like the old Kings!

Thomas

Do I sound too negative if I say that I don't like both names?
"Mantra" makes me think of long low notes and "Eagle" of the eagle that tried to moralize the Muppets
 
Yet another generic Taiwanese sax, i think the general consensus is you contact the factory, tell them what cosmetic changes you want making to theire already proven design, how many you want, what finish you want it in, they give you a quote....and bingo another new sax brand is born...

May be Taiwanese but it's hardly generic. Unique octave mechanism, tapered neck tenon, lot's of little improvements. Just because Theo jobbed out the manufacturing to a shop with experience instead of building his own doesn't mean there isn't anything new here.
 
Yes, made on the old B&S tooling (from Germany)...

So they're using some of the jigs and other tooling from B&S. With soldered toneholes there can't be much, if any of the important features (taper, toneholes) held over. Using the same tools doesn't at all mean making the same design.

i do apologize for my deep ignorance, but it sound like some relative of Jon Døe

Jim makes a saxophone with his own fingering system. In central California IIRC.
 
May be Taiwanese but it's hardly generic. Unique octave mechanism, tapered neck tenon, lot's of little improvements. Just because Theo jobbed out the manufacturing to a shop with experience instead of building his own doesn't mean there isn't anything new here.

Some of the improvements existed already. I am not sure to understand the revolutionary octave system and if the reticulated finish will be effective.

My main concern is actually spiritual. He seems to use a religion as a mean of marketing.
I find it quite disturbing.
Fine if Morgan Fry starts making the Zeus (large chamber, big opening) and the Hermes (small chamber, long baffle) models, but greek mythology is no longer a religion.

It would be like seeing an ad for the new Honda Jesus.

I am in the difficult phase in which I am trying to find a new sound, so I am really interested in any innovation,
but both Wanne saxes and mouthpieces don't appeal me at all.
 
Yes, made on the old B&S tooling (from Germany)...
So they're using some of the jigs and other tooling from B&S. With soldered toneholes there can't be much, if any of the important features (taper, toneholes) held over. Using the same tools doesn't at all mean making the same design.

They're only using the B&S tooling for the keys. Body, bell etc. is made on their own tooling. And the keys aren't the same as B&S, either.

IIRC, the last B&S's also used nickel silver for the keys, so it makes sense.

I just found it ironic that a defunct German maker has seen it's tooling find a new lease of life in an 'all american' sax. But really I'm glad to see Powell getting this going. Just like with the motorcycle industry, the West needs to recover from the Eastern onslaught. I just hope there are enough well heeled buyers to make this a success. But I'm a little sceptical.
 
Some of the improvements existed already. I am not sure to understand the revolutionary octave system and if the reticulated finish will be effective.
Maybe all of them. The neck (ball bearing on the mechanism and all mounted at the bottom) and the bell brace/pants guard combo are the only ones I don't think I've seen before. Triple ring hook like the Kings, adjustment screws everywhere like some of the old Conns, key bumpers inline like the Martins. Not sure who ever did a conical tenon but it's the best thing in there IMO. It's a lot of little things that nobody else really does right now, if the bore and neck are right it may turn out to be a great horn.

My main concern is actually spiritual. He seems to use a religion as a mean of marketing.
I find it quite disturbing.

I hear you Al, but I grew up in California in the 70's. I've seen the trappings of Hinduism and Buddhism used to sell so many things for so long being offended didn't even occur to me. Besides, for longer than he's been making mouthpieces I've heard that Theo was really into his meditation thing. Personally I hold that stuff more private but if the guy wants to wear his religion on his sleeve who am I to judge.

I am in the difficult phase in which I am trying to find a new sound, so I am really interested in any innovation,
but both Wanne saxes and mouthpieces don't appeal me at all.

Yeah, that can be a tough spot. Keep working at it and your voice will come through. Best of luck with it.
 
They're only using the B&S tooling for the keys. Body, bell etc. is made on their own tooling. And the keys aren't the same as B&S, either.

OK, that makes sense. IMO this one is even more interesting -- first new professional American made saxophone design in what, 60 years? 70?
 
They're only using the B&S tooling for the keys. Body, bell etc. is made on their own tooling. And the keys aren't the same as B&S, either.

IIRC, the last B&S's also used nickel silver for the keys, so it makes sense.

Hi Kev, what is the source for that interesting information ?

I would think that the keys would be quite easy to make for a flute-builder like Powell. Existing jigs etc would probably save a bit of time and money.

But for a new design of sax made in small numbers, why not buy in keywork from one of the big manufacturers, until you see whether the product is going to take off ? Isn't that what Inderbinen do with Yamaha keywork ?

Rhys
 
Last edited by a moderator:
May be Taiwanese but it's hardly generic.
I'm saying that they used a generic Taiwanese sax as a base...(or for that matter could be Chinese) before adding all the boutique flashy bits to create something "unique".

Unique octave mechanism
Hardly anything new about an underslung octave mech, King were doing it 50 odd years ago, what i would say was unique is the bracket/octave lever which looks like two near identical beams pivoting on a bearing rather like a pair of scissors, neat idea but i wonder how it will stand the test of time and deal with neck movement/flexure and constantly being taken off/put back on, could be quite an issue if the two halved start to flex themselves and rub against each other, in engineering terms a case of simple issue complication, but neat none the less.

tapered neck tenon
I wonder many tech's have the equipment to expand a loose tapered neck tenon, should it ever work loose?
 
Hardly anything new about an underslung octave mech, King were doing it 50 odd years ago ...

.... and so did Conn in 30's (ok-pipe down), Buescher in the 40's. But "The Mantra" use some old solutions as well.

Four point capurted bell to body brace. Like early King Super 20, Martin Comm I, II and III, Conn 6 & 10 M. Solder bell-bow connection. Most sax have detachable bells and they are also glued nowadays. I think this is important for the lowtones (soldered bow, more than 2 points bell/body brace). We have been talking about this before here at CS.

Thomas
 
Solder bell-bow connection. Most sax have detachable bells and they are also glued nowadays. I think this is important for the lowtones (soldered bow, more than 2 points bell/body brace). We have been talking about this before here at CS.

If you don't have to remove a dent from the lower body. My bari will stay dented due to the cost of unsoldering it (wether bell or crook).
There might be better solutions.
 
A tech in NJ told me that the best Selmer are soldered bell-bow. Leaks (bow-bell) and rotating bells are not unusal on MkVI. According to him the detacheable bell cut hours at the techs. But the low tones are better with soldered bell-bow. My Martins and also my (former) King Super 20 (early) has outstanding low tones.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,685
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom