Saxophones The Alphabet of Tone

Early in this thread you chose the word “sweet” for your sound. We’ve never heard your sound therefore we cannot comprehend your categorisation of your own sound.

“Sweet” is such a an unhelpful word in this case. You might as well use “pretty “.

I used the word Sweet in reference to an Orsi - not "my" sound - its what came to mind.
The Orsi sounds different the Hohner which sounds different to the Huller which sounds different to the Grassi.

You seem hell-bent on argumentative one-upmanship rather than being constructive. You don't need to participate if you're find this discussion not to your liking.
 
I used the word Sweet in reference to an Orsi - not "my" sound - its what came to mind.
The Orsi sounds different the Hohner which sounds different to the Huller which sounds different to the Grassi.

You seem hell-bent on argumentative one-upmanship rather than being constructive. You don't need to participate if you're find this discussion not to your liking.
Actually, I make references to teaching - I have been taught a lot in my life and also taught myself. You don’t ever reference this. You still refuse to talk about examples either, musical / sound examples. We are talking about sound in this thread after all, not words.
You’ve given me several jibes so far, which I’ll take as confirmation that you don’t want to cede any of the points I and others have made. Stop being crotchety and enter into discussion.
 
No - we are not talking about sound - we are (ideally) discussing tone, the way we perceive tone and the variations of tone when expressed by a saxophone.

You mentioned Sweet could be changed for Pretty. Well a young woman could be Pretty but her disposition would not be - her disposition would be Sweet.

Phrases such as centered / focused / spread / dark / warm etc etc etc have been in use when describing tonal character of instruments for eons - its nothing new - and YOU want me to quantify those phrases that are not of my invention? YOU can either comprehend or you cannot. "I" suspect YOU don't wish to. I'll say it again YOU do not have to participate here.

Why don't YOU go back through this thread and make note of the purile, flippant comments that bring NO constructive dialogue whatsoever. The topic is perception of "tone".
 
No - we are not talking about sound - we are (ideally) discussing tone, the way we perceive tone and the variations of tone when expressed by a saxophone.

You mentioned Sweet could be changed for Pretty. Well a young woman could be Pretty but her disposition would not be - her disposition would be Sweet.

Phrases such as centered / focused / spread / dark / warm etc etc etc have been in use when describing tonal character of instruments for eons - its nothing new - and YOU want me to quantify those phrases that are not of my invention? YOU can either comprehend or you cannot. "I" suspect YOU don't wish to. I'll say it again YOU do not have to participate here.

Why don't YOU go back through this thread and make note of the purile, flippant comments that bring NO constructive dialogue whatsoever. The topic is perception of "tone".
Ok Mr Angry, you’re shouting again. Take some more Valium.
 
You don't need to participate if you're find this discussion not to your liking.
This of course true. I'm finding it a useful discussion - whether or not the terms themselves are or become useful. It's all food for thought so definitely worth discussing.

The point may not be to define so much as to supply food for thought.

The problem I see (apart from the fact that many or most of the words are subjective) is that many of the words used for sound originate as words for other things (warm, bright, dark)

The ironic thing that struck me is that there are already perfectly good words that do relate directly to sound - used when discussing audio ton, but are almost never used for saxophone tone: e.g. toppy, trebly, bassy.
 
Phrases such as centered / focused / spread / dark / warm etc etc etc have been in use when describing tonal character of instruments for eons - its nothing new - and YOU want me to quantify those phrases that are not of my invention? YOU can either comprehend or you cannot. "I" suspect YOU don't wish to. I'll say it again YOU do not have to participate here.
I’m sure that you’re right in that these terms have been used for years. However, in all that time no one has seen fit to explain them in terms that can be quantified, ie. What are the proportions of the various overtones that produce a ‘centred’ sound, for instance?
 
A new mouthpiece launch video from GS Sax in the last 14 hours:

View: https://youtu.be/mrs8EdeRV9Y?si=0QrW_p1ii93F9gw2


This throws up at least three new terms:
  • Complexity
  • Punch
  • Lyrical / Singing
But I'm not sure these, particularly the last, are about tone - perhaps in some way I don't yet understand, the characteristics of that mouthpiece encourage its owner to play in a specific way ?

Unless the community can relate each useful term to an objectively measurable property of a saxophone's sound (e.g. the frequency spectrum of notes, covering the whole range of the instrument) then it seems like a free for all of pick your own term or analogy and use it to mean whatever you want it mean.

Rhys
 
I’m sure that you’re right in that these terms have been used for years. However, in all that time no one has seen fit to explain them in terms that can be quantified,
Centered in regard to clarinets was explained by Selmer in their as deep and woody
What are the proportions of the various overtones that produce a ‘centred’ sound, for instance?
I'm sure you won't get a consensus on this as most players do not have the apparatus to measure overtones very precisely. It would also have to be measured when played without any extra influence from the player's embouchure, how do you do that? Two players may sound completely different. And presumably any experimentation would need consistency of mouthpiece and reed as well.

I couldn't even start because I dont really know what the term means anyway.

Other descriptive terms we haven't mentioned are probably the most important, i.e. nice and nasty.
 
then it seems like a free for all of pick your own term or analogy and use it to mean whatever you want it mean.
That hits the nail on the head!
Unless the community can relate each useful term to an objectively measurable property of a saxophone's sound (e.g. the frequency spectrum of notes,
I did attempted just that in regard to subtone:

With:
subtone-waveform-tongued.jpg


Without
subtone-waveform-fulltone.jpg
 
I used the word Sweet in reference to an Orsi - not "my" sound - its what came to mind.
I'm going to throw another fly into the ointment, because I differntiate between tone and sound.

For me tone is the inherent tone of the saxophone, whereas sound is what a player adds to the tone - can be vibrato, dynamics, pitch, articulation and other expressive devices.I can image a player's sound being sweet (and it may not be the same definition as yours) but I'm finding it difficult to think of a tone being described as sweet.
 
Without getting into vocabulary words, it seems to me that the nature of a player's TONE really resides in the points where something changes. Play just a plain straight note, no inflections at all. It's actually pretty boring. There's some difference from person to person, or from equipment to equipment, but not very interesting. Now add attacks, releases, vibrato, accents, and the way a person moves from one note to the next - that's where the actual interest is, and I would suggest, that's where you'll find these qualities people try to describe with vocabulary words.

You'll note that when we try out a new piece of equipment, we don't just play long notes. No, we apply scales, patterns, little melodic fragments, even entire long phrases or chunks of music. Again, I suggest that it's the points of change in the sound that make the difference in what's perceived either by the player or the listener.
 
That ought to be easy to quantify/define then. ‘Woody’ means all the even number harmonics are missing.

Arghhh .....

I would say the such tones are "clarinetty". "Woody" as a descriptive term for tone would have no place in my glossary. And neither would "chocolatey" or "silky" or "crystalline" or most of the descriptive terms that people bandy around when they choose to make analogies to things other than sound.

Rhys
 
There is interesting discussion here - and - flipant comment - as can be expected. Eventually we'll have our Alphabet.
Seeing as we don't have any AI, I'll just have to do the summary myself of words so far (not including anything deemed too flippant)

Airy
Alive
Ballsy
Big
Booming
Brassy
Bright
Broad
Centered
Complex
Core
Dark
Deep
Delicate
Dull
Edgy
Fat
Floaty
Focused
Light
Lush
Lyrical
Mellow
Muted
Nasal
Pretty
Punchy
Quiet
Rich
Ripping
Round
Shrill
Singing
Small
Smokey
Spread
Sweet
Thin
Vibrant
Warm
Woody

Oddly, nobody has mention breathy - good word surely that may be one of the more quantifiable ones
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,438
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom