OK, I have played the Stephanhouser SAS1500VN now, and so has my tutor Dave Plummer this morning. He also tried my '73 Buffet SDA and '89 YAS-62 MkI Purple Logo, as I did last night to compare to the Steph.
His thoughts on the Steph, which he played first, were that it played well, had large touch pieces, sounded good, can indeed play loudly, and he'd recommend it to a student looking to upgrade. He played the SDA next, said that the ergonomics were good, played well, and definitely one to consider if looking for a good sax. 62 next, better ergos, more easily in tune... "this one" he said, identifying the best of the bunch.
When I played them last night I tried a few MP/reed combinations on the Steph. I struggled with Middle E and G sharp due to a slight involuntary octave shift to the lower octave which I couldn't work out? Thought maybe there was a leak but today Dave's Otto Link 6* HR with Rico Orange 3 (and him on the end of it!) was obviously a better combination as he had no issues, and I must say the Steph sounded very good in his hands. Down to my inexperience I think! I need to experiment with different reeds perhaps...
I'd tried the Rico Orange 3 reed with Yam 6CM HR and Yani 5 HR and also my standard RJS 2S filed but still had a few issues here and there on some pieces of music. The "new" Otto Link "early Babbitt" STM 6* MP I just couldn't get to grips with at all on any of the three horns.
Overlooking the odd duff note (due to me) the Steph does have a good sound and I agree it can be made to blow very loudly with no side effects. But also, blowing softly, I could get notes usually difficult to start from scratch. The low notes and palm key notes are also an easy blow and the l/h pinky table well positioned. This one, compared to the "well loved" black example from last week, had absolutely no key work rattles and felt very solid. Looking closely at the mechanism I couldn't find any manufacturing faults (as I did with the Jericho J6) and it looks to have been made to precise tolerances.
As I was playing the Steph with my usual Yam 6CM and RJS I thought to myself "this reminds me of something... the SDA?" and swapped to the SDA to see if I was right. Maybe it's "my" sound or the MP/reed but to me the two sounded quite alike. Does this mean the SDA sounds like the SA80 Ads has compared the Steph to? I can't recall any direct comparisons between SDA and SA80 which say they're similar, but it's oft said that the SDA was developed to take on Selmer's SBA so maybe there's something in that? I had thought maybe the SA80, which I've not tried, was one to look out for. I need to take my SDA somewhere and try it against an SA80.
After the Steph and SDA I went back to my Yam 62 and found the key work slicker, the sound edgier, still my current favourite. I'm conscious it's the one I play most now and so allow for that but it really does help me play as the keys are so good under my fingers.
So, in summary from an hour or so blowing the Steph I'd say it's comparable to the SDA for (my) sound, well made, good ergos, an even tone with good projection. The seller included the purchase receipt from 2010 at a discounted £1,100. That's probably comparable with a good intermediate horn from that year, which is where I place the Steph. I doubt I would have paid that, but for a used one I'd say £400 is about right. Ads got a real bargain with his new one! Time will tell if the Steph becomes the DeLorean of the sax world. Who knows how many were made? But it plays well and sounds good and that's what matters most.