Tech/maintenance Should Front F and side F key cause same amount of opening?

Way to go. That is certainly a creative way to measure. I have shared this before, but it is a great tip I got from Jeff Peterson who works for Yamaha at a saxophone workshop. That is to use a small hole round bore gauge along with a caliper. They are not that expensive unless you go into the professional machinist grade. They take all the guesswork out of the procedure.

View attachment 14533
I can only find guages for 3mm+. My drill bits allow smaller measurements. The Front F is 1.8mm.
 
Way to go. That is certainly a creative way to measure. I have shared this before, but it is a great tip I got from Jeff Peterson who works for Yamaha at a saxophone workshop. That is to use a small hole round bore gauge along with a caliper. They are not that expensive unless you go into the professional machinist grade. They take all the guesswork out of the procedure.

View attachment 14533
Good idea, as the screwdriver may go in the gap at an angle and give a false measurement.
 
Reading this thread made me think to go into the garage and find my feeler gauges, haven't used them for twenty five years but make sure they are there, come in handy again some day.
Found four fifty year old one gallon oil cans as well, wonder if I can sell them on ebay.
P.S. those F gaps are different on my Hanson tenor and alto by a 'fair amount'.
 
Update. Small bore guage tools have finally arrived. (Covid delivery delays).

Summary: E gap too big but seems not worth concern as all notes achievable in tune.

Table does not have my sax 82Z but my measurements are different to 62 in table.

Palm E measures 3.7mm vs 62 table at 3mm. Palm D and Eb and F are same as those in 62 table.

Palm E and Palm F were considerably sharp at time of starting this thread but I now find I can play them in tune with oral cavity adjustments. Reeds make a difference, too. I can occasionally but not consistently play Front E and Front F in tune. (I only practice them for a few minutes each day as I have more important priorities).

On Tenor the whole horn including front E and front F play remarkably in tune so I haven't bothered measuring its tonehole heights.
 
jbt is correct: balance the G against the E, unless you never play E from the front F. The optimal setting will vary between makes and models. As a general rule, the larger the diamater of the F tonehole, the more you will find that the best setting for G is lower (e.g., Conns and some Taiwan -- usually rolled-tonehole models -- will have large F toneholes). In theory, your palm F with normal palm pressure should open wider than the front F opens the palm F, because you don't want the palm F's setting blocking your front F from completely closing C#2/B2. In practice, there may be exceptions. I can't think of any, but I can recall being surprised to find that some horns played pretty well off the front F with the C#2/B2 leaking a bit.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,541
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom