Playing the saxophone Tenor & Alto

prelude1

Member
Messages
66
I'm a beginner and I have both saxes now... Been playing the tenor for the last couple weeks, loving it... It seems easier than my Alto......buuut I played my 55 Buescher Alto and, wow...love that too... Thing is it appears that it seems easier after playing my Tenor for that last week or so....I was wondering if I would see a preference after playing both but it doesn't appear to be the case....I love both sounds....
Cheers.
 
It would have got easier after a few week of practice anyway!

Good to like both - better than disliking both, anyway.

Keep going
Of course that makes sense..lol...but they do play different...I don't find it takes very much more air for a tenor....a little but not what I was expecting after reading up on the difference.
 
I found that playing tenor improved my alto playing. And vice versa. Both have things to teach you, and if you have the time to maintain your chops on both you will benefit greatly. As well as getting more gigs - or rather, “opportunities to play”.
 
I found that playing tenor improved my alto playing. And vice versa. Both have things to teach you, and if you have the time to maintain your chops on both you will benefit greatly.
I agree although you might that learning one might disadvantage learning the other this doesn’t seem to happen. There are possibly issues if you have developed your ears to the extent that you associate pitches with fingerings.

For example hearing something in the key of Bb, after playing a lot of alto your brain/fingers may automatically or subconsciously go to the G fingering.
 
@prelude1
From one beginner to another - I've been learning to play an alto (YAS-25) for three months and got a tenor (YTS-25) a couple of weeks ago.

There are similar questions to yours on here and I asked the same and of course got conflicting answers :rolleyes:

Some say learn one properly before you switch to another, others say do what feels good to you, practice both as they have different approaches and the practice on one can benefit the other e.g. embouchure, breath control etc. My teacher is of the latter camp and I am currently doing a week on one then a week on the other. I feel, in my limited experience, that it is working. It might take a minute or so to get the embouchure right but not a great problem (for me, others may have different experiences).

Like you I find the tenor 'easier' than the alto and overall I prefer the tenor - timbre, ergonomics, size of mpc, ease of blowing etc but also love the sweetness of the alto, so I will be learning on both. If I find it confusing then I might consider specialising in one until I feel more able. Different strokes for different folks!
For example hearing something in the key of Bb, after playing a lot of alto your brain/fingers may automatically or subconsciously go to the G fingering.
That is an issue but I think will be manageable over time. I tend to 'hear' in Bb and the switch to Eb can be disconcerting at first 😳

Enjoy the journey whichever horn you blow 🎷
 
Had to choose a car

saxcar.webp
 
Just finished today's practice which was a bit of an experiment - played the alto and the tenor one after the other.
Did scales and some long tones on the alto, then switched to tenor and did the same with no problem. I did need to adjust my embouchure but it was almost subconscious.
Back to alto and played my 'homework' (Autumn Leaves) plus Fly Me to the Moon and Can't Help Falling in Love, then switched to tenor and did the same; I was equally appalling on both 😱
MrsC has caught some bug and is resting in bed; I asked her if my playing had disturbed her and she said Autumn Leaves sent her to sleep :rofl:
Also some tunes fit better on one than the other.
Yes, I thought Fly Me sounded better on alto, Autumn Leaves on tenor.
 
MrsC has caught some bug and is resting in bed; I asked her if my playing had disturbed her and she said Autumn Leaves sent her to sleep
I’ve been playing saxophone for over 60 years and Autumn Leaves puts me to sleep too. I’ve learned to look like I am in the zone when playing it. In reality I am in the Zzzzzzzzz…..
 
At about 2 minutes in, you might try this on Alto, hopefully, in the future. :thumb:
Nothing wrong with learning Alto and tenor, except for the tenor. :hugging:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpB7-8SGlJ0

Slow it down and try a lick or two, on either horn.
That is so good, really beautiful, thank you.
If one day I get to be 1% as good as that I'll be happy :doh:Maybe even 0.1%!
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,393
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom