Playing the saxophone self conscious playing problem

cityartisan

Member
Messages
12
Location
Indianapolis, IN
Level
beginner
Hi, recently started playing alto sax and liking it a lot! Have a tendency to worry a lot about others hearing me play and what they think of my playing. I tend to be by myself most of the time and so have only played solo so far. I would like to join an ensemble but don't think I'm good enough yet. Wondering if anyone out there has had the same experience and if and how you got over it? Thanks ahead of time.
 
Hi, recently started playing alto sax and liking it a lot! Have a tendency to worry a lot about others hearing me play and what they think of my playing. I tend to be by myself most of the time and so have only played solo so far. I would like to join an ensemble but don't think I'm good enough yet. Wondering if anyone out there has had the same experience and if and how you got over it? Thanks ahead of time.
Hi there. Almost everyone feels exactly the same as you do. I am a very strong advocate of people joining a band / ensemble / community orchestra / et cetera as early as possible. There are many benefits of doing so, including improving confidence to play.

There will be groups that expect and accept complete beginners, so you should not worry about being 'good enough'.
 
Wondering if anyone out there has had the same experience and if and how you got over it?

It's easy, I don't get over it. I just keep doing it over and over....what was that definition of insanity again?

Seriously though, I am currently struggling through this as I've been going to a (very laid-back) jam session every other week for the last few months. I am definitely the 'worst' player there and sometimes I do question my sanity, but I think it's critical for really learning how to play. I will +1 @Tenor Viol and say start playing with others as soon as possible.
 
My advice is keep on playing. Don't give a toss or a flying fook what other people think. Remember Brecker, Sanborn, Coltrane, Getz, Pepper or name your player were students once. The more you play the better you get...:thumb:

Greg S.

I should also add that everyone thinks they are a music expert especially the non-musicians...:rofl:

Greg S.
 
and how you got over it?
Its part of a larger problem: being human.

When I was very young I was devastated when eating in a restaurant, my father started to sing with the piano player. I was worried how other people would react. So I learned at a young age that there is always an audience.

If your teacher says that you have to play as if there is a large audience beyond a door, just open that door, look, close the door and say:

Your audience is very shy.
 
When you're playing/practising on your own always play as you are playing in front an audience. The right breathing technique, playing position, the right volume, look at the photos or what ever you're playing for, have a happy and "feeling good" attitude ...... . You want to be heard, even if you 're playing on your own and all alone!

I recommend group lessons instead of individual lessons. Ok, some lessons are better to do with just you and your teacher. I guess most of us are not ok in a teacher - student situation? A group of 2-3 student on roughly the same level is fine. Even teachers like group lessons.

Find groups or places where you play with others. The beginner and the more advanced player can play together and having fun. The limit is not the level of the players, it's the songs you're playing. You don't need to have so much reading and playing skills to play an easy blues, rock & roll .... riff.
 
Try to find a small group like the Cafe, was a trio when it started, now it is between 4 and however many turn up.
We drink lots tea and eat plenty of cake and biscuits. It's really good fun and @chadders always gives us a good workout regularly bringing new tunes to play. We can now sort of sight read, which is good for us. However, they only let me play because I'm the only one stupid enough to drag a baritone to every meeting. 😉 Keep checking here at the cafe to see if there are any groups like this want to start in your area. We now have played on a band stand in a local park and in old folks home. Never thought I'd have the confidence to do that. The audience is usually there to appreciate nt criticise. Great ego boost when they applaud.
 
Hi, recently started playing alto sax and liking it a lot! Have a tendency to worry a lot about others hearing me play and what they think of my playing. I tend to be by myself most of the time and so have only played solo so far. I would like to join an ensemble but don't think I'm good enough yet. Wondering if anyone out there has had the same experience and if and how you got over it? Thanks ahead of time.
We all go through that scenario, it is human to feel that way when dealing with new situations. You will find that once you take your bold step to do such, it will dispel any mental sterotyping. You may find quite to the contrary of mental thinking, some in the group may be able to put you at ease with their candour.

Also if you have "bitten off more than you can chew", you can back off and retry again at a later date, when you are more confident with your playing ability; or simply find another group.
 
As others have said, perfectly normal to feel apprehensive, firstly meeting a group of strangers and then having to play Infront of them.

From my experience joining a local orchestra, here's what I've learnt.

There will always be someone better than you, but that's usually a positive thing, as it will bring you on a player whether timing, rhythm or general musicianship.

You'll soon find your own strengths within a section, as a section you'll start to work to each others strengths. Maybe someone is more confident playing up on the palm keys, someone can play a challenging rhythm, there are times where all everyone needs is someone to have the confidence to come in.

Most musicians are generally friendly, happy to help and offer advice. Provided you don't have a an ego, or see it as competition to be better than everyone else you'll be fine. Playing with others is very much a team effort. Most importantly enjoy it.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,401
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom