Saxophones Saxello why it disappears

so the alto tenor and baritone over-the-shoulder horn players marched at the front of the band with the bells pointing rearward and the rest of the band could hear them.
I thought it was so the infantry marching behind could hear them.
 
The opinion about " King Saxello " is not 100 % positive among players. Maybe it's "50/50"? I don't consider myself to be a player when it comes to play old saxophones. I'm a saxophone owner when it comes to old saxes.

There is a lot of myth surrounding them and quite a few really bad YouTube videos from players who lack even the tiniest modicum of skill. And the majority of Saxellos out there in the market place is in piss-poor shape, I have seen quite a few of those.

But that doesn't really count as qualifying criteria for the horn itself. It's a specialty with a soul and either you get it or you don't. And if you get it, you still need to work on it - constantly.
 
The soprano saxophone was also used in combos, like Joe Liggins & his Honey Drippers ..... .Two sax players and four saxes on the stage. Even Bruce Springsteen & the East Street band used to have songs with soprano sax on the River tour 1980-81. So there was a small market for the soprano saxophone.

IMG_4860.webp
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4860.webp
    IMG_4860.webp
    71.3 KB · : 144
The soprano saxophone was also used in combos, like Joe Liggins & his Honey Drippers ..... .Two sax players and four saxes on the stage. Even Bruce Springsteen & the East Street band used to have songs with soprano sax on the River tour 1980-81. So there was a small market for the soprano saxophone.

View attachment 25650
I don't think anybody disputes that, John Helliwell. Jay Beckenstein, Branford Marsalis, Rick Washington and many more played soprano but it never reached the level of tenor or alto.
 
I'm not sure about that. To make 400 saxes/year is not what I would call mass production.
Well, therein lies the problem. Saxophones, automobiles, computer monitors, these kinds of things are made cost-effectively in mass production quantities. 400 pcs/yr is not a viable mass production quantity. You try to run 400 a year down a mass production line and you'll have excessive production cost;' Try to make 400 a year without mass production processes and each one'll cost you many thousands of dollars. A truly hand-crafted saxophone would probably cost $20,000 or more.

So if you can't sell a viable quantity of saxophones, or automobiles, or computer monitors, you don't make them. For any mass produced product there's a break-even production rate where profitability becomes viable. Every manufactured product is subject to this constraint. Companies that fail to pay attention this go out of business.
 
I don't think anybody disputes that, John Helliwell. Jay Beckenstein, Branford Marsalis, Rick Washington and many more played soprano but it never reached the level of tenor or alto.
After the alto saxophone I think it was the C-melody ..... . The C-melody became a very popular instrument to use in the parlour (family room, living rooms). But it was, more or less, just in USA the saxophone became so desirable. Easy to play as well. Just read over shoulder of the piano player and play the melody.

Many progressive rock bands had a soprano in thier settings. Players that were sharing their time with other instruments. Some guys I know was playing soprano in progressive rock band and when I asked them why they played sopranos they answered: "The tenor saxophone is too commercialized." Needless to write, but they were no good. Soprano saxophone is IMO hard to learn to play well.

Even blues players couldn't resist to have a soprano. Muddy Waters "Tom Cat" ("Electric Mud" LP). Gene Barge on the soprano?
View: https://youtu.be/RnK4mvFNj64?si=YkMMi_6I0PJXfQzx
 
After the alto saxophone I think it was the C-melody ..... . The C-melody became a very popular instrument to use in the parlour (family room, living rooms). But it was, more or less, just in USA the saxophone became so desirable. Easy to play as well. Just read over shoulder of the piano player and play the melody.

Many progressive rock bands had a soprano in thier settings. Players that were sharing their time with other instruments. Some guys I know was playing soprano in progressive rock band and when I asked them why they played sopranos they answered: "The tenor saxophone is too commercialized." Needless to write, but they were no good. Soprano saxophone is IMO hard to learn to play well.

Even blues players couldn't resist to have a soprano. Muddy Waters "Tom Cat" ("Electric Mud" LP). Gene Barge on the soprano?
View: https://youtu.be/RnK4mvFNj64?si=YkMMi_6I0PJXfQzx
Well. just think back some 40 years and what was going on in the European music scene. If you wanted to listen to good music, you had to buy a vinyl LP or borrow one and copy it on a cassette for your Walkman. Radio stations were almost exclusively run by state and church and the most progressive stuff you could find was a Polka. Saxophone? Never heard of it unless it was classical sax.

Southern Germany and Berlin were a bit of an exception with AFN and RIAS (I loved their weather forecast, which never changed: "Mostly cloudy skies with scattered rain showers" year in year out).

Then in the mid 70s the pirate stations started up. Radio Veronica, Nordsee off the coast of the Netherlands until they hung them out to dry by changing the law so that advertising on any of those stations became a felony and they eventually had to give up.

Radio Xanadu was one of the few surviving stations, built in that small stretch of no-mans-land at the Brenner Pass (the border between Italy and Austria and broadcasting straight into Germany. And they played jazz! The Italians didn't care, the Austrians didn't either and still somebody managed to plant a few sticks of dynamite and blow up the antenna.

A lot of this was rumored to be orchestrated by the record companies, EMI/Electrola and others

I know this is a bit of a long discourse but if you wanted to listen to some saxophone in Europe, you had to buy the records and that did not help its acceptance.

Eventually some of this crap went away, courtesy of a few like Klaus Doldinger and, ironically one of the whodunit TV shows with one iconic episode featuring Miles Davis's Sketches of Spain as the music score.

We were actually allowed to bring Miles records to high school music class afterwards.

Bottom line, most people maybe knew that saxophones existed somewhere but that's where it ended.
 
After the alto saxophone I think it was the C-melody ..... . The C-melody became a very popular instrument to use in the parlour (family room, living rooms). But it was, more or less, just in USA the saxophone became so desirable. Easy to play as well. Just read over shoulder of the piano player and play the melody.

Many progressive rock bands had a soprano in thier settings. Players that were sharing their time with other instruments. Some guys I know was playing soprano in progressive rock band and when I asked them why they played sopranos they answered: "The tenor saxophone is too commercialized." Needless to write, but they were no good. Soprano saxophone is IMO hard to learn to play well.

Even blues players couldn't resist to have a soprano. Muddy Waters "Tom Cat" ("Electric Mud" LP). Gene Barge on the soprano?
View: https://youtu.be/RnK4mvFNj64?si=YkMMi_6I0PJXfQzx
You're mixing the musical environment of the great saxophone craze of the late teens and early twenties, with "progressive rock" from the 1960s (which is also when "Electric Mud" was recorded). Two VERY different times, two VERY different kinds of music.

The whole point of the thread was "why the Saxello didn't stay around?" The Saxello was GONE, GONE, GONE by the late 1920s, long before the musicians in progressive rock bands were even glints in the milkman's eye. It wasn't till Coltrane picked up soprano in the late 50s and started using it in the avant garde context that anyone except a few French Conservatoire students even knew what the heck it was. Very many players in the avant garde of ROCK listened very carefully in the 1960s to what the guys in the avant garde of JAZZ were doing, and that's how soprano made its way into rock and roll. I can assure you that it wasn't from listening to the recordings of Sidney Bechet and Charlie Barnet.
 
The opinion about " King Saxello " is not 100 % positive among players. Maybe it's "50/50"? I don't consider myself to be a player when it comes to play old saxophones. I'm a saxophone owner when it comes to old saxes.
Is the answer to this:
My next question is why european don't made saxello

If saxello has a advantages why don't make it at this period,
If they choose to don't make it, they're reason, but i don't know exactly the reason about this
It likely never really 'caught on'. As noted, it was its own thing, and a bit more tempermental to play than a standard straight or curvy. Not as problematic as some people make it out to be today, IMHO, but still it takes a good tech dial-in and some woodshedding to really get a good grasp of it.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom