Mouthpieces Theo Wanne 'The Mantra' Tenor Sax

I'm saying that they used a generic Taiwanese sax as a base...(or for that matter could be Chinese) before adding all the boutique flashy bits to create something "unique".

Has it been established that this uses a generic tube? Given how detail oriented Theo has always been about the mouthpieces I'm just assuming a similar level of care when it comes to the saxes. Just because they're made in Taiwan doesn't mean they're just another stencil.

Hardly anything new about an underslung octave mech, King were doing it 50 odd years ago, what i would say was unique is the bracket/octave lever which looks like two near identical beams pivoting on a bearing rather like a pair of scissors, neat idea but i wonder how it will stand the test of time and deal with neck movement/flexure and constantly being taken off/put back on, could be quite an issue if the two halved start to flex themselves and rub against each other, in engineering terms a case of simple issue complication, but neat none the less.

The lever is all I'm talking about, of course there are plenty of underslung octave keys. Can't tell exactly how the mechanism works, but it is unique. Seems to be a lot of metal sticking out there for it to be very rigid, but I'm not going to speculate on how good or bad it is based on a few pictures that don't even make clear how it operates. On the whole I think I'll reserve judgement until some make it to England.

I wonder many tech's have the equipment to expand a loose tapered neck tenon, should it ever work loose?

Who cares? It's acoustically superior. If that means a tech has to fix the reciever instead of the tenon in 10 years so be it.
 
A tech in NJ told me that the best Selmer are soldered bell-bow. Leaks (bow-bell) and rotating bells are not unusal on MkVI. According to him the detacheable bell cut hours at the techs. But the low tones are better with soldered bell-bow. My Martins and also my (former) King Super 20 (early) has outstanding low tones.

I heard a similar opinion from a repairer in London, but I think he mentioned an easy soft soldering solution easy to revert if needed.
 
Has it been established that this uses a generic tube?
No but it's widely acknowledged that if you want to produce your "own brand" sax you go to the "factories" over it Taiwan, (or china) tel them what you want, pay them and they make it.....not to sure whats so special about Theo Wann, but why would, or why should he be any different?

Seems to be a lot of metal sticking out there for it to be very rigid,
Yes i agree but imagine holding onto the neck and putting the mouthpiece on, your bound to squeeze it a bit over time this could result in the two surfaces coming into contact and creating friction resulting in a serious problem! also i wonder what would happen if say for example you were to get some grit, fluff from your case or other foreign body trapped in that open bearing...

Who cares? It's acoustically superior. If that means a tech has to fix the receiver instead of the tenon in 10 years so be it.
Well i for one would care, especially if I'd just spent two and a half grand on a new sax and the neck started working loose and no one could re-size it.....i'd care a lot!
 
1 thing for sure if Theo puts his name on something it is going to be made with near perfection and any thing he does or makes theres only 1 goal he looks for.THE SOUND.
 
I like "The Mantra" and "Eagle" saxes. Lots new solutions. Less mainstream. IMO it's just Keilwerth and R&C who is differnt in saxworld when it comes to tone/timbre.

I hope "The Mantra" and "Eagle" becomes successful. I've been waiting for a real American saxophone. Maybe Eagle is built with old B&S tools, but they can't use the drawn toneholes tech, because Eagle has silversoldered toneholes. Like the old Kings!

Thomas

Also Borgani.They got there own great voice,
 
Just had a listen to this Sax being played by some bloke named Ernie Watts, its on youtube.
Frankly I think I'll give it a miss

If you want to hear "some bloke named Ernie Watts" look for Charlie Haden quartet.
He is clearly trying some sort of Coltranish sound in the upper register (i guess the tune comes from Coltrane's Ballads, Impulse).

Considering the quality of the recording and the amount of loud Americans around it is hard to say...

But I will give it a miss too.
 
Didn't sound to "legendary" to me, in fairness he's probably a Selmer man though, theres another video on there of him trying out Tim Price's selmer, wow completely different altogether, amazing player..... That Mantra just sounded dead by comparison.

Did anyone see the look of worry on the reps face? the lady in the blue fleece? you could almost see her saying for Gods sake, someone get it off of him before anyone hears it, or we'll never shift any!

Great player, not so great sax...
 
Yes, I have heard that as well. But have not played a modern Borgani.

Thomas

A little OT but I tried one (Lovano model IIRC) a couple years ago, loved it. Nice clean action, great centered, dry, colorful sound. A little more resistant than I prefer. Really nice sound and response. The Rampones I've tried I also really like. The Italians seem to be doing it right IMO.
 
A little OT but I tried one (Lovano model IIRC) a couple years ago, loved it. Nice clean action, great centered, dry, colorful sound. A little more resistant than I prefer. Really nice sound and response. The Rampones I've tried I also really like. The Italians seem to be doing it right IMO.

I nearly let the borgani go.Its my 2nd.Wow a close call.Glad i kept it.There amazing huge tenors.
As for Ernie Watts he's a stellar player.1 of the best in the world.He has played Keilwerth for many years.Lawton mps also.A legend.
 
It's buried in this thread.

Thanks Morgan (and Kev). That relates to the Powell 'Silver Eagle' sax rather than this Theo Wanne 'The Mantra' - it's hard to keep up with so many new saxes being launched !

I scanned through that thread on SOTW and to save others doing the same, here is what Mike Smith (sax player and on the Powell design team) said:

"Yes we did buy the B&S tooling. No we are not basing our horn on their design. I am working with designers Chris French and John Weir on a complete new design. The tooling will be used to make pad cups, and posts. We will be altering the fixtures for our design. Neck, tube, bow and bell are being made with new tooling we created."

I can't wait until someone buys me one of each !

Rhys
 
"He seems to use a religion as a mean of marketing" - in India it's common to have businesses and brands named after deities eg Shiva Engineering or Lakshmi brand potato crisps and since Mr Wanne seems to have been heavily into meditation etc for years it's not unsurprising that he'd use those kind of names for his products. It's only when western companies are disrespectful of the hindu tradition that they take offence, like the fashion company that printed images of hindu deities onto shoes and skimpy womens clothes..

While some people may find Theo Wanne's hari krishna-esque demeanour and hyped up marketing speak a bit off putting, there's no doubt that he's invested a considerable amount of time and money in trying to create a good quality product that he believes in.
His prices may be steep, but so are Selmer or the top of the range Yamaha and Yanagisawa instruments and no doubt part of that high price is due to having to pay a cut of his profits to the people he's borrowed the money from. At least he's trying, rather than just ordering generic asian saxes and having his name engraved on them

here's a better youtube video of his tenor in action - http://youtu.be/QOMsIaODmNM and a bit of a review - http://www.kesslermusic.com/blog/?p=405

according to this - http://forum.saxontheweb.net/showth...n-this-Wanne-Saxophone/page2&highlight=mantra
some of the parts are made in the USA and sent to Taiwan for assembly, the final set up will be done by Music Medic in the USA.

No doubt these instruments will eventually make their way over here and than someone can have a blow on one and give us an honest opinion. Until then, who knows if they're any good?
No doubt SOTW will be full of people raving about them and then selling them off 6 months later when something else comes along...>:)
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,685
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom