- Messages
- 2,784
- Location
- Black Forest
As to my not playing right, if that's a valid theory given that I'm fine on other sops, then would you recommend that I either wait to grow into this instrument or move it on, if it turns out that other players have no problems with it?
That's a decision you need to make yourself. I have had horns that I absolutely hated and only kept because there was no point in selling them again - at a possible loss. And just a different mouthpiece and the thing came to life and it is all I am playing now. So don't let something like what you are going through discourage you, chances are that you are doing something wrong and other instruments are just more forgiving. But you are still holding yourself back with your wrong approach and that's where a more capricious instrument can teach you some very valuable lessons that will apply to everything else you are doing.
But if you don't get anywhere, and nobody else has a problem with your horn, then it might be time to reconsider. Arguably, soprano is the hardest one to get right in terms of embouchure and intonation, that's something else to bear in mind.
There is a YouTube video of Branford Marsalis explaining how he played all wrong for the longest time and how he improved just by changing posture etc. but I haven't been able yet to find it. If I come across, I'll post it again here.

