Teaching Student choosing the teacher’s method

Pete Thomas

Admin
Cafe Moderator
Messages
23,611
Location
London
Level
Retired professional
I hope eb424 doesn’t mind me quoting him from another thread to start off a new one here.

If I'm paying for their time surely I should take my agenda out of the lessons.

If this means what I think it does (ie the student should be able to say what methods a teacher uses) then I think it could be quite an interesting discussion hence starting the new thread.

What do you think?
 
I'll kick orf then...if i haven't already.. lol..is methods the same as agenda or are methods the tools to reach the goals?

Where does theory fit in.. ? At an older age is playing for fun the main objective..Darn you still want to be the best you can..Need feedback tho.. how? I know buy recording gear darn that daily 90 mins selfishly dedicated as my sax time isn't enough, need to play..Arghh. what are my goals, play as good as i can, darn gets isolating as a woodshed honker ( great term @thomsax ) right need to play with others darn cant read noted rhythm need to learn music theory, no time, gotta play..and so the saxy cycle continues..in isolation..

Ok its only been a short 6 year journey..fun and frustration..in my view you need a teacher..someone flexible enough tho to guide you and empower you to achievement..I have had 4 teachers and been to others that were so rigid in theory and jazz for improv i thought they were starch addicts...lol..

Right now i have 2 on standby ( i see on an as and when basis) Paul who has played for years and is great at articulation and not pricey as he does it for pin money..Sophya is great and flexible enough to accept how i play i e. Write out the lyrics with notes above and play to backing tracks. She is going to assess my 10 songs and give me constructive criticism on what I need to do to play 20 tracks in the carehome..HopefuIly work on some improv theory.. I would like to say that without the cafe and the genourous knowledge sharing by the people here and resources supplied by @Pete Thomas I would have been lost..

Yes a teacher is important for the fundementals AND ongoing support. Yes music theory is important the circle of 5ths is critically interesting and downright fascinating, key sigs, transposition, note recognition, all need addressing and learning in my mind..However certain issues, phrasing, timming, rhythm, improv and articulation to a certain degree can be learnt in an alternative manner..I don't feel that this is accepted as much as it could be out there..
Now in typical teacher terminology "discuss" lol
 
.is methods the same as agenda or are methods the tools to reach the goals?
You could say methods means the same as agenda, basically meaning the things the teacher gets you to learn in the lesson.

Of course everything must be aiming at a goal, whether that goal is to learn saxophone technique (which should be the main goal of saxophone lessons) or to also learn skills such as memorising tunes, sight-reading, theory, improvising, performance techniques. In other words become an all-round musician.

Where does theory fit in..
Some (very few) players attain a very high level without learning much theory. If they are great players they somehow have some innate ability to kind of subconsciously understand theory. I'm not exactly sure what that is, but is very rare.

Understanding theory helps you memorise tunes, read music, improvise in certain styles etc.
Write out the lyrics with notes above and play to backing tracks.
You've mentioned before you do this and plenty of people have said it's a bad thing to do instead of learning to read music. People think of it as a short cut, but actually IMO it's a very long cut. If you have been doing it for years then that proves the point, because learning to read music competently enough to read a basic lead sheet can be achieved in a few weeks.

Writing the note names (A, B, D etc.) above the lyric is a method that will never replace being able to read music or even prepare you for learning to read music because it is so limited in communicating a melody and completely incapable of communicating rhythm.
 
Last edited:
I had the money and willing to pay for some rock & roll saxophone teaching/leading/conducting. He wanted the money and told me he could help me. I was clear about what I wanted and that I was more or less autodidact. I had some basic knowledge in reading music, I have learned songs by ear and played from memory. The first thing he did was to give a the "Autumn Leaves" sheet music that he copied from the Fake Book. I was soo disappointed after the first lesson. The next lesson was the same. I told him that it was not what I wanted. I listened to Bobby Keys, Clarence Clemons and the music that they played. And it was a lot of money for me as well.

A music/sax teacher knows about methods and didactics beside music theory and also to master the sax. A sax teacher should be able to change/vary the lessons. Many good teaching sax players but just because you are a good player doesn't mean you can teach other?
 
You could say methods is the same as agenda, basically meaning what you do in the lesson.

Of course everything must be aiming at a goal, whether that goal is to learn saxophone technique (which should be the main goal of saxophone lessons) or to also learn skills such as memorising tunes, sight-reading, theory, improvising, performance techniques. In other words become an all-round musician.


Some (very few) players attain a very high level without learning much theory. If they are great players they somehow have som innate ability toe kind of subconsciously understand theory. I'm not exactly sure what that is, but is very rare.

Understanding theory helps you memorise tunes, read music, improvise in certain styles etc.

You've mentioned before you do this and plenty of people have said it's a bad thing to do instead of learning to read music. People think of it as a short cut, but actually IMO it's a very long cut. If you have been doing it for years then that proves the point, because learning to read music competently enough to read a basic lead sheet can be achieved in a few weeks.

Writing the note names (A, B, D etc.) above the lyric is a method that will never replace being able to read music or even prepare you for learning to read music because it is so limited in communicating a melody and completely incapable of communicating rhythm.
I do agree @Pete Thomas..but from my perspective im nearer the end of my paying than the beginning..Ut will only be for fun..I can read basic music and am learning in tandem with playing. The backing tracks give me my rhythm..The reason i do it the way i do is because playing the whole song most scores are 5 or six pages and i would need at least 2 music stands or have them on my tablet..as i learn the song i can get it all on 3 sheets and they will condense more..

Granted the method is more lobg winded but for my purpise so much more practical. I do have to read music to transpose and do it the way I do..just could never play fast enough or fit the 6 pages on 1 stand..
 
I had the money and willing to pay for some rock & roll saxophone teaching/leading/conducting. He wanted the money and told me he could help me. I was clear about what I wanted and that I was more or less autodidact. I had some basic knowledge in reading music, I have learned songs by ear and played from memory. The first thing he did was to give a the "Autumn Leaves" sheet music that he copied from the Fake Book. I was soo disappointed after the first lesson. The next lesson was the same. I told him that it was not what I wanted. I listened to Bobby Keys, Clarence Clemons and the music that they played. And it was a lot of money for me as well.

A music/sax teacher knows about methods and didactics beside music theory and also to master the sax. A sax teacher should be able to change/vary the lessons. Many good teaching sax players but just because you are a good player doesn't mean you can teach other?
Thats awful...but I'm sure quite common..there seems to be a lot of rigidity from people who can only teach the same way they learned..Flexibility is key "theres more tan one way of skinning a cat"..I think I have finally found a teacher that can or at least will accept that...
 
When I started lessons just over 12months ago, my teacher, told me he isn't a teacher, he doesn't know it all. But what he says is gospel, ie don't be watching YouTube videos, if I'm paying for lessons of him, listen to him.

I understand where he's coming from, and he doesn't want to be fighting against other trains of thought.

Lessons, we flew though one workbook, that he recommends, and I happened to have from school, at the end of that I got "well done, now you know what all the buttons do, now to teach to you to play"

He gave me more choices, do another book, venture into improvising.

I struggled with rhythm and timing, so opted for another book he recommended, that was certainly more challenging.

I've taken pieces of music for Christmas, to not open it and start playing by ear "what you going to do Christmas day, when the family is round, egging you on to play something, tell them to wait whilst you go get your stand & books?"

I've gone with niggles for it to be solved on minutes, or taken pieces for the orchestra I play with and run through those.

I want to get back into the improvising, he's suggested maybe doing a grading exam (for the structure)

One thing is for sure, my sound is far better than it was 12months ago (no mic needed for my solos) and my overall playing is far better, I'm sure he has a plan in his mind, and as yet he's been right in everything he's taught me.

Perhaps I've landed lucky, perhaps he's an brilliant teacher, but it certainly wouldn't work if I was being rail roaded down a route I didn't want.
 
For an adult learner, surely it's a negotiation; and everyone - teachers and students - have a range of positions they are prepared to land on.

in such situations, one of the stumbling points can be the student expressing just what they want to achieve - which, itself, may not be a fixed point. It happens often enough, here, that someone asks 'how do I do y' and people answer until someone says "why do you want to do y?" To which they reply "because I want to do x" and then people go "oh, well, to do x, you should do z. y won't work.."

so, yeah, it's up to the teacher to divine what the student really wants, at this point, to achieve and proposes a rout there. I'd guess that not all teachers have the skill/interest/time to do that. But if they do, it's up to the student to accept and commit to the path proposed ... and lots of students won't do that.
 
don't be watching YouTube videos, if I'm paying for lessons of him, listen to him.
I can understand that and (based on most of the Youtube videos I’ve seen) would say exactly the same. It's like going to two teachers with contrary advice because:

theres more tan one way of skinning a cat
 
Last edited:
… learning to read music competently enough to read a basic lead sheet can be achieved in a few weeks.

Writing the note names (A, B, D etc.) above the lyric is a method that will never replace being able to read music or even prepare you for learning to read music because it is so limited in communicating a melody and completely incapable of communicating rhythm.
Amen!
 
The reason i do it the way i do is because playing the whole song most scores are 5 or six pages and i would need at least 2 music stands or have them on my tablet..as i learn the song i can get it all on 3 sheets and they will condense more..

Granted the method is more lobg winded but for my purpise so much more practical. I do have to read music to transpose and do it the way I do..just could never play fast enough or fit the 6 pages on 1 stand..
If you could read the dots - including rhythm - competently, a couple of pages of score would suffice. No need for half a dozen.
 
Last edited:
Mr. Anecdote just tapped me on the shoulder.

A very good friend of mine and extremely good player took on a few students. One of them came to him one week and said "I've been doing some work on Joe Allard's method of embouchure" to which my buddy promptly replied "well you've now got a choice, you can either learn that **** or you can continue lessons with me."

This was totally fair enough IMO as trying to learn two totally different embouchure concepts at the same time is never really going to work very well.
 
In my formative years I was fortunate to take lessons from the principal clarinettist in the BBC Orchestra in Belfast...he gave me a very good grounding on playing the instrument,reading and theory..all with a classical bias and one day I said that I wanted to make money playing in a band as an objective..he produced a large reel to reel tape recording and switched it on saying "is this the type of stuff you mean"
Then Monty Sunshine blared out with "The Old Rugged Cross" and I was hookef...after that my lessons had a jazz or pop bias leading me to buy my first tenor and join a showbans...so sone teachers do have the ability and willingness to meet pupil's needs.I am forever indebted to that man for all that he taught me.
 
Another thing to add, I think it's important the teacher explains the 'why'

When I had lessons at school, I was told to learn scales, I never did, it was boring, and seemed pointless. Now I've a teacher who explained why, and how to learn them I wish I had years ago.

My teacher's explains why we're doing things, no point having a smashing big sound, but rubbish timing and rhythm. Running before you can walk.
 
Since my post introducing myself initiated this conversation, I'll chime in. I understand and appreciate all the advice to find a teacher. I'd love to have exactly the teacher I'm ready for and who is available whenever I want/need him or her. I value teachers -- I was one for nearly 40 years. And I'm certain my saxophone playing would be better if I had the access to a flesh and blood saxophone teacher. But in reality, that's a rarity. Teachers come in lots of different flavours, as we all know. And the very best teachers require financial commitments from students -- X number of lessons a month, X number of minutes per lesson, a specific time to show up for lessons -- I get it. In order to be a successful teacher financially, teachers have to impose that structure. At this stage in my life (and even previously, to a great extent....), I don't like external factors imposing structure on my life or my musical interests. But if Pete Thomas were to move in next door and be available whenever I had a question or needed a bit of guidance, I'd willing seek out a teacher......
This would be the educational model that Jean-Jacque Rousseau proposed back in the 18th Century. It still works great, provided students can find the right teacher.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,289
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom