Tech/maintenance The ideal pad

If I was going to redesign an saxophone from the point of view of tone holes and pads, and this is purely my personal view, not founded on any technical basis:

My first question would be - why is it that the bit that moves also the has the squishy bit (pad)? Would it not be better to have the moving part rigid and inflexible and have the the flexible part on a non-moving surface i.e the tone hole rim?

I'd have in place of a pad, a rigid and flat piece of material in plastic or metal depending on preference.

Then a ring of silicone with a 'U' shaped profile fitted on top the tone hole rim. Some experimenting world be required to determine composition firmness and depth etc and effect on tuning and player feel. The silicone could also remove the need for perfectly flat tone holes.

Smaller holes such as octave pips could just use a solid piece of silicone in place of a pad.
Well it has been tried by Selmer USA
View: https://youtu.be/txR7HW_aL5Y?si=e4zSrcYt7hUXGU9d
 
On the other hand.
Materials, basically, matching the OP certainly exist. Polyurethane or silicone sealant/calcs are cheap, flexible, not tacky etc. And there are epoxy like materials which set but are flexible.

Seems to me the process would be a bit delicate. Given a fitted, empty key cap; you'd have to fill it, level it, allow it to firm up just enough, form it around the tone holl - while not letting it stick to that surface, clean up the excess... Allow it to cure, hope there's no shrinkage, flow etc.
And repeat, if it's not perfect because it'd be difficult if not impossible to adjust.
And a pile of steps more you'll only discover once you try.

Worth a try?

The thing is it's not just the material, but the processes; fitting, maintenance, etc.

Oh, and, you'd need to test the various alternatives for Coefficient of restitution - how bouncy are they...
The way I would envisage it working is to roll it out like Play-doh, (that would be the initial consistency) cut each 🔴 to approximate slightly larger size using a cookie-cutter template set, add resonator, pop onto a little flat spoon (pizza oven style) and line up under the (pad-less) key cup. Press into place. Close 'dollop-pad' over tonehole. Secure in place with some duct tape over the key arm, so it will stay shut until the pad sets. Pare off excess around the key cap edge.
But, like I wrote, until the right material comes along, this is just a saxophone shaped pipe dream 😉
 
That was my point exactly!
The concept I envisage would not fundamentally change the instrument, and would be retro-fittable next time your pads need changing. Perhaps only the first such occasion would require taking the keys off and cleaning the cups of residual shellac etc, see my other comment about the fitting...
 
The way I would envisage it working is to roll it out like Play-doh, (that would be the initial consistency) cut each 🔴 to approximate slightly larger size using a cookie-cutter template set, add resonator, pop onto a little flat spoon (pizza oven style) and line up under the (pad-less) key cup. Press into place. Close 'dollop-pad' over tonehole. Secure in place with some duct tape over the key arm, so it will stay shut until the pad sets. Pare off excess around the key cap edge.
But, like I wrote, until the right material comes along, this is just a saxophone shaped pipe dream 😉
I think you watched too much Blue Peter.
 
It's common place to form highly complex parts metal parts to 100ths of a millimetre -just look at machinery -yet saxophones are produced so imprecisely by comparison. 🤔
 
like I wrote, until the right material comes along, this is just a saxophone shaped pipe dream
Sure, I understand that - it's just that saying it'll work when everything is perfect is trivially true. The thing is, I've never seen something that magically doesn't stick when you don't want it to and does when it should. Even epoxy putty is still sticky and...
Close 'dollop-pad' over tonehole. Secure in place with some duct tape over the key arm, so it will stay shut until the pad sets.
...if you put it in a key cap then duct tape it shut... You'll have built a lamp stand.
 
Do innovations flow from low end products to high-end?
In many areas it's the other way around. R&D tends to be put into premium products, which cover the costs (protected by patents) and once discounted, and factories start selling overrun to their mate round the corner and copying starts etc. the mass market get the benefits.
I wasn't saying without copyrights at all. A lot of products become so niche by getting tied in to exclusive deals that they get strangled before they've even started and they're also often marketed at such a premium you rule out a lot of the consumer demographic.

Ideally there would be a product that would be retrofitable in a way that was entirely reversible perhaps alongside a purpose built series of saxophones.
 
The Selmer Padless (actually a Buescher product) was on the right track, I believe, just about 50 years too early for the materials needed.

Using a low-durometer synthetic rubber for the sealing rings rather than leather would go a long way to solving the issues with the Padless.

I believe that ribbed construction would be called for. Realistically, soldered toneholes would also help add some rigidity to the system. The weakness I think would be the thin sheet metal the toneholes are attached to. Even minor distortion in a system with so much less compliance would cause leaks that the more compliant leather pad can accommodate - maybe not with zero leakage, but possibly with less. However, the relative long term reliabilty of the mating of key plate to seal is speculative.

Someday when the work's all done I'd like to get an el cheapo sax and try it; the construction isn't at all exotic, and a wide variety of elastomers are now available.
 
It's common place to form highly complex parts metal parts to 100ths of a millimetre -just look at machinery -yet saxophones are produced so imprecisely by comparison. 🤔
well, replace the thin rolled and formed sheet metal of the body with a thick walled casting, machined, and you can do that. Saxophones are made to sheet metal tolerances, because they're made out of sheet metal.
 
There are other ways a building wind instruments... But would this still be a sax?
A saxophone is a conical single reed keyed instrument that overblows the octave. You might want to confine the angle of the cone to a certain range. That's the definition of a saxophone.
 
A saxophone is a conical single reed keyed instrument that overblows the octave. You might want to confine the angle of the cone to a certain range. That's the definition of a saxophone.
Technically, or rather, philosophically; it was saxyjt that mentioned definition. I dont, philosophically, believe definitions are all that useful outside of formal systems.
 
I wasn't saying without copyrights at all. A lot of products become so niche by getting tied in to exclusive deals that they get strangled before they've even started and they're also often marketed at such a premium you rule out a lot of the consumer demographic.

Ideally there would be a product that would be retrofitable in a way that was entirely reversible perhaps alongside a purpose built series of saxophones.
That's what I'm aiming for with my system, but it sure takes a long time to perfect. At present the entirely reversible version is coming to fruition, just waiting for the next set of custom parts from the US. I think I have everything else... BUT... we're moving house soon. probably to another renovation project, so that may take my eye off the ball rather.
 
It's common place to form highly complex parts metal parts to 100ths of a millimetre -just look at machinery -yet saxophones are produced so imprecisely by comparison. 🤔
Saxophone making is not an exact science. If it was, they would all be identical in geometry.

And the beauty of it is also there, like sailboats or ... humans.
 
It's common place to form highly complex parts metal parts to 100ths of a millimetre -just look at machinery -yet saxophones are produced so imprecisely by comparison. 🤔
As an aside, the archeology of musical instruments book contends that the bronze age, Danish 'lure' horns (see Lurepack Butter) are made to a tolerance of 1-2mm. No valves, mind you.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,460
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom