Intonation Temperature and tuning

Yep. Hotter, sharper... colder, flatter. Moreso the smaller the instrument. This is my experience going from plaice-d tenor to highly clam-ed top note alto.
Simon

(Cue acoustic physicist flaming retort...) 🙂
 
The real killer is changing temperature while you're playing. The worst spot at any festival gig is playing while the sun is going down- looks beautiful but the temperature drop causes havoc with brass.
 
simon wrote:
Yep. Hotter, sharper... colder, flatter.
(Cue acoustic physicist flaming retort...) 🙂

I haven't noticed either way as I don't need tempearture changes to be out of tune.

You would think that as the metal would expand as it gets hotter, the tube becomes longer and the pitch flatter. I'm not arguing about it though...
 
Pete Thomas wrote:

You would think that as the metal would expand as it gets hotter, the tube becomes longer and the pitch flatter. I'm not arguing about it though...

That was how I was thinking of it, not only would the tube get longer, but also wider - whatever way it expanded, it would increase in volume and therefore flatten the pitch. But no, once again science goes against intuitive thinking.

The main reason I was asking is because last night I went down to the lakes on a duck-startling mission, and noticed that in the 3deg C temperature the soprano was flat. Not just a bit, but a lot, like nearly a semitone with the mpc in its usual place. The alto was out by some way, and the tenor a little. I thought because I haven't been playing for about 10 days it was me.

Cheers, Bob
 
The speed of sound (in meters per second) in air is 331.5 + 0.6 T, where T represents the temperature in Celsius degrees.
At room temperature (20 degrees Celsius) that comes out to 343.5 m/sec.

For a one-degree increase in temperature the speed of sound increases by 0.6 meters per second.
In percentage language that's 0.6/343 = 0.00175 = 0.175%.

The frequency of a standing wave in a wind instrument is proportional to the speed of sound. Therefore the fractional or percentage change in frequency due to a temperature change will be equal to the corresponding fractional or percentage change in sound speed. (The effect of thermal expansion of the brass is insignificant compared to that of the air.)

This means that the frequency of a note played on a wind instrument will want to increase by about 0.175% for each Celsius degree of temperature increase.

A semitone is a 5.95% change in frequency. Since 0.175 divided by 5.95 comes out to be 0.03, we expect a pitch change of about 3 cents for each one-degree (C) change in temperature. (Remember, a "cent" in this context is one hundreth of a semitone.)

In other words it's the air temperature that changes the speed of sound that alters the pitch and not the - as stated above - thermal expansion of the metal.

gruss - spike
 
I don't think air pressure would have an effect, unless you were very high and weren't getting enough oxygen yourself, you might find you end up playing everything in 2 bar phrases.

as to the temperature affecting the soprano more I really don't know why. My guess is probably because it is smaller. Nature tends to pick on the smaller of things.
 
the question is whether or not air pressure has an effect on the speed of sound, if so, then yes it will affect the frequency, otherwise then not.

So if you live in a temperate climate, wrap up warm, keep reasonably cool and don't get high on gigs and you should be allright.

gruss - spike
 
I've had this discussion a few times before over the years which is why I know a tiny little bit about it and - Just to add another complication to the matter, the ammount of CO2 in the air also has an effect on the speed of sound and since the air we exhale has a high CO2 content, it also effects our tuning, so just blow hard and play louder than the guitarist and keep asking him if he's got new strings on.

gruss - spike
 
If what you're sayin is true, and I have no doubt that it is, then it seems a band would simply have to tune to the ambient temp and go on with it.

In reality, though, there is real difficulty tuning up cold (unplayed) horns, no matter what the air temp is. When the horns warm up, the tuning seems to revert to where it ought to be.

This would seem to indicate that the temperature of the brass, and/or the mouthpiece, was making a difference.
 
Yes Lee, this is of course correct, I omitted the explanation above because of an acute attack of sloth, the metal parts will at first have the same ambient temperature as the surrounding air however as soon as the player blows into the horn, the temperature of the metal will gradually rise due to the higher temp of the exhaled breath, - the greater the difference between the human body temperature and the ambient temp, the greater the effect on the pitch (which is relative to the speed of sound, which is relative to the air temperature).

And it's all relative to the temperature of my Beck's which tastes better when consumed cooler than the surrounding air and considerably cooler than the normal body temperature, which in turn raises the question as to whether or not the Beck's temperature has an effect on whether I'm in tune or not.

gruss - spike
 
spike wrote:
In space no-one can hear you scream.
Can you hear yourself scream though - or is it like watching Eduard Munch.

Yes, you can hear yourself as the sound is transmitted to the ear via various bits of bone and stuff. The realisation that you have just exploded in an airless and weightless environment will not, however, register on your ex-consciousness.

Cheers, Bob
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,307
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom