Playing the saxophone Sound proofing your studio - I had an idea...

DavidUK

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,133
Location
Near Evesham, Worcestershire
Whilst showing me around the warehouse, my foam sheet distributor (for my new pads) mentioned in passing the "sound proofing" area with special sheet piled high. I didn't ask any questions at the time but I dare say they are experts in the technical specifications of this material and I could easily find out what's suitable.

Now I have two vague sound proofing requirements when playing: 1/ to prevent my noise from disturbing neighbours and 2/ to soften any harsh reflection off hard surfaces.

I say "vague" as I'm no expert on sound proofing, the reasons for it, or requirements from it.

I inherited some large suede french wall hangings but the ceiling of my "studio" slopes so I don't have room for them, otherwise I'd give them a go. They'd serve the purpose to some extent perhaps and give some decoration too.

Now, my wife has a different hobby. She's a quilter. She makes large intricate quilts from cut pieces of different fabrics sewn together. They're mostly for use on beds but they are used for wall hangings too.

How about combining the two? Quilts have a padded internal layer or "batting" which could be replaced by sound proofing foam sheet to produce a decorative sound deadening wall hanging to fit floor to ceiling and in a variety of widths or shapes (for sloping ceilings etc.).

Your "sound proof quilt" could either be a complex collection of cut squares featuring musical instruments, famous musicians, or whatever you like (subject to availability) or it might be a favourite poster transferred to fabric, or a simple and cheap material of your choice (a Harry Potter duvet cover for instance).

As hangings, you could remove them when needed or move them around. You could have several different designs or perhaps three quilts on three walls to form a kind of booth.

So, does anyone care? Would you buy one (or three)? What would you pay? Bearing mind a large intricate quilt made from hundreds of cut pieces of fabric can cost well over £200, what are the alternative costs to sound proof a playing area?

It's just an idea... I have them sometimes. :confused2:
 
I actually use batting for high frequency absorbers, it's amore costly but nicer alternative to Rockwool. You can now also get a recycled insulation for lofts called non-itch which is also good.

However batting or Rockwool or anything like that will not soundproof, only cut down or soften room reflections.

To soundproof you need mass, e.g. concrete, sand, plasterboard.or bespoke sound proofing material that does probably little more but costs a lot more.
 
I would recommend that you check the flammability of anything that you're planning to use, just in case the worst should happen and you have covered every wall and ceiling.
 
There's a product called Dynamat and plenty of cheaper alternative branded similar products used in automotive sector. This is a heavy mass material that comes in sheets or on a roll and is self adhesive with a foil outer surface. You would use this as acoustic damping inside the doors and under the floor etc. of a car. It would work quite well in domestic situation but would be expensive.
 
Preventing sound to neighbors really depends on how much sound has to be stopped and how many avenues of transmission there are. If it's a lot of either, the job can't be done without building a special enclosure that includes isolation strategies which can either be mass or other forms of preventing the transmission of vibration. This can be rebuilding or overbuilding the room or building a booth.

If you share a building with your neighbors I think it would be more cost-effective to build a booth (although learning to do this correctly will take an investment of time). If taking the edge off by covering some problem leaks will do the trick, i.e. you are in a separate building and a lot of sound goes out of windows, then some kind of combined mass/absorption strategy may be adequate.

It is very easy to misunderstand sound.
 
Sound proofing (preventing transmission in and out) is not the same thing as the control of reverberation.

Hanging draperies is much more about controlling reverberation than about transmission.

For transmission attenuation you need to improve several matters.

1) Mass. The more massive the walls, the more energy required for sound inside a room to energize the wall to radiate sound outside. The gold standard is walls of concrete blocks, filled with sand (which addresses the second point). There's only so much you can do in standard residential construction. Doubling up layers of drywall is a good starting point.

2) Damping. This means consuming energy in internal friction - the "filling the wall with sand" is an example. Again, your ability to do anything about damping the vibration OF THE WALL in residential construction is very limited; I'd probably not worry too much about it.

3) Sealing. This is a very very big one. If you have holes in the wall through which the sound can travel, you might as well forget about the other measures for sound proofing. Electrical outlets/j-boxes; boxes for light fixtures; gaps around doors; and the biggest two are windows (don't forget that sound could leave the house through a window and re-enter through an adjacent window) and the HVAC ducts.

4) Isolation. You need the outer wall (radiating to surroundings) to be isolated from the inner wall. The gold standard is dual walls that are not mechanically connected, on a slab that's separate from the building slab. In practice even making a first cut at this in residential construction gets expensive and troublesome fast, unless you buy something pre-made ("Whisper Room").

4) Reverberation inside the room. This DOES contribute to soundproofing, since reducing sound energy inside the room from reverberation will also reduce the energy available for transmission. Despite the emphasis of vendors on applying treatments to walls, it's only a minor contributor to actually soundproofing your room. Fortunately, it's real easy to stick some (not very effective) pointy foam panels on the wall; unfortunately it doesn't do much. Note as well that the thin (1-2") pointy foam that's usually sold is only going to be effective for high frequency/short wavelength sound, whereas what's most transmissible is low frequency sound. Typically you're going to need anti-reverberation material of at least 4" thickness.

Thing is, it's easy to apply some pointy foam to the walls; pretty much everything else on my list is orders of magnitude more effective, but also orders of magnitude more troublesome and expensive.

T'ain't easy to soundproof a room. I've contributed to the construction of four different hemianechoic rooms, two of which I designed myself and one of which I designed completely from scratch, so I've got some directly relevant personal experience.
 
Last edited:
These HF baffles in y control were were specced up by an acoustic designer, so hopefully turf3 also being a designer might approve of.

They are basically boxes with 2" Rockwool or batting behind acoustically transparent hessian. They are hung so as to leave a 2" gap between box and wall/ceiling.

Ceiing soundproofing was achieved by extra plasterboard but crucially lifting floorboards above and adding sand for mass. After carefully testing for structural integrity.

You will notice the extra damping in front of the left hand monitor.

Luckily in this one there is no sound leak issues outside. In my previous studio there was, so as turf 3 mentioned absolve that is crucial to fix before anything else. All we did was replace the glass with think glass (about 6cm ). Double or triple glazing obviously does help but also come with their own issues re: bass at about 150Hz.

My current studio has bass issues due to suspended floor. I dealt with this by using tuneable monitors rather than bass traps as I enjoyed more space in the room.



stud7.webp
 
@turf3 that's really useful and I'll probably give up now...

My studio is on the 2nd floor of a detached house with no close neighbours but the idea has to appeal to all sorts of locations,

@Pete Thomas we have two dogs and two cats. Will they be sufficient for a surround sound system? (Velcro'd?)
 
For music you don't want to kill all reverberation. So the baffles applied to the wall will be appropriate. As far as soundproofing I note the mention of extra drywall and adding sand, thicker glass, and having assessed sound leakage and determined it's not a problem.
 
Having recently seen the construction of an audiology booth at work I can understand all that @turf3 says. Even after the blockwork construction was completed, it took several tens of thousands of pounds for the rest of the work, and that was for a small booth with space for one patient and one clinician.
 
My son works for Specsavers... They just had a re-fit. Wonder what they did with the old audiology room stuff? In the skip and gone I expect.

My BIL is a Spesavers director - he may be able to point me at the next store re-fit... that's a re-fit of a Specsavers, not a Next store, before you get all clever on me... :rolleyes:
 
if cost is relevant and looks not too important you can usually get carpets that are being taken up and replaced from any carpet company. They just throw them out. The deeper and tighter the pile the more sound you absorb. I hang them by nailing to a board then attaching that to studs in the wall. Not permanent and basically free.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,717
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom