Saxophones Saxello why it disappears

In regards to why they were stopped being produced, also....Sops...big bands didn't need soprano parts....and big bands started coming into commercial favor in the 30's (some sources will claim they originated as far back as the 19-teens, but I am talking about your standard big band dance/swing band, a 4-4-4 or 5-4-4 classic, standard one...not referring just "extended/embellished" dixieland bands which ahd multiple horns/reeds but no real 'sectional' arrangements/structure per se.

Unlike the Cornet, which managed to survive being cast aside as an un-serious jazz instrument, primarily because it maintained usage in classical and concert bands....

...the Sop never had much usage in either of those contexts so when small-ensemble/Dixie/etc. got supplanted by big band...there was no other band context for the sop, really.
Just had a few, lonely loyalists left who used 'em....
 
can be set up to play no less in tune than any other soprano.

After my last Uber Haul of my own Saxello and Borgani, I pitted both against my 1928 straight Conn (bare brass, RTH) and, oh yeah, I treated myself to an Electrovoice RE20 in addition to my Sterling ST51.
Great comparison. The Borgani is a DARK-toned Soprano, I have refurbed a number of them. The Conn is considered by most sop players to be dark, but again compared to the old Borg.... it actually sounds sorta bright. Yet next to a Yamaha or Yani, the Conn does sound dark and lush.

But... compare the Borg to the Saxello, and really, IMHO, the Saxello sounds almost
un-soprano-like, outside of the register of the notes.
That is why I say the Saxello was something different from a sop with a tipped bell....it really was its own thing.
 
I answered on your thread on SOTW, but basically you got your answer here. It wasn't just Saxellos that vanished, it was ALL SOPRANOS (American manufacture).
I have a 1928 Buescher TT soprano LP-122 model. According to Vincent Bach International they were made until 1969 on special order. Buescher TT was popular among classical players.


Try to find a King, Conn, Holton, Buescher or Martin Soprano from the 50's-60's....you cannot, because they stopped being made by the 40's. Only the Italian and French made Sops in the 50's-60's.
Don't forget German (both BRD and GDR) and CZ manufactures.
 
Last edited:
In regards to why they were stopped being produced, also....Sops...big bands didn't need soprano parts....and big bands started coming into commercial favor in the 30's (some sources will claim they originated as far back as the 19-teens, but I am talking about your standard big band dance/swing band, a 4-4-4 or 5-4-4 classic, standard one...not referring just "extended/embellished" dixieland bands which ahd multiple horns/reeds but no real 'sectional' arrangements/structure per se.

Unlike the Cornet, which managed to survive being cast aside as an un-serious jazz instrument, primarily because it maintained usage in classical and concert bands....

...the Sop never had much usage in either of those contexts so when small-ensemble/Dixie/etc. got supplanted by big band...there was no other band context for the sop, really.
Just had a few, lonely loyalists left who used 'em....
Really, even in the earlier days of jazz, I think the soprano was mostly used as a prop, to help create that "forest of woodwinds" you see in old band photos.

Serious soprano players in jazz? There's kind of Bechet and pretty much no one else in the top tier of pre-swing players on soprano. Yeah, it was in there from time to time as a double. By the late 20s it was all clarinet, but it was pretty much mostly all clarinet before that.

There are a few soprano parts in concert band repertoire of the early 20th century, so town bands would often have had a soprano player.

So mass production of sopranos in the US was a tenuous business even in the early 20s with the sax craze; it lost its feasibility in the mid 20s; the Big Two continued making a FEW of them (but no development) into the 30s; there were a tiny number even made later from old parts (I mean, like single digit tiny number, like the "lady face" Conn or the "Buescher 400" soprano, that I've seen pictures of, but which are horns from the 20s with later engraving). The only reason Selmer (Buffet? someone else in Europe?) kept making them was because of the small but persistent conservatory classical usage.

We've all read the story about how when Coltrane ran across a soprano he had to ask what key it was in - he was already a famous professional saxophonist by then.
 
Funny thing here is these days Saxellos are a 'grail' saxophone.
I know and the demand is getting stronger regardless of all the tipped-bell thingies coming out of China.

The tube of a King Saxello vs. King straight are different specifications. They were different designs. That' why, if you listen closely, a Saxello and a 'regular' sop (even a King one) don't really sound the same.

Exactly. Probably even Grumps would sound different, wall or not. 🙂
 
The only reason Selmer (Buffet? someone else in Europe?) kept making them was because of the small but persistent conservatory classical usage.
Even then wasn't the MKVI soprano based on an early model rather than it being a brand new design like the altos and tenors?
 
But then he did some of his most iconic works on soprano.
The point was, that when he first saw a soprano sax, he was an experienced professional saxophonist and it was so unfamiliar to him that he didn't even know it was pitched in Bb.

I went back through the Wikipedia "List of Jazz Saxophonists" and I confirmed, in pre-swing they only list Bechet. In the swing era, exactly two prominent saxophonists were listed as "soprano" along with other voices: Hodges and Barnet (Hodges of course primarily on alto and Barnet primarily on tenor, but with a fair amount of alto).

Of course I'm sure a large number of saxophonists and clarinettists in the swing and pre-swing eras occasionally doubled on soprano when a particular arrangement called for it, just like they'd have done for flute or English horn, but as far as someone being specifically identifed with the soprano, of prominent players I only see Bechet, Hodges, and Barnet before the late-50s explosion in interest. And for Hodges and Barnet it was definitely a secondary double. So, as I say, soprano was NEVER a popular heavily used instrument until the late 50s, so its production in the US was always tenuous at best.
 
Even then wasn't the MKVI soprano based on an early model rather than it being a brand new design like the altos and tenors?
The keywork of the Mark 6 soprano is old-style; the keywork of all the Selmer sopranos back to the first model after the Model 26 is pretty much identical; but I've never seen anyone positively confirm or refute whether the acoustical design changed or not. It seems I vaguely remember someone saying there was an acoustical change in there somewhere.
 
The point was, that when he first saw a soprano sax, he was an experienced professional saxophonist and it was so unfamiliar to him that he didn't even know it was pitched in Bb.

I went back through the Wikipedia "List of Jazz Saxophonists" and I confirmed, in pre-swing they only list Bechet. In the swing era, exactly two prominent saxophonists were listed as "soprano" along with other voices: Hodges and Barnet (Hodges of course primarily on alto and Barnet primarily on tenor, but with a fair amount of alto).

Of course I'm sure a large number of saxophonists and clarinettists in the swing and pre-swing eras occasionally doubled on soprano when a particular arrangement called for it, just like they'd have done for flute or English horn, but as far as someone being specifically identifed with the soprano, of prominent players I only see Bechet, Hodges, and Barnet before the late-50s explosion in interest. And for Hodges and Barnet it was definitely a secondary double. So, as I say, soprano was NEVER a popular heavily used instrument until the late 50s, so its production in the US was always tenuous at best.
I never understood the clarinet thing. I get flute, ok, I love bass clarinet, but I've always found clarinet pretty annoying, like a stick version of a bag pipe.

But you are right, soprano sax was mostly used as doubling instrument until Kenny G.

On the other hand, I had a 50+ years professional sax player, 40 years sax teacher stop by my house and when I showed him the saxello he asked what key it was in. It IS way shorter than a soprano so he thought it might be C. It never hurts to ask when there is even the slightest doubt.
 
Last edited:
I never understood the clarinet thing. I get flute, ok, I love bass clarinet, but I've always found clarinet pretty annoying, like a stick version of a bag pipe.

But you are right, soprano sax was mostly used as doubling instrument until Kenny G.

On the other hand, I had a 50+ years professional sax player, 40 years sax teacher stop by my house and when I showed him the saxello he asked what key it was in. It IS way shorter than a soprano so he thought it might be C. It never hurts to ask when there is even the slightest doubt.
Original New Orleans jazz was played using instruments that were readily available. That meant clarinet, cornet, trombone, piano. Some bands had violinists. Tuba or double-bass. These are all standard instruments from the orchestra or military band. Saxophones were rare in early jazz.

When the N.O. guys started dispersing to places like Chicago and NYC, and when players in those areas started hearing both the bands and records, they heard lots of clarinets cornets and trombones. Few saxophones. So clarinet was the high treble ornamentation instrument.
 
I rather doubt that US military bands, or town bands, or factory bands, or fraternal organization bands, in the period 1880-1910, used many fifes.
 
The trumpets(?) with over the shoulder bells, however...

1000001052.webp
 
Funny thing here is these days Saxellos are a 'grail' saxophone.

I agree with other commenters...a Saxello, honestly, is a cool horn, not really all that problematic at all to a player used to playing vintage Altos or Tenors....WHEN the horn is dialed-in correctly by a good tech.

What it ISN'T....is... "just a straight with a curved bellpiece and neck".

The tube of a King Saxello vs. King straight are different specifications. They were different designs. That' why, if you listen closely, a Saxello and a 'regular' sop (even a King one) don't really sound the same.

I answered on your thread on SOTW, but basically you got your answer here. It wasn't just Saxellos that vanished, it was ALL SOPRANOS (American manufacture).

Try to find a King, Conn, Holton, Buescher or Martin Soprano from the 50's-60's....you cannot, because they stopped being made by the 40's. Only the Italian and French made Sops in the 50's-60's.
My next question is why european don't made saxello

If saxello has a advantages why don't make it at this period,
If they choose to don't make it, they're reason, but i don't know exactly the reason about this
 
My next question is why european don't made saxello

If saxello has a advantages why don't make it at this period,
If they choose to don't make it, they're reason, but i don't know exactly the reason about this
Because it is an almost impossible design. Yes, you can build it and yes, you can get it in tune with the right mouthpiece and setup but you are looking at a niche market and a huge overhead for getting it out into the market place and an even bigger overhead for dealing with all the Yahoos who want one because it is fashionable but then resort to buyer's remorse because they are not willing to invest the time to learn and the money to maintain an instrument like the Saxello. And trust me, I know every screw and every rod and cup on that thing and I love it the same way I love my Bugatti 57SC - just kidding, I wish ...

The Saxello has the advantage of being elusive, a unicorn among saxophones but an affordable one compared to a Coon-O-Phone (I can't even tell you how much I wish I had one) but it has features that make it very difficult to master. The very same features are what is so appealing about it.

If you come out with a "lite version" it won't be the real thing but you still run into headaches with customers who expect to sound like Rahsaan Roland Kirk and it just won't happen, If you copy it .., good luck, you better have an army or specialty-trained techs standing by.
 
My next question is why european don't made saxello

If saxello has a advantages why don't make it at this period,
If they choose to don't make it, they're reason, but i don't know exactly the reason about this
R&C made a sax that they called "Saxello". Nothing to do with the real thing.

The opinion about " King Saxello " is not 100 % positive among players. Maybe it's "50/50"? I don't consider myself to be a player when it comes to play old saxophones. I'm a saxophone owner when it comes to old saxes.

You can try to come in touch with the European manufacturers that are still in business; Selmer, Keilwerth, Amati, Buffe?, R&C, Brogan ..... . I guess is not a problem to make a saxello. The problem is who is going to pay for research and developing? And who is going to sell the new saxellos? Are there enough with twisted sax players that are willing to pay lots of money for a Bb soprano?
 
The soprano saxophone was not a frequently used sax in popular music back in the 30's and 40's. Still useful in the classical music. It would be interesting to know how many sopranos that were made during the roaring decade?

I have information that says Buescher made around 500 C-sopranos. If they made 500 saxes over a period of 10 years, it would be c 50 C-sopranos/year or less than one C-soprano/week?

How many "king Saxello were made? Introduced in 1924 and went out of production in the late 20' or early 30's.
 
Last edited:
My next question is why european don't made saxello

If saxello has a advantages why don't make it at this period,
If they choose to don't make it, they're reason, but i don't know exactly the reason about this
Because they don't feel they can make a profit doing so.

Remember, saxophones are mass produced items, intended to be sold at a profit that pays back development costs, tooling, etc., within a reasonable amount of time. Saxophone manufacturing is no different than making computer monitors or toothbrushes. Sales revenue less material, labor, manufacturing overhead, MG&A, tooling, depreciation and project costs equals profit. No profit, no product.
 
The trumpets(?) with over the shoulder bells, however...

View attachment 25648
Not trumpets, those look like alto tenor and baritone horns - members of the cornet/tuba family. They were used in military marching in preference to trombones, because the trombones would have to march at the back for the rest of the band to hear them and then the slides interfered with proper marching spacing; but if the trombones are at the front, the rest of the band can't hear them; so the alto tenor and baritone over-the-shoulder horn players marched at the front of the band with the bells pointing rearward and the rest of the band could hear them. The largest horns there look like what would today be small tubas, maybe in Eb. Oddly enough, I can see the valve slides clearly but I can't see the valves clearly enough to tell if they're piston or rotary. I suspect rotary.

It took a long time for low brass to settle into the present configurations, and even now it's not totally fixed. For example in clarinets you pretty much universally have Eb, Bb, bass all in Boehm configuration, flutes are C and piccolo. Saxophones are Eb and Bb, we all know the sizes, and the C family are curiosities. But in low and medium brass you still have mellophones, marching baritones, upright bell and forward bell baritones and euphoniums all occupying roughly the same range, not to mention the upper end of the F tuba and the bass trombone in all its variants plus the rare contrabass trombone and the equally rare bass trumpet.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom