Tech/maintenance Soprano with stuffy C2 after overhaul

As to my not playing right, if that's a valid theory given that I'm fine on other sops, then would you recommend that I either wait to grow into this instrument or move it on, if it turns out that other players have no problems with it?

That's a decision you need to make yourself. I have had horns that I absolutely hated and only kept because there was no point in selling them again - at a possible loss. And just a different mouthpiece and the thing came to life and it is all I am playing now. So don't let something like what you are going through discourage you, chances are that you are doing something wrong and other instruments are just more forgiving. But you are still holding yourself back with your wrong approach and that's where a more capricious instrument can teach you some very valuable lessons that will apply to everything else you are doing.

But if you don't get anywhere, and nobody else has a problem with your horn, then it might be time to reconsider. Arguably, soprano is the hardest one to get right in terms of embouchure and intonation, that's something else to bear in mind.

There is a YouTube video of Branford Marsalis explaining how he played all wrong for the longest time and how he improved just by changing posture etc. but I haven't been able yet to find it. If I come across, I'll post it again here.
 
Following the "diversion" concerning nomenclature. I would like to get back to the topic of this thread which is a stuffy C2 after an overhaul. In my experience, a C2 that is stuffy is not venting properly through the B tonehole (the one covered by the B key) and perhaps to a lesser degree, the G tonehole (the one covered by the G key).

Referring to the Yamaha key opening specs for sopranos:
B on the YSS-465 is 4.9mm and the G is 6.2mm
C on the YSS-62 is 4.6mm and the G is 6.1mm

These are not "absolutes", but can provide a reference or a starting point. A way to check the influence of the G venting is to open the G# while holding the C. You are correct that opening the B key requires sanding or removing the foot cork. On some instruments the "front F" key also limits the opening of the B key and needs to adjusted as well. Changing key heights on the upper stack can be a bit tricky so you don't introduce "lost motion". You might experiment with key opening using layers of masking tape and then take it to your tech to adjust the keys to that specification.
 
Thanks @jbtsax I believe that if I sanded the B foot cork I would also be introducing lost motion/double action in the mechanism by which the B key holds the high C/auxiliary B key down? (There is no front F FWIW) I will take a stab at measuring the key heights and come back on that.

Meanwhile, I believe we so far have one vote for the proposal that on a soprano, where the surrounding notes are fine, a stuffy C2 with unplayable C3 can be user error. [Edited to correct a miscount. 🙂 ]

For the record I now understand that what I was calling the "high C key" (which I picked up somewhere on the web) is what Stephen is calling the "auxiliary B key", and that it is its lever I should focus on when using that key to test for a regulation problem.
 
Last edited:
To check "user error" I would first play on just the mouthpiece alone using lots of air and getting a big clear tone. The pich you are aiming for is a C concert. Next sing the pitch of the C2 (use falsetto if needed), then blow that same pitch on your airstream like an airy sounding whistle. Lastly assemble the saxophone and using the same embouchure, shape inside the mouth, and airstream play the note C2 as a long tone. Then double the speed of the air and play C3 with the same embouchure and shape inside the mouth.
 
Following the "diversion" concerning nomenclature. I would like to get back to the topic of this thread which is a stuffy C2 after an overhaul. In my experience, a C2 that is stuffy is not venting properly through the B tonehole (the one covered by the B key) and to a lesser degree the G tonehole (the one covered by the G key).

Referring to the Yamaha key opening specs for sopranos:
B on the YSS-465 is 4.9mm and the G is 6.2mm
C on the YSS-62 is 4.6mm and the G is 6.1mm

These are not "absolutes", but can provide a reference or a starting point. A way to check the influence of the G venting is to open the G# while holding the C. To open
 
Thanks @jbtsax I believe that if I sanded the B foot cork I would also be introducing lost motion/double action in the mechanism by which the B key holds the high C/auxiliary B key down? (There is no front F FWIW) I will take a stab at measuring the key heights and come back on that.

Meanwhile, I believe we so far have one vote for the proposal that on a soprano, where the surrounding notes are fine, a stuffy C2 with unplayable C3 can be user error. [Edited to correct a miscount. 🙂 ]

For the record I now understand that what I was calling the "high C key" (which I picked up somewhere on the web) is what Stephen is calling the "auxiliary B key", and that it is its lever I should focus on when using that key to test for a regulation problem.
Sometimes you have to introduce lost motion. Many techs were taught to eliminate all lost motion, whether or not the horn plays properly. I usually have to make some key height adjustments whenever I get a horn back from the shop. It just depends on the detailed mechanical design. Lost motion is not a catastrophe.
 
I always leave a small amount of "lost motion" in the front F to insure the F palm key closes completely and in the LH table where the low B and C# connect to the G# key to give that key a positive closure. In the regulation of the stack keys I remove all lost motion because in my view it serves no purpose and it affects the "feel" of the keys. Some techs call it "double action" which is a good description of how it feels. My method of regulation starts with setting the opening of the F key which then determines the opening of the rest of the lower stack when lost motion is removed. It also dictates the key opening of the upper stack through the Bis connection. If the ideal key heights of the lower stack do not permit acceptable opening of the upper stack keys, it can be adjusted by adding or removing curvature in the arm from the Bis key without introducing lost motion.
 
Rather than keep puzzling this out, I tried a new-to-me local tech. He immediately showed me that the sax is bent, and that there are small leaks all over the place, so I am having him fix it. Hopefully when that is done all of this will be behind me.
 
Well done! A decent tech.

Many years ago (2000 - the year, that is) I bought a brand new Keilwerth SX90R alto. I still have it. Within 2 months I had dropped it twice onto some nice hard floor tiles. I took it to a local repairer who got it to a roughly playable state. I persisted with it for a short while but it wasn't good, so I got in my car and toddled off to my favourite tech who is not exactly just down the road. He took one look at it and said, "It's bent". He clamped up the bow and inserted a broom handle in the body and straightened it. And all the keywork lined up again. It's still good.
 
Bends are funny. I noticed a bend in another soprano that most people didn't see, but this one completely escaped me.

I'm starting to be a bit distrustful of cases at this point. I begin to wonder whether they're jealous of all the attention the instruments get.
 
I'm starting to be a bit distrustful of cases at this point. I begin to wonder whether they're jealous of all the attention the instruments get.
I don't think mine are really jealous, more indifferent. But some self-righteous cases don't think it's fair that they should get all the knocks while the saxophone inside gets off scot-free. You need to make sure that all your cases are feeling altruistic.
 
Bends are funny. I noticed a bend in another soprano that most people didn't see, but this one completely escaped me.

I'm starting to be a bit distrustful of cases at this point. I begin to wonder whether they're jealous of all the attention the instruments get.
The smaller the horn the worse the impact of a bend. My bass sax is bananaform, in fact I call it my banana bass but it plays just fine and I can bend the notes back if I need to.
 
Rather than keep puzzling this out, I tried a new-to-me local tech. He immediately showed me that the sax is bent, and that there are small leaks all over the place, so I am having him fix it. Hopefully when that is done all of this will be behind me.
You could always just put it on eBay as a “curved” soprano.
 
My mentor in repair taught me that if all of the stack keys are moving and the pads are sealing properly, it is best to leave the curve in the body "as is" when doing a "play condition". This goes against my "perfectionist instincts" but it makes sense that the keywork has adjusted to the bend over time which is the "new normal". If I were to do a complete mechanical overhaul everything would be addressed including the bent body.
 
My mentor in repair taught me that if all of the stack keys are moving and the pads are sealing properly, it is best to leave the curve in the body "as is" when doing a "play condition". This goes against my "perfectionist instincts" but it makes sense that the keywork has adjusted to the bend over time which is the "new normal". If I were to do a complete mechanical overhaul everything would be addressed including the bent body.

That makes complete sense though. I am aware of how lucky I am to have found someone willing to address the situation on this soprano.

Two of my local techs would not unbend a soprano even as part of an overhaul. Now that I have found someone who doesn't flinch at the idea I'm going to do my best to avoid the other two.

Oddly on the soprano in question the keys are working fine. It is all a big mystery. The saxophone world is full of sand traps and ambiguity, I find.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,701
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom