TV/film/books The Social Dilemma

saxyjt

Saxus Circus Maximus
Messages
5,282
Location
France
j4CBsXaGcltcHGbcxsWD5VfEaiU.jpg


Title: The Social Dilemma

Tagline: The technology that connects us also controls us.

Genre: Documentary, Drama

Director: Jeff Orlowski

Cast: Tristan Harris, Skyler Gisondo, Vincent Kartheiser, Kara Hayward, Sophia Hammons, Catalina Garayoa, Barbara Gehring, Chris Grundy, Vic Alejandro

Release: 2020-01-26

Runtime: 94

Plot: This documentary-drama hybrid explores the dangerous human impact of social networking, with tech experts sounding the alarm on their own creations.


 
This is a must see documentary these days! If not for us, for our kids and for a better awareness of what's being the scene and what people from the inside say about it. Don't miss the very end, when they tell about their attitude towards their kids on the matter.

Being here proves we are all more or less addicted to social media. The forum being a social media obviously. I'm an addict! I've been taking increasingly high shots of internet related content since 95!

Working in IT I felt compelled to know about these things... But as many I got trapped in them too!
 
That looks very interesting thankyou :
I make a conscious effort to keep ( anti ) social media at arms length . Other than here and the occasional Twitter post I don't participate . No Facebook : Instagram or Whatsap whatsoever. Even Twitter is limited to posting clips of music and the odd " light hearted " comment .
I did try these social platforms years back but found they weren't for me . Everybody has an opinion about FB etc but this is not the place for that . I will however say that it is " addictive " and I have problems understanding just how people can become so obsessed with it all ; to the extreme cases of people taking their own lives : making and losing fortunes : meeting spouses and on...
All of the above can be done on a mobile phone and that is a frightening thought .
Parents especially need to be over vigilant and to let their kids know exactly where all of this can go if not " used correctly "....
Yeah : our lives dictated via mobile phone applications is a very dark thought...
I stay well away..
 
Being here proves we are all more or less addicted to social media.
Not! (That means, I disagree.) Being here means you found the best place for socialising with like-minded people. There are many others about other topics. As a single-topic focus, it is far more efficient and interesting than "social media". "Addicted to social media" means you are constantly looking at your Instagram feed to see how many likes you have, and you can't put your phone down, anytime there's time to fill.

This said, the reason this doc is so important is that the people who invented this technology are explaining what the intent was: to get users as addicted as possible to it. For example, the infinite scroll was invented at Google by Tristan Harris. The past few years, he's been spending his time explaining how evil all these designs are. The inventor of the YouTube algorithm is in this too, and also is warning people about it. The main takeaway of the documentary is that the people responsible for inventing and perfecting these platforms are telling you how damaging they can be: suicide rates among the young increasing, organized groups lynching people, election tampering and more. Alll these things have been linked to the social platforms. You owe it to yourself to watch the show even if you bhave no interest in these platforms, because you can explain it to others who are in danger of succumbing.
 
As I'm reading this some guy on television is talking about following his tour on FB etc.....it's everywhere : a constant and will become a necessary part of everyday life..
I'm glad I'm old !! :confused:
 
It's not a question of putting down your phone when there is " time to fill " Randy it's a constant thing . An example : a friend and I watched a couple having a " romantic meal " in our local bar / restaurant abroad .
Candles lit they were shown to the table and offered the wine list : no sooner had they ordered from that than out out came the phones. The couple hardly exchanged a word throughout the whole meal engrossed in their FB world...
It's everywhere ; people don't talk anymore....phone phone phone...the desire to accumulate the " likes " is a sad thing . I don't have a smartphone preferring to come to the Cafe via a pad...that's it !!
 
out came the phones.
Yes, there's a lot of that extreme. I recall seeing a father with a young child in a restaurant, the cild looking around while the dad screwed with his phone the entire meal, quality time!
But there are levels of this. I could look at twitter in a waiting room or in line, but I make an effort to look elsewhere. When I'm on my desktop environment, I take breaks to look at the café and other sites. Outside, I'd rather look at people and things like trees. But that's me, I get that when you grew up with the Internet, it's a part of you.
 
As I'm reading this some guy on television is talking about following his tour on FB etc.....it's everywhere : a constant and will become a necessary part of everyday life..
I'm glad I'm old !! :confused:

The trouble with FB is it has grown into a monster and many people consider that if you're interested by what they do or sell then you will go to FB to follow or stay informed. But what if you do not use FB? And then FB acquired Whatsapp and Instagram too! And now they are planning to merge them. All into one! FB also does auctions like ebay apparently. So what's next? They are already working on an OS for smartphones to bypass the hurdles of IOS and Android.

We must educate our kids to want alternatives to keep a balance. It's like healthy competition. Today in Social Media there is no real alternative, yet! Even Google failed to create one with Google+.

Not! (That means, I disagree.) Being here means you found the best place for socialising with like-minded people. There are many others about other topics. As a single-topic focus, it is far more efficient and interesting than "social media". "Addicted to social media" means you are constantly looking at your Instagram feed to see how many likes you have, and you can't put your phone down, anytime there's time to fill.

I still recognize that I'm addicted to this forum. It's a fact!

You're only "Positively obsessed"... :optimistic:
 
I'm obsessed with trying to be positive, not positively obsessed. I just saw a young girl playing a Stevie Wonder tune, Sir Duke on Youtube, she hit all the notes perfectly. Some jerk commented "if you're cute and smile and can't play bass..." type comment. Why do that? Why give a thumbs down on ANYTHING! Don't, no one cares about your thumbs down. Why dump on some young musician? Be positive.

WRT Social, I just earned that in the three years it has been up, Tik Tok has something like 800 million active users. FB is afraid! If you haven't loked at Tik Tok yet and you have offspring, better go see what it is. It's actually addictive and may steal most young users away from Insta etc.
Screen Shot 2020-10-11 at 15.30.57.png


Tik Tok stats
 
I wouldn't know where to start thankfully . My niece has just had a little girl and is determined to guide her toward music: books : drawing : animal welfare...
Ask kids to go out and play as we used to and they are clueless !! If a phone app doesn't tell them what to do or to think it's not happening . What happened to imagination...should all this crap be banned I wonder . Many of the top guys from social platforms are well aware of the monster they have created : a brave few are even speaking up and that is brave !!
 
I'm obsessed with trying to be positive, not positively obsessed.
1602426983706.webp

I just quoted you my friend! 😉

I agree that Social Media should be about being positive and giving thumbs up, not thumbs down. If you don't like it, then leave. But people need to express their feelings. Blow off some steam and they now do it on social media because they probably don't have another way to do it!

Internet started with Netiquette. That was part of the foundation and was generally adhered to initially. Of course as the Internet became very popular and used by just anybody without any kind of introduction, this code of conduct is no longer applied by most.

What about Social Media? Any published and widely recognized code of conduct?

NB: Here in the forum there is such a code, so you're right it's very different!
 
Is there no escape!?
None. But any reasonably intelligent person can deal with YouTube or Netflix algorithms. The same is not true for Facebook. It's an illusion when people say "I don't see that stuff". Entertainent is mostly designed to, erm, entertain. The social networks are for that, too, but even more they influence you. The proof is the amount of political memes your friends post daily, after the baby pics and whatever else. That was the end for me, when my musician friends flooded my stream with pol stuff, even if I agreed with side it was on, it ruined the day.
 
None. But any reasonably intelligent person can deal with YouTube or Netflix algorithms. The same is not true for Facebook. It's an illusion when people say "I don't see that stuff". Entertainent is mostly designed to, erm, entertain. The social networks are for that, too, but even more they influence you. The proof is the amount of political memes your friends post daily, after the baby pics and whatever else. That was the end for me, when my musician friends flooded my stream with pol stuff, even if I agreed with side it was on, it ruined the day.

Ha, thanks for running with me? I have to admit I posted to be a bit provocative 😉 Not to try to disprove anyone's point, but just for discussion. I'm broadly in agreement with the negative sides of Social Media, though I'm not as strong as some in my views, I have to say.

I'm not so sure the Netflix Algorithm is necessarily any less persuasive (Or even manipulative) than other algorithms. I don't think the very clever people behind Netflix would allow it. It's all about the bottom line, after all.

Facebook has, of course, changed immeasurably over the past 15 or so Years. Where it was the next step up from 'Friends Reunited' where you caught up with people you went to School with, and in many cases discovered there was a reason you hadn't been in contact with most of them for the past 20 Years! It's now very different. Quite useful for gathering people in Private Groups for Social reasons (Sports Clubs, Mutual Appreciation Societies etc), but not much else, I would agree.

My kids (16 and 14) laugh at Facebook. They reckon it's for oldies. They use other Social Media. I don't fear for their futures through using it.
 
All opinions welcome, but honestly, NO ONE thinks Netflix suggestions are useful or appropriate, and most algorithms for recommendation are rubbish. For example, i was very invested in Google Plus a few years ago. Their "You may also like", just as Amazon and Netfilix were way off, and look how much info Google has on you if you use their stuff. If you don't have an iPhone, you're in the Googleverse, or you don't have a phone. Actually, YouTube usually wins on that area because at least once you've watched a bunch of Mile Davis videos, it's going to start showing other similar jazz stuff among the useless ones. Also, every person whose opinion I've have read or heard directly will agree that the Netflix interface is horrible. You have to fight hard to find and watch what you want, so it kind of negates any diabolical plan they have to show you documentaries, etc. I think mostly, Netflix shows you what they want to promote. There's one line, "Because you watched..." Amazon does this too, but again, it's very low signal to noise.

FB (yes, it's for oldies now) has been open to the public for about 14 years. I was on it in 2007, quit, came back, quit again... (Almost like smoking!) I still maintain one or more accounts for admin of a friend's business page, but I never go there to "use" it and have literally zero friends on it. Even so, I still see stuff just in trying to reach the management pages. It's far more odious than most people realise, as they coo over the baby photos and gossip. I think, though, that in the first world, the FB population will get older quickly as the young flee first to Insta (a FB property) and then Tik Tok. The up and coming adult platform (not porn, but not for kids) is LinkedIn, which I quit but then finally opened an accout to see people's profiles when I wanted to learn more about them.

The problem with Insta and Tik Tok is different. It is widely thought to have an influence on teen depression, because both show exaggerated lifestyles of a new social status called "influencers". A lot of pre-teens and teens are trying hard foir the job of influencer, thinking it's a career. It may be, for about a month. But all this dancing and primping for the camera separates two groups of people. Those who see it as fun, and nothing else and those who aspire to this fake level of life. We've all heard about the people who fall off the cliff while taking selfies, right, the 2020 version of lemmings?

It's hard to imagine what Tik Tok is without seeing it. Every parent with phone age kids should look and understand. The danger there is that the parents will get addicted as well. >:)

Sooner or later, someone will put forth the agrument that they said the same about radio, TV, movies. There's no similarity.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,429
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom