TV/film/books The Social Dilemma

My kids (16 and 14) laugh at Facebook. They reckon it's for oldies. They use other Social Media. I don't fear for their futures through using it.

Mine are the same about Facebook. Not interested. They are 18, 16 and 13. The 13 years old started to show worrying tends with regards to Social Media usage, so I installed Google Family on his phone to limit his usage and monitor it. It took a while for Google to come up with something but it looks rather useful. We never meant to provide our kids with social media interfaces. Just phones to stay in touch for safety reasons... What a trap!

I'm not so sure the Netflix Algorithm is necessarily any less persuasive (Or even manipulative) than other algorithms. I don't think the very clever people behind Netflix would allow it. It's all about the bottom line, after all.

For me netflix is rather like Spotify, a Service I subscribed to and paid for. If I don't like it, I can take my business elsewhere. There are many other options, but so far in France, I'm not seduced by the competition. Usually bundled with many other things I don't care about.

Spotify by the way as lso uses algorithms, but generally speaking they rather go in the right direction. I also pay for a service and do not suffer from ads as a consequence.

That's probably the whole point. When you don't pay, you get... humm. What you get and you can't really argue or complain about it! It's take it or leave it.
 
If you think you really know what your kids are up to, try to remember what you were like at that age. Did your parents know your every move? Not specific to you here, but often the parents of teen suicides claim there was absolutley no warning, nothing to indicate that the child hated the way they looked, until they posted the suicide note on... Facebook. There've even been a few live suicides, that's a really ugly side to the question.
 
All opinions welcome, but honestly, NO ONE thinks Netflix suggestions are useful or appropriate, and most algorithms for recommendation are rubbish. For example, i was very invested in Google Plus a few years ago. Their "You may also like", just as Amazon and Netfilix were way off, and look how much info Google has on you if you use their stuff. If you don't have an iPhone, you're in the Googleverse, or you don't have a phone. Actually, YouTube usually wins on that area because at least once you've watched a bunch of Mile Davis videos, it's going to start showing other similar jazz stuff among the useless ones. Also, every person whose opinion I've have read or heard directly will agree that the Netflix interface is horrible. You have to fight hard to find and watch what you want, so it kind of negates any diabolical plan they have to show you documentaries, etc. I think mostly, Netflix shows you what they want to promote. There's one line, "Because you watched..." Amazon does this too, but again, it's very low signal to noise.

I always thought the awful structure of Netflix was their way of forcing you down their particular route!
 
On topic: Is Social Media Good For Anything At All?

Often overlooked in discussions like this: Google's centrality. Google is the ultimate producer of mediated reality, and misperceptions of truth, because as people Google, the AI does not care if their curiosity is informed or misinformed, it only cares if they click. When most people are misinformed, the algorithm continually reproduces and further exaggerates untruth, and for all those misinformed people, misconstrues truth because for most people truth is a function of consensus, not rationality.

That is a danger to civilization, and could easily signal an end to functional democracy.
 
My conclusion for the evening is this: we need to be able to cultive in the coming generations the ability to discern things like the validity of the source of information/news, the vested interest of these sources, and the potential value added of any channel purveying information or entertainment. To sum that up in a word,

THINK

If thought is applied to all we receive, we should be able to sort out the probabilities. For those who cannot, they'll be the ones living with it. When applied to an electorate, unfortunately, if majority rules and the majority are not thinkers... you do the math.
 
...”Some jerk commented "if you're cute and smile and can't play bass..." type comment. Why do that? Why give a thumbs down on ANYTHING! Don't, no one cares about your thumbs down. Why dump on some young musician? Be positive.”
- Because the jerk has an inferiority complex (probably because he/she IS inferior) and it makes them feel good to put someone down.

I’ve noticed that some people always greet with a put-down - I guess it gives them confidence. If you challenge them about it you get “It was only banter. What’s WRONG with you?...”
Then they wonder why nobody can be arsed to talk to them.
Anyway, back to saxophones...
 
I just saw a young girl playing a Stevie Wonder tune, Sir Duke on Youtube, she hit all the notes perfectly. Some jerk commented "if you're cute and smile and can't play bass..." type comment. Why do that? Why give a thumbs down on ANYTHING! Don't, no one cares about your thumbs down. Why dump on some young musician?
Within the range of usual human behaviour

Some people choose to behave like pillocks
 
If the comment you are referring to on that video is the one that's recently been edited, it reads like a compliment now (a bit of a badly written compliment, maybe), so perhaps the person who commented pressed return by mistake or came back and read their response and changed it.
 
If the comment you are referring to on that video is the one that's recently been edited, it reads like a compliment now (a bit of a badly written compliment, maybe), so perhaps the person who commented pressed return by mistake or came back and read their response and changed it.
You could be right. FWIW, on any page I manage on YouTube, comments are checked first before they're published. I highly recommend everyone does this, because YouTube is famous for seriously mean comments, as well as sexist, negative and every other thing you'd rather not see under a video.
 
My youngest flunked his A levels due to the "little screen".

Having to go back and take the whole year again, with what was the year below him, has hopefully taught him a life lesson. He got his grades second time around, then a first at Anglia Ruskin Cambridge, and is now succeeding in his chosen career path.

I have no idea how Twitter, Instagram, etc work and don't wish to. If I had my way the whole lot would be binned and outlawed. It maddens me when some youngster takes their own life because of online bullying. JUST DON'T GO ON IT!!

It's an addiction (as is the Cafe) but the worst offending sites need to be under Government control.

Sugar and fatty foods should similarly be controlled substances. A set of scales at the checkout perhaps?
 
It's a huge challenge for parents. It's why I recommend as may watch as possible. Because what you don't know can hurt you and yours.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
While on the subject!
IMG_20201012_132254341.webp

Just arrived, seconds after my Légère American Cut reeds.

But due to the replacement of my boiler in my den, I can't access my toys! 🙁
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,429
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom