Playing the saxophone The Harmonic Minor scale without sharps and flats

You said all you needed was the key, and your ears would do the rest. Just wanted to hear how well that worked.
I have to agree with Colin. It actually works very well for a lot of people in a lot of genres.

Yes, Giant Steps may be tricky but I didn’t infer that he meant that kind of music necessarily.

And if you think about it, possibly the majority of musicians get by in the world without ever wanting or needing to play Giant Steps. I know for a fact if I was asked to play it or similar (in public) I would politely decline as I don’t have the skill to do it justice.
 
I have to agree with Colin. It actually works very well for a lot of people in a lot of genres.

Yes, Giant Steps may be tricky but I didn’t infer that he meant that kind of music necessarily.

And if you think about it, possibly the majority of musicians get by in the world without ever wanting or needing to play Giant Steps. I know for a fact if I was asked to play it or similar (in public) I would politely decline as I don’t have the skill to do it justice.
Doesn’t have to be Giant Steps. But there are a lot of tricky changes in tunes that ear players who completely ignore all theory crash and burn on. Many have come through my bands over the years. My point is that completely ignoring theory doesn’t always work unless you are exceptionally gifted. My hat is off to ear players who can play complex lines over complex changes. Sounds like Colin is the real deal.
 
Yep, there's the bridge to the girl with Emphysema; Joy Spring (one of my favorites to call and watch people scuffle); One Note Samba, and a bunch more.
 
My point is that completely ignoring theory doesn’t always work unless you are exceptionally gifted.
Yes I know such players. No, probably not get Giant Steps but may be due to the tempo, but can get key centres and changes by ear that I certainly can't.

To be honest I believe I've never had a great ear, but somehow got by.
 
I've tried hard over the last 10 years or more not to let this become an either/or issue. Knowing some theory makes it much easier to learn and categorise (and hence remember) songs and lines and to find them on my instrument. And ear training (of which I've done a ton because I seriously needed it)) helps me to associate those theoretical ideas with sounds. They reinforce each other. I'll take all the tools and help I can get my hands/ears on.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom