Tech/maintenance Separating a key cup from its arm.

Here are a few more photos showing the key removed from the arm, and the finished key. As you can see, there is quite a bit of "finishing" involved.

3 Showing finished key.webp

3 keycup unsoldered from clarinet key.webp
 
Thanks all. I think I will stick to cutting the cups away by hand. It's an experiment to see whether manufacturers could make horns, using my new pads, and dispense with the key cup altogether. Weight saving, speedier action, and ease of cleaning are the advantages.
I only need to do this on one prototype to find the answers I need.
 
A 10mm diameter centre of each key cup would be left to glue the magnet to. This would be better than trying to glue the magnet direct to the 3mm wide key arm. Key touches and any other utilised cup areas would add to the centre 10mm.
In manufacture the key cup would change to "10mm pad base."
These are neodymium strong magnets, each with a 1.2kg pull. A severe jolting of my prototype (I just checked) displaces none of them.
I tried dropping a single test key, on the key cup edge, onto hard ground. Over 3 feet height the pad dislodged.
Dropping a sax over 3ft is likely to cause other issues.
If pads "falling out" is a real concern there is a way of securing them whilst retaining their self-levelling abilities. This would add to the cost so I may wait until someone falls off a stage and complains before adding this as an option.
They would still not need to be locked into place after finding their level against the tone hole.
Bear in mind this is experimental. I may cut away a few keys, decide it won't work, and shelve the idea.
I bought the cheap Windcraft 1 for £40 to mutilate... but I quite like it!
I'll try out on the spare keys Jonf is very kindly donating before killing off any complete horns.
 
Last edited:
A random thought wandered through my mind as they so frequently do, a sax like this might be dangerous for anyone with a pacemaker.
Any other similar problems less serious, credit card or phone in pocket .....?
I brought this up on the other thread a long time ago. David‘s got it covered. Still a great question.

@DavidUK ever test Velcro as a way to attach pads ?
 
A 10mm diameter centre of each key cup would be left to glue the magnet to. This would be better than trying to glue the magnet direct to the 3mm wide key arm. Key touches and any other utilised cup areas would add to the centre 10mm.
In manufacture the key cup would change to "10mm pad base."
These are neodymium strong magnets, each with a 1.2kg pull. A severe jolting of my prototype (I just checked) displaces none of them.
I tried dropping a single test key, on the key cup edge, onto hard ground. Over 3 feet height the pad dislodged.
Dropping a sax over 3ft is likely to cause other issues.
If pads "falling out" is a real concern there is a way of securing them whilst retaining their self-levelling abilities. This would add to the cost so I may wait until someone falls off a stage and complains before adding this as an option.
They would still not need to be locked into place after finding their level against the tone hole.
Bear in mind this is experimental. I may cut away a few keys, decide it won't work, and shelve the idea.
I bought the cheap Windcraft 1 for £40 to mutilate... but I quite like it!
I'll try out on the spare keys Jonf is very kindly donating before killing off any complete horns.
So a replacement pad would be a simple magnetic swap
 
Is that a feature folks would like?
Think of the Keilwerth adjustable palm keys. It is a feature that makes the saxophone more adjustable, but it didn't spread to other brands as it was no game changing feature.

On the present saxophone some key cups are bigger than neccesary for the size of the tone hole just for aesthetics.
Removing the cups and adding a screw to every key arm increases the steam punk look of the instrument.

So I think that only some folks would like this feature enough to buy it.
 
Work in progress... as I said earlier, on second thoughts a 10mm diameter remnant of key cup would be better and easier to glue the magnet to.

For manufacturers, a small key cup with height adjuster hole in its centre would be good. Pads could then be whatever size is preferred for functionality or aesthetics.
Pads would still be instantly removable.

For retro-fit, no modifications are needed to use the "pad out" height adjustment. An owner could choose whether they want any further modifications involving cut away cups, cup hole adjusters, and other features milling around in my mind.
 
Last edited:
Revolution... in pad design, and by all the traditionalists and woodwind repairers!

If it ain't broke...
I meant evolution in the design process as a consequence of the discussions...

As for the revolution, I'm not yet betting on it until you find the appropriate pad material(s) with the right plasticity for the job.

Good luck with that. In a positive way!
 
Pad material is found. Took eight months mind you. Airtight; waterproof; low compression set; hard wearing; washable.
What's the market though?:
I think repairers will be sceptical; nerdy DIY home users will be curious as they're easy to fit (but still need regulation and adjustment) and can change resonators; performers may like longevity, hard wearing, easily replaced, and no sticky pads; manufacturers will like ease of assembly and customisation of models.
What's your view... scared of something new, or embracing progress?
 
I really like the concept but before the concept takes off and becomes viable, you need some promoters. I can't help you there.

I'm a DIYer, but I'm not prepared to saw off my horns keys to fit these. It's a BIG step to customize a sax to replace traditional pads by your system.

The only way forward is to produce horns using this concept. IMHO.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,680
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom