Saxophones the obscure, the overlooked

is that not permitted? shame!
at g
Do you mean emails in posts? No it encourages spammers, fraudsters and scammers to the site so it’s in everyone’s interest not to publish any email addresses.

Putting emails, phone numbers would make you open to scammers etc.
As above it’s not just whoever puts there email publically but attracts the scammers to the site
 
thanks just saxes. i have heard that about mk VII altos. they were described to me as 'not so weird' (as the tenor) by an experienced technician of my acquaintance. i am by no means a great player myself, i often wonder if i am a player at all, but i'm talking chiefly from concern about tone. i wonder if the actual process of manufacture rather than design is the big difference. brass was treated differently in the early and mid 20th century. bodies were formed differently. i would love to have a proper history of manufacturing processes. earlier saxophones must have had a great deal more handwork, even in the shaping and fixing together of the body itself, as well as the production of the toneholes and the mere fixing of pillars and plates.
Yes, besides the metal processing I reckon its down to the quality of the metal being better before modern mining techniques raped the earth. New horns are made with whats left in the mines rather than the rich veins of the past. China use bulk out metals in their copper, zinc I think is one of them so it stands to reason the raw quality of the
Oh: this was the simple point that led me to type all that out: there are modern horns that I really like, and that I think are really great. I could be happy personally with a number of them (despite not playing very well, I am very picky, due to wide exposure over many years, and some OK tone production and decent sensitivity and authentic goals -- i.e. there is a place I want to get to, and I'm not so far off that I can't tell when a horn, like a car, is helping me get there more immediately).

But there is nothing modern that is like what was made in the past.

That's not inherently bad or good. It just is.

I have yet, personally, to find that a claim by a modern manufacturer that "these horns have that vintage THING" to really ring true.

There are so many reasons for that to be true, if you allow for a moment that it might be.

I'm just saying I have not encountered any contemporary make/model (in its time of manufacture) that had the all the same magic as the best VIs, Chus, 10Ms, Aristocrats, TH&C tenors, you name it.

Altos are closer. Probably I only think that because I'm not personally as sensitive to altos as tenors...but also probably (again, based on personal experience) altos have just come a bit closer to being "as good as vintage" tonally over time than tenors. I can't tell you why that is, and probably that is its own vast -- much vaster than any "interwebz" discussions anywhere, to date -- topic. But you can get closer with a modern alto to whatever vehicle it is that will get you where you want to go, if normally you only find your particular desired flavor amidst vintage offering, in altos than tenors that are in production today. The Mark VII is a great example. Most tenor players who love VIs do not find the VII tenor workable. Many are shocked to find out that that prejudice against VIIs, inherited by experiences with tenors, does not hold with altos. A lot of very skilled alto players find the best VII alto they've ever played to be on a par with or even preferable to their life experience's best VI alto. Not so much for tenor.
Yes as well as the techniques used to form the bodies in the old saxs, its gotta be the quality of metal, as well. Its the copper/ zinc quality in modern horns that makes them as they are. The older ones were made when mines wernt scraping the bottom of the pits. The chinese add other metals to their copper piping to bulk it out so it stands to reason they would do the same with the brass. ( more zinc less copper) Im picking out copper rivits at the moment from a very old boat Im burning, you can tell the copper is quality from its weight.
 
Yes, besides the metal processing I reckon its down to the quality of the metal being better before modern mining techniques raped the earth. New horns are made with whats left in the mines rather than the rich veins of the past. China use bulk out metals in their copper, zinc I think is one of them so it stands to reason the raw quality of the

Yes as well as the techniques used to form the bodies in the old saxs, its gotta be the quality of metal, as well. Its the copper/ zinc quality in modern horns that makes them as they are. The older ones were made when mines wernt scraping the bottom of the pits. The chinese add other metals to their copper piping to bulk it out so it stands to reason they would do the same with the brass. ( more zinc less copper) Im picking out copper rivits at the moment from a very old boat Im burning, you can tell the copper is quality from its weight.
All wrong. You don't know anything about how factories make products from sheet metal and bar stock.

They buy the sheet metal for bodies and keycups, as well as the bar stock for key parts, from the local metals distributor, who buys the stuff from the rolling mill. It's all standard alloys which have specifications for main alloying elements, minor alloying elements, and maximum allowable content for various contaminants. If you buy C36000 (a good all purpose brass, good for machining, most keywork is made of this most likely) or C26000 (a good all purpose brass for forming and drawing) it will conform to the composition requirements of the alloy. A few years ago someone did some composition testing of saxophone bodies and they all came out as C26000.

If anything the composition of sheet metal is more tightly controlled now than it was 100 years ago, before the UNS standards were fully developed. Not that it will matter for saxophones - the drawing and forming requirements are not that severe, and the key arms, rods, etc., are very lightly stressed.

Furthermore, the material of which the sax body is made has nothing to do with the tone quality of the horn, that's due to the dimensions of the air column and the surface finish of the bore. This has been discussed ad infinitum.
 
All wrong. You don't know anything about how factories make products from sheet metal and bar stock.

They buy the sheet metal for bodies and keycups, as well as the bar stock for key parts, from the local metals distributor, who buys the stuff from the rolling mill. It's all standard alloys which have specifications for main alloying elements, minor alloying elements, and maximum allowable content for various contaminants. If you buy C36000 (a good all purpose brass, good for machining, most keywork is made of this most likely) or C26000 (a good all purpose brass for forming and drawing) it will conform to the composition requirements of the alloy. A few years ago someone did some composition testing of saxophone bodies and they all came out as C26000.

If anything the composition of sheet metal is more tightly controlled now than it was 100 years ago, before the UNS standards were fully developed. Not that it will matter for saxophones - the drawing and forming requirements are not that severe, and the key arms, rods, etc., are very lightly stressed.

Furthermore, the material of which the sax body is made has nothing to do with the tone quality of the horn, that's due to the dimensions of the air column and the surface finish of the bore. This has been discussed ad infinitum.
Ok boss, metals not been mined out then ok Im mistaken, I have old metal workers in the yard here, one majes armour I will tell them the quality hasnt gone down over years, thanks for the info.
 
Evening,
Anyone know the weight of a MKVI Alto from 1954 or 55, compared to one from around 1970?
I know there are different bows and my '73 has a piece of metal on the inside,
just curious.
Thx
PP

I've read that some clarinet players say they can tell the difference between a Grenadilla, Metal or Plastic clarinet, when listening to a recording.
 
Last edited:
...

I've read that some clarinet players say they can tell the difference between a Grenadilla, Metal or Plastic clarinet, when listening to a recording.
Let's see some data. Basically every controlled experiment shows that when the listener is not aware of which material is being played, they CANNOT tell the difference. Have you seen a blind experiment where the listener COULD tell the difference? Or is it the same old same old, where they can't do any better than random in guessing the material of the instrument being played?
 
Let's see some data. Basically every controlled experiment shows that when the listener is not aware of which material is being played, they CANNOT tell the difference. Have you seen a blind experiment where the listener COULD tell the difference? Or is it the same old same old, where they can't do any better than random in guessing the material of the instrument being played?
I agree. I'd go as far as to say that, if it were possible to do a test double blind, so the player didn't know the material of the instrument they were playing, even the player wouldn't be able to reliably tell.
 
Anyone know the weight of a MKVI Alto from 1954 or 55, compared to one from around 1970? I know there are different bows and my '73 has a piece of metal on the inside, just curious.
I think this was done to provide greater resistance to denting when dropped. Regarding additional weight, that small piece of sheet metal plus the small amount of sweat soldering to fasten it is probably almost negligible. This is just my opinion.

I've read that some clarinet players say they can tell the difference between a Grenadilla, Metal or Plastic clarinet, when listening to a recording.
Let's see some data. Basically every controlled experiment shows that when the listener is not aware of which material is being played, they CANNOT tell the difference. Have you seen a blind experiment where the listener COULD tell the difference? Or is it the same old same old, where they can't do any better than random in guessing the material of the instrument being played?
Not doubting there's some truth in what you say, but do you have a link to such study?

I've been playing mostly sax in my older years, my primary instrument is the clarinet. I notice there is a difference in timbre when listening to them live or playing them. (Do the studies you refer to have experienced clarinet players as the sampling source or people in general? IMO, I think the quality of the recording and reproduction equipment (sound system) and reproduction environment (room or headphones) may also affect the results of the study.)

A wood clarinet will have a slightly warmer mellower tone to it. Although it is true that it is the shape of the air by the internal dimensions, resonating by the sound column, the resonating of the material which shaped the air column does have a small effect.

This is why for example, IMO, listening to a few modern plastic / fiberglass saxophones, although they definitely without a doubt have a true sax sound through its range, a saxophonist can notice a tiny difference.

If there were absolutely no difference, then the choice of wood versus say "Ebonite" or plastic would be more of a marketing gimmick or teacher's prejudices. (I don't know, perhaps one of these days someone will come up with a synthetic matrix material that has properties so similar in resonance to wood that it gains popularity in professional grade instruments.)

Is the difference significant? I've played both Ebonite and wood and in truth, one can play a symphonic band part just as well on one as the other. (We used to use the "beginner" Ebonites for outdoor performances where if struck by inclimate weather (rain), it was preferred to "ruin" a cheap instrument rather than an expensive one. An oddity, back in the mid 1980's whilst drilling with the 91st Training Division Band, Army Reserve in Saucelito, CA, I was issued a brand new Selmer Bundy Ebonite clarinet. It was the first clarinet I played that was close to perfect pitch throughout its range, even better than the Buffet Crampon woody I played with the 264th in Honolulu, HI in the early 1970's.)

My early 1950's Beaugnier Vito low Bb baritone saxophone has a slightly darker tone to it versus my newer Antigua Winds low A bari. To the listening audience, would one shine more than the other in solo performance? I think not.

Apologies for my verboseness, although there is slight discernable differences in timbre in construction materials of wood versus metal versus plastic, when it comes to performance, and although there are critics who would be able to argue on the pin head of a needle the differences, in reality, most listeners really don't care. It is the skill of the musician that makes the performance.

Your take?
 
As far as my comment on some people saying they can tell the difference between wood, metal and plastic clarinets, that's something they just said, that I read, no real empirical tests/data.
Perhaps, empirical imagination? 🧐
 
As far as my comment on some people saying they can tell the difference between wood, metal and plastic clarinets, that's something they just said, that I read, no real empirical tests/data. Perhaps, empirical imagination? 🧐

Thanks for the clarification on the internal bow construction.

How do you scientifically measure feelings? How do you scientifically measure the affinity for love of the music art?

Due to limitations in technology, even though nowadays MIDI technology has come such a long way, that rather than hiring a whole orchestra or band, get away with a couple keyboards and a few key instruments, (much music these days seem to use fewer musicians), the human hearing and ability to mentally discern will always have a lead.

Also, how many so-called studies truly follow the "scientific method" to assure there is no skewing of the evidence?

Nonetheless, I gather that the Conn, especially one that is well maintained is indeed a worthy instrument to hold, behold and use.
 
Last edited:
I think this was done to provide greater resistance to denting when dropped. Regarding additional weight, that small piece of sheet metal plus the small amount of sweat soldering to fasten it is probably almost negligible. This is just my opinion.


Not doubting there's some truth in what you say, but do you have a link to such study?

I've been playing mostly sax in my older years, my primary instrument is the clarinet. I notice there is a difference in timbre when listening to them live or playing them. (Do the studies you refer to have experienced clarinet players as the sampling source or people in general? IMO, I think the quality of the recording and reproduction equipment (sound system) and reproduction environment (room or headphones) may also affect the results of the study.)

A wood clarinet will have a slightly warmer mellower tone to it. Although it is true that it is the shape of the air by the internal dimensions, resonating by the sound column, the resonating of the material which shaped the air column does have a small effect.

This is why for example, IMO, listening to a few modern plastic / fiberglass saxophones, although they definitely without a doubt have a true sax sound through its range, a saxophonist can notice a tiny difference.

If there were absolutely no difference, then the choice of wood versus say "Ebonite" or plastic would be more of a marketing gimmick or teacher's prejudices. (I don't know, perhaps one of these days someone will come up with a synthetic matrix material that has properties so similar in resonance to wood that it gains popularity in professional grade instruments.)

Is the difference significant? I've played both Ebonite and wood and in truth, one can play a symphonic band part just as well on one as the other. (We used to use the "beginner" Ebonites for outdoor performances where if struck by inclimate weather (rain), it was preferred to "ruin" a cheap instrument rather than an expensive one. An oddity, back in the mid 1980's whilst drilling with the 91st Training Division Band, Army Reserve in Saucelito, CA, I was issued a brand new Selmer Bundy Ebonite clarinet. It was the first clarinet I played that was close to perfect pitch throughout its range, even better than the Buffet Crampon woody I played with the 264th in Honolulu, HI in the early 1970's.)

My early 1950's Beaugnier Vito low Bb baritone saxophone has a slightly darker tone to it versus my newer Antigua Winds low A bari. To the listening audience, would one shine more than the other in solo performance? I think not.

Apologies for my verboseness, although there is slight discernable differences in timbre in construction materials of wood versus metal versus plastic, when it comes to performance, and although there are critics who would be able to argue on the pin head of a needle the differences, in reality, most listeners really don't care. It is the skill of the musician that makes the performance.

Your take?
Most misinformation. The audible difference between clarinets is due to their internal geometry. Does an ebonite Bundy sound different than a grenadilla Buffet? Well, yes, duh. They are different models made by different companies.

Ever notice that all grenadilla clarinets sound the same? What, they don’t? Why not?
 
Most misinformation. The audible difference between clarinets is due to their internal geometry. Does an ebonite Bundy sound different than a grenadilla Buffet? Well, yes, duh. They are different models made by different companies.

Ever notice that all grenadilla clarinets sound the same? What, they don’t? Why not?
It's their internal geometry.

The Bb Soprano Clarinets with the bigger bore (Selmers, haven't kept up) are usually preferred for jazz whereas the narrower (earlier Buffets, I haven't kept up with the latest) were preferred for classical music.

However, a competent musician on either will do either jazz or classical very well, and the audience overall could care less.

Could you clarify "most misinformation?"
 
It's their internal geometry.

The Bb Soprano Clarinets with the bigger bore (Selmers, haven't kept up) are usually preferred for jazz whereas the narrower (earlier Buffets, I haven't kept up with the latest) were preferred for classical music.

However, a competent musician on either will do either jazz or classical very well, and the audience overall could care less.

Could you clarify "most misinformation?"

You make sweeping claims regarding the difference between clarinets made of differing materials while failing to notice the difference in their internal geometries, hence your assertions are false.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,420
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom