Pete Effamy
Well-Known Member
But you’re in a minority of one.in the register I prefer to call "clarion".
But you’re in a minority of one.in the register I prefer to call "clarion".
If the composer wanted a tonal concept expressing a clarion call to action, maybe for a piece on revolutions, turf would be first in line.If a composer...
The composer would write the notes and say "are these within the common range"? and the person answering would either say "yes, any high school student can do that" or "only for more advanced students" or "serious professionals only" or "nope, ain' no one can play those notes".That just seems musically daft. If a composer writes those notes and asks if ok as they are altissimo and the reply is; “not today sunshine!”.
Have you read the posts above?The composer would write the notes and say "are these within the common range"? and the person answering would either say "yes, any high school student can do that" or "only for more advanced students" or "serious professionals only" or "nope, ain' no one can play those notes".
consider for example the high F#. 80 years ago, that would have been considered "extended range" and scholastic music would have avoided it. Today, since so many instruments have the high F# key which eliminates the need to be able to play it as an altissimo note, that is part of the standard range. Same thing with low A on baritone sax.
It's trivially easy to play a high F# on a horn with the high F# key, BECAUSE WITH THAT KEY IT'S NOT ALTISSIMO. It takes additional practice at voicing to be able to play the note on a horn without, BECAUSE WITHOUT THE KEY, IT'S ALTISSIMO.
If you look at an orchestration book, it's going to show certain ranges as "common", others as "extended" and others as "extremely difficult" or some variant of that terminology. This holds for woodwinds and brass. What drives this? On reeds it's how you access the notes.
OK, I admit this may be the case.But you’re in a minority of one.
Pencilled in...If the composer wanted a tonal concept expressing a clarion call to action, maybe for a piece on revolutions, turf would be first in line.
Yes, does this comment have a point?Have you read the posts above?
Middle or 2nd as you say. Whilst the saxophone has seen much creativity from a playing aspect in its (shorter) history, this cannot be said for the years since 1840 and the naming of the registers.But what would you call the register that's overblown an octave, then?
Yes; from Brymer's book "The Clarinet", he refers to the "homogeny" of notes / registers.The clarinet's throat Bb is even more distinct from its clarion B.
Not sure I agree with this, but I'll agree that if not it's a close-run thing. Depends upon what / how you are trying to play up there. The 3rd break on the clarinet can be an absolute swine to cross smoothly. If it's a modern classical piece that wants pp then it's proper tough. S'pose that goes for most instruments though.but getting up into the third register is much easier on flute and clarinet and a great deal tougher on sax.
Side Bb??(Can I mention the full-Boehm clarinet that has a clarion Bb the same pitch as the throat Bb?)
It was discussed at length by Pete (the other) and also others (not the same other)Yes, does this comment have a point?
Yes, because it's succinct and avoids knickers altogether.Would that terminology untwist everyone's knickers?
Would that terminology aid communication for most sax players; at least learners and advancingWould that terminology untwist everyone's knickers?
Not the side Bb, the low Eb fingering with register key (only available on the true Full Boehm).Side Bb??
Ah ok. I've never played one. How common are they in the states? I believe them to be (or were) preferred in Italy, where players transpose parts for Clarinet in A. Not that used in the UK, AFAIK.Not the side Bb, the low Eb fingering with register key (only available on the true Full Boehm).
Exactly. So altissimo in many cases includes F# but not always.It's trivially easy to play a high F# on a horn with the high F# key, BECAUSE WITH THAT KEY IT'S NOT ALTISSIMO.
Full Boehm clarinets are NOT common in the US. When I was in college there was a fine old Selmer full-Boehm in the instrument closet, I never saw anyone play it.Ah ok. I've never played one. How common are they in the states? I believe them to be (or were) preferred in Italy, where players transpose parts for Clarinet in A. Not that used in the UK, AFAIK.
