Playing the saxophone The Harmonic Minor scale without sharps and flats

Sorry if it wasn't clear . Let me try with an example. D harmonic minor starts 1 2 3b in the key of D so that is just DEF now take a gap of a tone and get to G so do it again in the key of G and get GABb finally add in 7 8 in the key of D so that is C# D. The point is the last 2 notes nobody is going to forget. The rest of the scale is put together using two 3 note pieces which are easy to play anywhere on the sax without too much thought. If you know your circle of fourths you don't need to worry about that tone gap in the middle either. Just play the 3 notes and go to the next place round the circle.

This makes total sense to me, it's a good way to think about it IMO
 
Sorry if it wasn't clear . Let me try with an example. D harmonic minor starts 1 2 3b in the key of D so that is just DEF now take a gap of a tone and get to G so do it again in the key of G and get GABb finally add in 7 8 in the key of D so that is C# D. The point is the last 2 notes nobody is going to forget. The rest of the scale is put together using two 3 note pieces which are easy to play anywhere on the sax without too much thought. If you know your circle of fourths you don't need to worry about that tone gap in the middle either. Just play the 3 notes and go to the next place round the circle.

I agree all this needs to be automatic and subconscious but initially one has to think about what one is doing and how to do it with least brain power. The whole scale is WH W WH (W+H) H. I put the spaces in to complement my idea. Great if you can learn how it sounds and just play the sound in a different place. My ears/fingers are not up for that yet but getting there with the 1 2 3b idea.
This makes total sense to me, it's a good way to think about it IMO

I see... There is some American book (like that Miller guy about modal jazz) that uses smaller groups of notes.
Good to memorize, but personally I would loose the bigger picture. For me 123 and 567 are completely different, even if they share the WH grid. But it might just be that I had a conservative education.
 
My thinking would be up on the B half diminished chord down on 3 9b 1 7b in E then 3b 2 1 in A and has it happens those 7 notes are just running down the A Harmonic minor scale,
Like this... Minor modes were originally "Dorian" (Scarlatti Senior) then "Natural" (Scarlatti Junior, Vivaldi, Bach....).
The Harmonic and Melodic scales were a formalized way to describe the leading note occurring on the dominant chord.

Sometimes we still find the obsolete (but cute) Dm7b5 Gm7 Cm
No leading note.
 
leading note occurring on the dominant chord.
This is of course the reason for different descending melodic minor in classical. It reverts to the mode because the leading note was only necessary when ascending to the tonic.

So it was really a case of an accidental to give a more satisfactory cadence without losing the modalness overall.

Green sleeves is an example of this happening
 
Then I realised a simple way to get the scale without thinking of sharps and flats at all. It is just 1 2 3b in I followed after a step of a tone by 1 2 3b in IV and then 7 8 in I. Easy Peasy
The down side to this is that it doesn't help you also learn the chord tones, as starting your second block on the 4th would actually emphasise that note.
 
The down side to this is that it doesn't help you also learn the chord tones, as starting your second block on the 4th would actually emphasise that note.
Same critic that I have for the system where you learn the major scale as in
CDEF
GABC

as in blocks with the same WWH WWH grid.
Pretty far from the actual major scale sound
 
Same critic that I have for the system where you learn the major scale as in
CDEF
GABC

as in blocks with the same WWH WWH grid.
Pretty far from the actual major scale sound


This is better IMO, because it still gives you a framework of the chord notes.

CDEF
GABC

With the minor scale in blocks of three:

D
EF
GABb
C#D
 
Say that you are in A minor
II V I is
Bm7(b5) E7(b9) Am7

You use A minor natural starting from B on Bm7(b5)
A harmonic minor starting from E on E7(b9) but you don'y stop on A
A minor natural on Am7, but you don't stop on F

it is actually pretty simple: in a minor key we use the natural minor (well...) unless the underlying chord is the V. In that case we use the harmonic or the melodic

:headscratch:
As a newcomer to jazz, I find discussions of chord sequences rather mystifying.

I think @aldevis is saying that the chords are
II: B D F A
V: E G# B D (F?)
I: A C E G

So we just use the notes from the A-minor-natural home key (i.e. the white notes) except for the G# in the V chord.
Is this correct?

Is there a simple explanation (for dummies) why the V chord uses G# rather than G?

What does: "you don't stop on A" and "you don't stop on F" mean?
 
I think @aldevis is saying that the chords are
II: B D F A
V: E G# B D (F?)
I: A C E G

So we just use the notes from the A-minor-natural home key (i.e. the white notes) except for the G# in the V chord.
Is this correct?
Yes

Is there a simple explanation (for dummies) why the V chord uses G# rather than G?
It sounds better.
Or the ascending semitone G#-A creates a stronger tension (dominates better) than G-A.

What does: "you don't stop on A" and "you don't stop on F" mean?
I should have added "You don't stop on G on Bm7b5"

It means that on each chord, those notes don't sit well as static extensions. They need to resolve somewhere.


Of course it is not always like this...
 
The ambiguity lies on the fact that we are talking modes and chords at the same time. That is where the issues with the minor mode exist.
I don't consider the harmonic or melodic minors modes, in most pre-George Russell styles; just an adaptation of the original minor mode (natural or "dorian")
 
Is there a simple explanation (for dummies) why the V chord uses G# rather than G?

Before answering that, I would want to know if you have a keyboard to try things out with. If not then any answer is going to be quite longwinded.

However try this very simple process.

Play a C (on keyboard or saxophone) so that your brain is grounded in the tonality of C.

Then play G - A - B. You should hear how the next note "wants" to be C, ie it has a strong tendency to resolve (or come home) to C

Now do the same but play G A Bb. Is there the same tendency to lead up to the C ??

An end of phrase e.g. coming home) is called a cadence, and an important part of a cadence is this semitone lead up to the tonic (from the 3rd of the V7 chord to the root of the tonic)

This leading tendency is made even more strong by the presence of the dissonant tritone

EDIT: this is the interval between F (3rd) and B (7th) in the G7. There is no tritone in Gm7, because it is Bb and F, an interval of a perfect fifth.

This is where you need a keyboard.

If it is Gm7 to C there is

  • No semitone leading note
  • No tritone to cause tension

It is this tension and release from V7 to I that makes this type of cadence very useful in many types of tonal music

In a modal V I cadence, e.g. Gm7 to Cm, if you play it on a keyboard and compare to G7 to Cm, you will hear how it sounds weaker as a cadence in that it doesn't have as much tension which is satisfyingly released.

So it's all about these key elements of music:
  • melodic tendency of leading note
  • harmonic interest through tension and release
 
Last edited:
I don't consider the harmonic or melodic minors modes, in most pre-George Russell styles; just an adaptation of the original minor mode (natural or "dorian")

I agree totally. They aren't modes in my book either. (The major scale is, of course, ionian mode)
 
Play a C (on keyboard or saxophone) so that your brain is grounded in the tonality of C.

Then play G - A - B. You should hear how the next note "wants" to be C, ie it has a strong tendency to resolve (or come home) to C

Now do the same but play G A Bb. Is there the same tendency to lead up to the C ??

OK. I understand. Many thanks.

This leading tendency is made even more strong by the presence of the dissonant tritone. This is where you need a keyboard.

If it is Gm7 to C there is

  • No semitone leading note
  • No tritone to cause tension

Now I'm confused again. Which note is the tritone?
I believe a tritone is an augmented fourth(diminished fifth), so tritone for C is F#/Gb, tritone for G is C#/Db.
 
Now I'm confused again. Which note is the tritone?
I believe a tritone is an augmented fourth(diminished fifth), so tritone for C is F#/Gb, tritone for G is C#/Db.

In the chord of G7 it is the B and F.

The B has a tendency to resolve up a semitone to C, the F has a tendency to resolve down a semitone to E, of if you are in C minor then down a tone to Eb
 
The down side to this is that it doesn't help you also learn the chord tones, as starting your second block on the 4th would actually emphasise that note.
I fail to see a problem. Regardless of how one learns the construction of scales, the tonic triad is still 1 3 5. To me the real benefit of seeing a major scale as two W W H patterns separated by a whole step, or a natural minor as two W H W patterns separated by a whole step is that when one learns a scale, the last four tones (2nd tetrachord) match the first four tones (1st tetrachord) of the next scale clockwise in the circle of 5ths. This is an aid in learning the fingering patterns of scales as well as the theory.
 
I fail to see a problem.
Assuming that all notes have equal length, noted on strong beats are more important than notes on weak beats. (I practise scales to the 9th for this reason)

I do not like the major tetrachords, because if I don't accent the odd notes, each tetrachord feels like C to F (V-I of F) and G to C (V-I of C).

When we think that there are only 12 major scales, I believe that it is better to build WWHWWWH 12 times, than looking for shortcuts, when it comes to fingerings.
Fingerwise, all the other scales are just adaptations coming from the major (except 3 diminished and 2 hexatonic).
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,674
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom