Saxophones should i get a soprano????????????

Get a Trumpet! Same range/key/music and provides a different learning experience. You can get an excellent axe for under £200, including mouthpiece, and it fits in well with Tenor sax in many bands/quintets/horn sections. For me a trumpet has more body to the sound than a soprano sax. You can then sound like Miles Davis as well as John Coltrane!

Kind regards
Tom😎
 
If you do go ahead and buy a soprano, be prepared for the fact that it is like being a beginner again in terms of the sound you produce. You need to dedicate time specifically to long notes, pitching, basic technique work etc. After many years of playing tenor and owning a Yamaha soprano which spent 99.9% of its life under the bed, I sold it in 2001. Last year I got the urge to pay soprano again and bought a second hand Selmer SAII which is a superb instrument (much better than the Yam) and which after a few months of careful practise, started to sound really good (IMHO). The problem you have is that if you go try second hand sops they will all have different mouthpeices which you aren't used to anyway. My approach was to go to John Packers in Taunton and try about 20 different mpcs on their top of the range Yani, find one that sounded good for me, bought it, then went off trying second hand horns. I am still happy with the Meyer mpc on the Selmer. My only other advice would be to buy the best horn you can afford. After its life under the bed, I sold my Yamaha for a few hundred pounds more than I paid for it new back in the 1980s! Good luck
 
I have been playing alto for about two years (one of Pete Canter's students in fact - see above!) and I recently bought a 1920s Buescher Truetone Soprano - I was expecting a real struggle but I have been pleasantly surprised - It plays in tune from top to bottom and I found no real struggle playing the full range. I am not saying that I have already developed that full tone you hear from experienced players but I produced a quite a good sound from the off. I suspect that says more about the Buescher than me, so find a good playable horn and it needn't be quite the struggle that some say. Having said that I am back to playing more alto, and I can't find the time to practice both, and I am not sure I can afford to have the Buescher sitting around, so half of me thinks I ought to sell! Give it a go, or you always be wondering what if...
 
I am probably going to be the weird one here. First, I bought a new Buffett sop several years ago when my brother-in-law was getting married and he wanted me to play some Kenny G music at his reception. Great excuse to tell the wife I need a soprano. I had always had an alto, and always wanted to play a sop. So I traded in an old 1930 Selmer tenor that was in bad shape, and a clarinet that I never played, and some cash, and got the sop. Great move. I have played hours and hours on that sop and loved it!!

I am probably a bit different than many of you in that most of my playing has been in church. I played in a gospel group called Sojourn for 7 years, and have always played in praise bands whenever I could (still do). I use both my sop and alto about equally. There is no rhyme or reason...some songs sound better on one over the other. I just kinda rely on my experience and feel for the music as to which horn to play. For some songs the soprano is just perfect. No one has ever told me I was doing it wrong, nor has anyone ever asked why I choose to play one over the other.

I would love to add a tenor at some point.

So I say it really depends on what kind of music you are playing. Many of you jazz players probably have no use for a sop. But I love mine and would never be without it. Comes down to personal preference I guess!! I have always loved Spyro Gyra and how great Jay Beckenstien makes both the alto and the soprano sound!!
Kraig
 
thanks for all the good advice...its only what i`d expect on this forum...i think tom had some good points, i should find a good reason for getting a sop and not just get one on a whim, when i think about it thats exactly what i did with the alto and hes right in his conclusion that because of that i play it less,
many thanks
neil

Nell

I'd suggest you consider the cost to you. If cost is not a concern - especially if you are spending out on a low cost chinese sop, why worry, just buy one! If it has to be a more considered purchase due to cost, then you'll probably need more justification.

I bought a sop last year and found it hard going. The embouchure is way different to my tenor and my teacher suggested I focus just on the tenor which I have done. I do aim to start using the sop sometime soon, though I've been saying that for 6 months. If you get one, be prepared to be a beginner again unless you are one of the lucky ones and you find it easy.

Every month or so I think I should maybe sell my sop :w00t: but it's still here!
 
I was the same wondering weathering to get a soprano sax i got a alto and tenor (and a clarinet) and i feel i need to complete my collection by getting soprano, but is it worth it?
Saying this today i got a TRUMPET!!! Borrowed one of a friend who stopped playing, but after trying it out if i get on with it i will buy it off him probably.
 
Another 3 button soprano sax player - great news! Trumpet is going to strengthen your embouchure and breathing at the very least, and you can practice it in a lot more places, with minimal preparation - no reeds, no ligatures, no straps - go for it.

Kind regards
Tom😎

Apparently Nat Adderley's favourite alto sax player was Peter King (NOT Cannonball.....)
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,434
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom