Saxophones Selmer Supreme alto (quick look)

[PigSquealer]

I love testing stuff.

I didn’t notice

 

[PigSquealer]

There's a lot of prejudice in some opinions.

Beginning with Eric Brand’s hate for Holton’s in his mid ‘30s repair guides.

 

[PigSquealer]

It'll be interesting to see how it stacks up against the one I saw recently.

Would also be interesting to compare SN#’s. Made the same week or months / years apart ?

 

[thomsax]

I‘m not a tech, but I have experience with saxes and different repair philosophies over almost 40 years. And I believe this one is not merely a matter of taste. I have had setups that stay well for a year or two and others that stay well for a decade or more with only minor tweaks. The latter were set up play-free with perfectly aligned cups, carefully levelled toneholes and not-too-soft pads of the right thickness to allow an even installation in the aligned cup.

If I need to fix something on my horns, I can get it leak free for the moment with all sorts of “soft compensation” of my lack of precision, including plenty of shellac/glue, softer pads, teflon wrapping etc. But it does neither stay like this for the same amount of time, nor does it feel the same. I think on the long run it definitely is even cheaper to do it right in the first place. Stays good forever.

I used to sell second-line -, student - or beginners saxes to aspiring rocksax players. Also Amati, Weltklang, Dörfler & Jörka made saxes. Most of the buyers were in their forties and returning to the sax after 20-25 years and they most of them couldn't afford or to justify to buy a Selmer, Keilwerth, Yamaha, Yanagisawa .... . So a cheap and playable sax was enough. To start to talk about premium saxes with them, maybe thier enthusiasm for honking Rocksax would had been lost?

My best sax is a Martin Handcraft (Committee) 1938 tenor, which I played a lot since 1995. A fine horn, well built with fine material and the guy who did the renovation back in 1995 did a very good job. I'm a good owner as well. I have been taken good care of my sax. Cleaning and minor adjustments.

I'm not tech or a good player. I been playing and listening to Blues, R&B, rock&roll ... since late 60's. But I have a story to tell. Right now I'm trying to put together an hour with blues (electric). I use to go to "bluesklubb" and sometimes we are asked to talk and play music (records). I'm going to play and talk about bluessongs which have saxes and play some sax as well A monitor, laptop. backing tracks on a stick and my sax! How to play and blend with my sax in Muddy Waters, Elmore James, Howlin' Wolf, Willy Dixon .... ? A dirty tenor in the style of Eddie Shaw, A.C. Reed, J.T.Brown ...... is the thing. My Martin is a fine blues horn.

 

[PigSquealer]

I used to sell second-line -, student - or beginners saxes to aspiring rocksax players. Also Amati, Weltklang, Dörfler & Jörka made saxes. Most of the buyers were in their forties and returning to the sax after 20-25 years and they most of them couldn't afford or to justify to buy a Selmer, Keilwerth, Yamaha, Yanagisawa .... . So a cheap and playable sax was enough. To start to talk about premium saxes with them, maybe thier enthusiasm for honking Rocksax would had been lost?

My best sax is a Martin Handcraft (Committee) 1938 tenor, which I played a lot since 1995. A fine horn, well built with fine material and the guy who did the renovation back in 1995 did a very good job. I'm a good owner as well. I have been taken good care of my sax. Cleaning and minor adjustments.

I'm not tech or a good player. I been playing and listening to Blues, R&B, rock&roll ... since late 60's. But I have a story to tell. Right now I'm trying to put together an hour with blues (electric). I use to go to "bluesklubb" and sometimes we are asked to talk and play music (records). I'm going to play and talk about bluessongs which have saxes and play some sax as well A monitor, laptop. backing tracks on a stick and my sax! How to play and blend with my sax in Muddy Waters, Elmore James, Howlin' Wolf, Willy Dixon .... ? A dirty tenor in the style of Eddie Shaw, A.C. Reed, J.T.Brown ...... is the thing. My Martin is a fine blues horn.

An honest reply from experience. Well noted the Martin Committee one was/is a fine sax.
Here’s my question. Given the choice today between a new Supreme and a new Comm 1 at same price point. What would the masses choose ?

 

[Stephen Howard]

An honest reply from experience. Well noted the Martin Committee one was/is a fine sax.
Here’s my question. Given the choice today between a new Supreme and a new Comm 1 at same price point. What would the masses choose ?

That's a tough one.

I rebuilt and played a Handcraft bari for years - and then did some work for a guy who played in a noted West Indian band...on a Martin tenor. I tried to buy it off him...but made the rookie mistake of telling him it was the best-sounding tenor I'd ever played. Would you sell if after someone told you that?

So yeah, they have a great inbuilt sound - but they have a LOT of build issues; and let's be honest, the action pales beside even a basic modern horn. Yeah, you can slap modern keywork on them...but it's a hell of a job, and it's not like there aren't some great modern horns out there these days.
Some years later I spent half a day going between my faithful old YTS-23 and a Martin. It was close...damned close...but I stuck with the Yamaha because the action on it was sublime. Tonewise they were closer than you might imagine. And that's why I have tremendous respect for Martin horns...they were way ahead of their time tonally, but they knew where they came from.

But to have to choose between a Supreme and a Martin?
I have two answers.

1: I'd take the Supreme. And while everyone's busy congratulating themselves on how the modern horn beat the vintage banger hands down, I'd sell it and buy something I really liked.

2: Assuming folks were wise to my ruse and nixxed it from the outset, I'd have the Martin - because at the very least I'd enjoy how it sounded...and in time I'd get used to its foibles (or mod the hell out of it).

But...and it's a big but - that's going on a sample of one Supreme. Let's see what the other one delivers.