Tech/maintenance Soprano with stuffy C2 after overhaul

Oddly on the soprano in question the keys are working fine. ...

Except they're not, as there are leaks up and down. A bend in the same plane as the stack rods probably won't cause binding; a bend that compresses the posts toward each other will; a bend the other direction (spreading the posts apart) won't. And if a bend is old, previous repair people may have eased a binding without straightening the body. But if the pads are shifted with respect to the tone holes, leaks show up even though the keys all move freely. In addition, depending on the direction of a bend, end play may have been introduced into the keywork so adjustments and new pads won't be stable.

Best thing to do is probably what you're doing.
 
My mentor in repair taught me that if all of the stack keys are moving and the pads are sealing properly, it is best to leave the curve in the body "as is" when doing a "play condition". This goes against my "perfectionist instincts" but it makes sense that the keywork has adjusted to the bend over time which is the "new normal". If I were to do a complete mechanical overhaul everything would be addressed including the bent body.
That's generally my approach too. I point out the bend and discuss the ramifications - with the emphasis on reassuring the client that a slight bend will not affect the response of the horn provided the action is set up around it. It can be dealt with at a later date when the horn is due a more thorough service.
With that said, a significant number of clients opt to spend the extra and have the horn straightened out.
 
After the local tech worked on it there was small improvement but C2 still tended toward stuffy and C3 needed a lot of voicing to get a clear tone.

I measured the key heights. I'm quite stumped by how low they are, as the tone holes don't appear particularly small.

(+ - .2 mm)
B 2.9 mm
Bb < 2.8 mm
A 3.1 mm
G 3.6 mm
F 3.2 mm

Since taking those I did sand the cork controlling the B key just a bit, and that seems to have made another incremental improvement.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,717
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom