Tech/maintenance Should Front F and side F key cause same amount of opening?

CliveMA

Senior Member
Messages
1,047
Location
Brisbane, QLD, Australia
I'm wondering if my soprano needs adjustment. My front F does not open the tonehole as wide as the side F key does. On my Tenor they both open the same. It does not seem to affect note production but it is hard for me to tell as I can only sound front F by sounding octave C first then slurring up.
 
People have different opinions on this, but it's my understanding that when using front F, the F palm key should only open a fraction of how much it does when using the palm F fingering because it now acts as a vent as opposed to an open tone hole.
 
Try pushing your jaw forward.

Thanks for the tip. Good demo video of pushing jaw forward for altissimo:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zez8GADc7mU


People have different opinions on this, but it's my understanding that when using front F, the F palm key should only open a fraction of how much it does when using the palm F fingering because it now acts as a vent as opposed to an open tone hole.
Interesting, my Tenor (on which heights are the same) does not seem to have a way of adjusting heights apart from changing a cork height. My Soprano has an adjustment screw to adjust height for Front F. I'm mechanically challenged so I'm too scared to touch it to experiment.
 
High notes on soprano are a challenge. The reed is so small. Minor adjustments to embouchure are tiny.

Don't blame the gear, just persevere. It will come. It's not a little tenor. 😉
Just to make clear. In this thread, I'm not looking for any hints on how to play altissimo. I'm not ready in my own development anyway. I have plenty of more basic things like tone across the middle of the instrument to focus on at this stage.

I'm interested in this thread solely on the relative adjustment of Front F and Palm F. The reason is because my new Saxophones are almost due for a free 12-week checkover. And the difference between the Front F and Palm F on the Soprano is the only thing I can find that seems to want an explanation. And as I'm not experienced enough to playtest that difference I'm asking you lovely folks, is that something I should ask my techs about at the free checkover or should I just ignore it?
 
That is a great question and the answer is "it depends". 😉

The "front F" will speak when the F palm key opening is reduced, but the "front E" (adding LH3) will not. Eugene Rousseau advocates setting the opening of the front F to about .25 mm (the thickness of a business card) to facilitate playing altissimo G using that key. This in effect makes the opening more of an "octave vent" than an open tonehole. Rousseau advocates that once the player learns to "voice" that note, then the key can be returned to its original opening.

In my repair I try to give the front F the same full opening as the palm F unless the customer specifies otherwise. The saxophone professor at a local university was a student of Rousseau and he sends a lot of his students to me to lower the front F opening as they work on playing altissimo. The repair tech who was my mentor when I started professional repair "invented" and patented a front F key that when pressed one way opens the F key completely and when pressed a different way reduces the opening to facilitate altissimo G. For anyone interested this is his patent:
 
Interesting isnt it? Its all swings and roundabouts. For altissimo G, as one contributor says, "the front F acts as a vent" Indeed it does..Try Alt G with the front F cracked open..In my case its easy on my horns and you can indeed set the mechanism up to achieve this on a regular basis. However. When using the front F (for Alt G) and fingering the alternative front E and F (IE Alt G is already rolled open with the index finger on B) they then sound stuffy so I open the front F out until they sound clear. Its a compromise of course but when fast fingerings are required then the fingers are already in position to do the runs down. Just watch Chris Potter..But what do I know!!
 
Last edited:
The "front F" will speak when the F palm key opening is reduced, but the "front E" (adding LH3) will not. Eugene Rousseau advocates setting the opening of the front F to about .25 mm (the thickness of a business card) to facilitate playing altissimo G using that key. This in effect makes the opening more of an "octave vent" than an open tonehole. Rousseau advocates that once the player learns to "voice" that note, then the key can be returned to its original opening.

In my case (on Soprano but not Tenor), Front F opens about 0.75 mm (about the same as the body octave vent (maybe 0.5mm) and a little less than the neck octave vent (maybe 1mm). Palm F opens about 2.5 mm (same as Palm E and Palm D).

Thoughts?
 
In my case (on Soprano but not Tenor), Front F opens about 0.75 mm (about the same as the body octave vent (maybe 0.5mm) and a little less than the neck octave vent (maybe 1mm). Palm F opens about 2.5 mm (same as Palm E and Palm D).

Thoughts?
For what it's worth, the Yamaha recommended key heights for soprano are 3 mm for F palm, and 1.8 mm for front F.
I've attached a file so you can check other keys if you like.
 

Attachments

Thanks very much. I'll check other keys, too. I note the music medic calipers are accurate to 0.01mm so it seems reasonable to request the Yamaha recommended key heights be followed unless there is a good reason otherwise.
 
For what it's worth, the Yamaha recommended key heights for soprano are 3 mm for F palm, and 1.8 mm for front F.
I've attached a file so you can check other keys if you like.

That's great! Reminds me I started a project ages ago to make some tools to measure key heights. But I got tired of filing those aluminum rods... By It I have since invested in a tool that should make it a breeze to achieve.

It can't hurt to double check where my horns are...
 
For what it's worth, the Yamaha recommended key heights for soprano are 3 mm for F palm, and 1.8 mm for front F.
I've attached a file so you can check other keys if you like.

The table doesn't list my 82Z Soprano. Just checking, is the table for the Soprano YSS-62 correct for 82Z?
I think it should be as I believe the 82Z is really a rebadged 62. My 82Z does have the split C (upper and lower in table) to flatten Octave C# that is not in the design of the other Yamaha Sops. It is interesting that the key heights vary quite a bit between the two different soprano designs.
 
Previous estimates were only unreliable eyeballing. Using these specialist screwdriver bits (for computer repair) I've confirmed Front F and Palm F are as recommended (1.8mm and 3mm). High Eb is 2.5mm vs 3.0 recommended. Upper and Lower Octave are 2.5mm and 2.0mm respectively vs 3.0 recommended.
bits.webp
 
Way to go. That is certainly a creative way to measure. I have shared this before, but it is a great tip I got from Jeff Peterson who works for Yamaha at a saxophone workshop. That is to use a small hole round bore gauge along with a caliper. They are not that expensive unless you go into the professional machinist grade. They take all the guesswork out of the procedure.

1588961090785.png
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,541
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom