Reeds Soprano saxophone reeds for a particular mouthpiece?

ClassicalCrow

New Member
Messages
1
I'm a student saxophone player, and I recently got my hands on a selmer S80 mouthpiece for the soprano sax. However, I'm noticing a weaker sound and a much more limited range (esp. high octave) than with my old yamaha 4C. I've had great success with the same model on alto sax. I've noticed that the vandoren reeds I've been using are wider at the tip than the mouthpiece, and I'm worried that may be causing part of the problem?
Am I correct in this, and if so are there reeds better suited to the mouthpiece? Should I try to clip them myself?
Or am I totally wrong, and if so is there anything I can try to make the mouthpiece work?
Thanks!
 
I can imagine there may be more than one viable answer to this question, eg:

  • If the Yamaha works better for then use that mouthpiece.
  • Try other reeds on the Selmer, or experiment with adjusting the Vandorens
 
The soprano is notorious for being more demanding than its bigger brothers. What you are experiencing is precisely one phenomenon. Every tiny bit of change has a bigger impact.
Furthermore, the upper range of the soprano IS challenging. It could well be that the Yamaha mouthpiece makes it easier than the S80. The cheap Yamaha mouthpiece is designed for beginners, and it does make the soprano easier, or let's say less challenging.
A specific combination of reed and mouthpiece will work better than another. It sounds dumb said like this, but it is so.
I can only confirm what Pete says above.
Try other reeds, maybe just softer.
And, if the Yamaha does the job, keep playing it. I also have one (7C) for challenging orchestral stuff.
 
The problem is the poor manufacture control of your Selmer S80 - they are notoriously variable, whereas the Yamamha 4C is an incredible reliable (if rather vanilla) mouthpiece.
Unfortunately you cannot just walk into a store and buy an S80 (or any Selmer piece) and expect a good result - the last time I bought a stock classical mouthpiece I tried maybe 6 or 8 in order to find even one that was OK.

My honest advice to you would be to go to Ed Pillinger and ask for one of his classical pieces. Depending upon your sonic taste, either his 'S' model (based on a Selmer Soloist) or perhaps the 'P' model (with a slightly bigger throat that suits modern sopranos better IMO). Take it from me, his work is immaculate and he will adjust what he makes for you to your taste. In comparison to the cost of a rubbish Selmer mouthpiece, his work is very reasonable indeed.
Tell Ed that David Roach recommended him.
 
P.S. the issue of the reed being wider at the tip than the mouthpiece is not necessarily a problem. It's not something a really good maker would do, but it's not really an issue and can do things like darken the tone or accelerate the air stream a little at that point. Vandoren reeds are a standard width, so any reed brand will be wider than that S80.
 
or perhaps the 'P' model (with a slightly bigger throat that suits modern sopranos better IMO).
Note that the PPT soprano is similar to a Selmer soloist but with a more open throat - which actually gives a more full bodied sound and aids intonation IMO. (Also helps support the Cafe!)
 
On Alto I find filed reeds work better on my S80, unfilled on my Jazz Select piece.

On my recently acquired soprano, I'm playing a Vandoren Jazz piece & java green reeds. Regardless of what set up the palm keys are still a work in progress.
 
You say S80 but not what size. I'm using an F with a blue Vandoren 2 no problems with dynamics, or intonation. If you're using the C* then try a harder reed. In my experience the S80 likes a french cut reed and a blue Vandoren suits best. Maybe a 3 on a C*.
The S80 is a very marmite piece. Some love them. Others hate them.
Whilst playing in the practice room the sound may feel weak but the same sound in ensemble can be surprisingly loud.
You may just need time to adjust your embouchure to the different facing curve.
If bought used then you've found why the previous owner got rid of it.
Inspect, with a lens the tip and side rails for damage. Use a straight edge to ascertain the flatness of the table and evenness of the rails. HR can distort and a little correction may be needed.
All my used HR Selmer mouthpieces needed a light dressing.
Their single screw ligature also improved things. If you decide to go for one, opt for the silver plate. The lacquer falls off the gold one and it greens very quickly.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,439
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom