Playing the saxophone Sax playing after heart attack

That’s a sign, you should play more because yes it’s good for health 🙂

Sorry to hear of this challenge @Janosax . I suspect you will be able to play again, but that some new "protocols" may be helpful to consider.

One thing I want to mention that you might discuss with your MD is the bacteria and "organic matter" consideration.

Related to Covid research, I discovered some (known, materially documented by medical professionals) things that had never come to my attention in the past because, despite 20 years of professional activity, they just didn't come up, at least for me. The major one is that 2 things are common for woodwind players, as far as respiratory effects related to playing: 1) stronger lungs (greater ability to suck air in and expel it) and 2) respiratory issues -- irritations, conditions -- probably related to repetitive bacterial and other allergen (molds, fungii, etc.) exposure.

Your MD is unlikely to know off-the-top that those latter items are "organic" issues within saxophones, i.e. won't think of them immediately, but they may be future considerations for playing safely in the future. Bacterial and other types of infections and respiratory irritants will probably be different kinds of risks than in the past.

Good luck! I'm sure you'll play again, and maybe even more happily (because nothing is as awesome as that which we love that we now recognize to be a blessing that can be taken away) than before.
 
Sorry to hear of this challenge @Janosax . I suspect you will be able to play again, but that some new "protocols" may be helpful to consider.

One thing I want to mention that you might discuss with your MD is the bacteria and "organic matter" consideration.

Related to Covid research, I discovered some (known, materially documented by medical professionals) things that had never come to my attention in the past because, despite 20 years of professional activity, they just didn't come up, at least for me. The major one is that 2 things are common for woodwind players, as far as respiratory effects related to playing: 1) stronger lungs (greater ability to suck air in and expel it) and 2) respiratory issues -- irritations, conditions -- probably related to repetitive bacterial and other allergen (molds, fungii, etc.) exposure.

Your MD is unlikely to know off-the-top that those latter items are "organic" issues within saxophones, i.e. won't think of them immediately, but they may be future considerations for playing safely in the future. Bacterial and other types of infections and respiratory irritants will probably be different kinds of risks than in the past.

Good luck! I'm sure you'll play again, and maybe even more happily (because nothing is as awesome as that which we love that we now recognize to be a blessing that can be taken away) than before.

Sorry for late reply. Thanks. And yes I’m more concerned about what you mention now. I think playing synthetic reeds is a step in good direction, much more safe. I also dry the whole inside sax much more carefully including drying pads with proper tools like BG and Key leaves stuff, after each session.


Key Leaves Spit Sponge Saxophone – Thomann France

Useful antibacterial MPC cleaner for outside playing:

Thomann Mouthpiece Cleaning Spray – Thomann France


Also, for ending the story my heart training cardiologist had confirmed to me yesterday that sax playing involves Valsalva maneuver 🙂

She said there was no issues for me playing sax again, just being a tad careful with higher energy playing for a while, being progressive is the key.
 
Awesome. I've realized, too, that my younger-years idea that I would really try to learn to play in my twilight years was kind of foolish. One can never take for granted the ability to do anything (something all the old people learn, and sometimes try to get across to the younger people, and with any luck very occasionally someone takes it to heart and goes further, and farther, thanks to not thinking themselves invincible for far longer than they are -- which is not at all, lol).

Not trying to be a bossy, but off the top of my head if trying to really keep a horn clean and sanitary, this would be something like my own checklist:

1) always brush teeth before playing (thus no, or a minimum, of calories end up being deposited inside the saxophone -- nothing to eat for bacteria = no or less bacteria). Also, toothpaste seems to have some antibacterial function?

2) I guess if you really wanted to go The Full 9, you could sub any leather pads with synthetic with synthetic felts. Pisoni sells a waterproof pad that would probably be a very good choice.

3) wash mouthpiece with a mouthpiece brush and dishsoap after every use

4) swab neck after every use, then also wash with neck brush/snake and dishsoap, allow to air dry, after every use

5) drain horn (the old fashioned, caveman way), swab and allow to air dry with case open every night.

I guess one could try to figure out something safe for the player and harmful to bacteria to put on the body swab before using it, but I would stay away from rubbing alcohol, because it might harm the pads. Something to look into? I dunno. I love lists. Hopefully it's of some, rather than zero utility lol
 
I admit to not having read the 3rd page of posts because as a Heart Attack survivor I want to tell you why you're doing great and shouldn't worry. You are way ahead of the game and it will all get better much more quickly than you think. For one thing you are relatively young and furthermore you only have had stents and not open-heart surgery. Right there you are better than I was by at least a year, year and a half as I will explain.

Back in January 2017 I left a club where I had been listening to my friends' band playing and as I got to the edge of the patio entrance by the sidewalk two guys stabbed me both at once in both pecs with what felt like oyster-shucking knives. If you don't know what those are they look like this.....
H2bfcbe1f0fb14a7d83fb220dc1f0b113K.jpg_q50.jpg

The oyster shells represent my two pectoral muscles and yes it hurt enough to make me visualize those as the cause. I got dizzy, saw stars and thought I was going to pass out but didn't and the pain went away after a bit and I sat down on the steps there to contemplate what that might have been and if it were indeed a heart attack because you see I had never had one to know what it's like. In fact not one doctor had ever told me that I was in danger of having one, and I was 73 when this happened. So much for preventative medicine and frequent testing.

Fast-forward to the Hospital Cardiac ward where they sent me right from the ER after they determined that it indeed had been a coronary. I was there for a week having all sorts of tests and scans and waiting for the operating theater appointment. The decision was made to operate because I had the two major arteries seriously clogged and a third peripheral one that had burst causing the attack and the only option was to do a triple bypass. Stents could not have been put in because the clogs were too close to the heart itself, and they would fall into it.

Now if you don't know about arteries, the two major ones that go directly into the heart are called the Widow Makers because usually when they fail, you are dead right there where you were standing but now lying lifeless. In my case I was very fortunate that neither of those went and it was the less important one on the left side of my chest.

Cut to the chase....a triple bypass operation is OHS...open-heart surgery where they saw your sternum open, spread your rib cage fully apart and take your heart out to be able to work on it while you are hooked up to a heart lung machine. These operations are commonplace these days and rarely have complications, However, having one is, as the surgeon told me afterwards when I mentioned being unable to even move, like being run over by a flotilla of giant lorries (to a yank it's like being run over by a 16-wheeler pulling a full cement mixer). In fact, it was more like being trampled by a stampede of all the elephants, zebra and wildebeests on the Serengeti urged on by David Attenboro -- but why quibble.

It took me 3 weeks in the hospital to recover enough to be able to walk down the hall and they let me go home. But I couldn't stand for more than a minute or stand in the shower or do much of anything except lie on the couch and then do the exercises they had taught me. I was on a faft load of meds which I still take daily and I went to Cardiac rehab. It was 4.5 months more to recover enough to be able to walk around and do much of anything. I didn't even try to play my tenor until 9 months had gone by and even then it was slow-going. It was not until the beginning of the next year that I felt good enough to go out and jam, but by 9 months later I realized that I didn't have the stamina to do what it takes to play out in clubs anymore.....haul my horn, drive there, park walk to the club, stand on stage amidst a zillion cables while keeping my balance and not falling over from the pain in my feet and ankles that the effort of standing with the tenor caused. This was due to both age....I was then 74, and I was suffering from Cardiac insufficiency which makes doing anything physical harder and more tiring. So I gave up the club scene and went back to just playing at home for myself seated.

Now that sounds lousy but the good news is that now at almost 77 I feel so much better it's almost like being the way I was before the HA. More importantly for your situation, my stamina for playing is very much improved. I can play for 2 or 3 hours at a time when I want and feel fine afterwards but I just can't do it standing much at all. I haven't gone out to play at all but that's been impossible here since March due to Covid. If and when the virus is neutralized by a functional vaccine and musical life goes back to some semblance of what it used to be I think I have the wherewithal to go and jam, but on alto and not tenor just to lessen the load.

So to the OP I say, you are in much better shape than I was or even am now almost 4 years out, so take heart man, hang in there and do what the doctors tell you to do to heal ASAP. Remember, no pain, no gain and when the going gets tough, the tough get going. Cheers
 
There was some rain yesterday and today, but temps were still quite high, no lower than 33/35°C. That should be better in the days to come 🙂



Thanks you very much 🙂



Thanks for the kind words. I don’t even realize it, but yes perhaps it’s an artist way of thinking. All I can say is that returning to sax playing is my current obsession, even more than my global health as I feel now so much better, I’m on the right way. I think I just want to feel alive 🙂



I’m still quite moderate on my efforts, even if I check my capabilities. Thanks for the encouragements 🙂

I played sax again yesterday and today for 35 mn each day. I sweat a little bit as usual with heart pulse between 80 and 95 bpm with a few peaks above that. I recover to 60/70 bpm in less than 2 mn, the medication is here also quite efficient and offer a valid protection.
I’ve bought a connected watch to monitor my heart and it’s quite a good tool for that purpose, it’s even able to take ECG.
I use Legere 2 instead usual 2.25 and that helps too. I don’t push my playing loudness and energy too much, and take smalls 1 or 2 mn breaks here and there.

A fun thing is as I stopped playing sax for some weeks, my 5 brand new D’Addario Select reeds all have green mold now.... I played each of them perhaps one or two times in June, then stored them in Vandoren blue cases with some Listerine (on sponges). That has not worked well. I´ve bought Rejuvinate perhaps 10 years ago and had a similar bad experience. For me, it’s like a sign, I was ready to buy an expensive Reedgeek but I think I will only use Legere Signature like I did for last 3 years. I don’t want that green stuff in my lungs at all!!
I’m health conservative now!! 🙂
Hi, I live in Barcelona, and we have a very humid climate here especially in summer. This past summer was not only hotter than Hades but also very moist. My reeds have not gotten mold of any kind in years because I stopped doing all that wet sponge b.s. routine, which is what in fact causes it. I used pure straight Vodka in the jar with the reeds, and they all grew mushrooms practically. I had to toss them all. What I do for a reed routine is as follows:

I hardly ever soak them before playing anymore and if I do it's at most for 2 minutes. Mostly I just suck on them for about 45 seconds or until I gag while I am putting the mpc on the neck. Then once in place I lick and suck the reed some more and start playing. Within a couple of minutes it is fully functional. Forget all those jars of liquid and reed geeky things. They are the Klangbogen of the reed loonies. You'll drive yourself crazy with all those rigmaroles. I keep them in clear plastic Tupperware type containers in loose original Van Doren holders and some few black multi Rico ones from the store. I took all my 100 or so Rico plastic holders and hot-glued them together in groups of 6 just like the store bought back-to-back ones, but they are clear plastic and have plenty of spaces for air to flow through and dry the reeds. If you let the wet reeds dry out either before storing them or even in these holders, they will not generally mold. I posted about this on another thread and you should search for it to see what they look like.

Man, life is too short to waste time futzing with reed care. Just take on and slap it on and play the sax. If it doesn't play well at that moment put it back in the holder and choose another one because for sure it will on another day and another time. That's how reeds are by nature we must adapt to them, not they to us. You dig?
 
Your practice session frequency and duration put a guy like me to shame! Great work!
It's interesting that your post is today as this marks the beginning of my seventh year with my replacement valve. I think we should both keep on blowing. There seems to be a number of health benefits to playing an instrument. I would guess that reed care is very important as things can grow in wood that might not be so healthful. One person commented a while ago that brushing one's teeth prior to practice is a good idea. I've been doing that ever since I read that one.
I have always done so because who wants all that left over food and gook that you spit into the sink getting stuck to the inside of your horn. I have read the horror stories and seen the photos so always brush or even gargle with Listerine and brush too. Doing that will improve the life of your mpc and your sax on top of the reeds. Those are the cheapest item in the equation you realize.
 
Fortunately, a sax player doesn’t have to be a heart specialist to play his sax 😉

You have to understand that my main concern is to play sax like before my heart attack, as much as possible, but I have some doubts about that because it’s so physical. My goal is to play sax looping alone on stage in front of people for one hour set, that will be demanding. I hope that dream is still possible today. Time and training will tell.

About Valsalva, I don’t really know anything about that. But I’m sure that sax playing involves some apnea skills, after all these years playing I know my body.

In the meantime I’ve found also this:

From science direct



Tuba players and Valsalva




Another source mentioning saxophone



Valsalva and brass playing

This one is interesting about articulation/tonging.



By curiosity I will ask my heart doctor. Perhaps I will end knowing more that average sax player about that topic🙂


Many activities of our daily lives such as straining during defecation or playing the saxophone entail performance of Valsalva maneuver.

I don't know whether to be shocked or laugh reading that playing the sax is like straining to pinch a loaf. I think I have to laugh and be happy because if that were true I would have to wear depends every time I play. This is because when I was 65 I had bowel cancer and the treatment they cured me with (thankful for that of course) was radiation on my crotch both from the front and rear. So to put it discreetly, they fried my genitals and then for good measure, my rectum....That reminds me of that junior high level joke that went "....did it kill him?" "No, but it nearly rectum".

It's all Ha ha until they drop a baby A-bomb on your rear end and fry your sphincter to KFC standards. I only mention this because if playing the sax was the same as straining to poop I would have to stop eating solid food.

So my contention is that there is not connection between those two activities although your heart may get some exercise doing either. Hell, when I strain to poop, sometimes my sternum zipper still pops loud enough to be heard by others. This after almost 4 years now. So I think my heart can withstand that pressure as well as the pressure of playing sax simply because in the last year and a half of playing I have built up my chops to be able to blow a open tip high baffle mpc with a 3.5 reed for a couple of hours while freely improvising.

One thing I want to suggest to you Janosax is to get one of these breathing devices they usually give heart patients. I mean the one below with the tube to inhale and exhale on to raise the little balls in their columns. In one direction you inhale to raise them and then turn it over and have to exhale to do it. When you can do it with no straining in both ways and keep the balls at the top for a long time, I guarantee it will help your sax practice. However, it may be that you are already able to do that in which case just work on extending the time you keep them floating.

I had one of those and couldn't do anything at first but once I started healing that was the best exercise for my lungs there was. I didn't start back on sax until I could lift those balls to the top and keep them there for a decent amount of time. Even so, I only played on my most closed mpcs with soft reeds at the start and worked my way back up to where I was before I had what I now recognize were the warning signs of the impending HA. Too bad I didn't how to recognize them at the time.+
41pulHlXiSL.webp
 
Many activities of our daily lives such as straining during defecation or playing the saxophone entail performance of Valsalva maneuver.

I don't know whether to be shocked or laugh reading that playing the sax is like straining to pinch a loaf. I think I have to laugh and be happy because if that were true I would have to wear depends every time I play. This is because when I was 65 I had bowel cancer and the treatment they cured me with (thankful for that of course) was radiation on my crotch both from the front and rear. So to put it discreetly, they fried my genitals and then for good measure, my rectum....That reminds me of that junior high level joke that went "....did it kill him?" "No, but it nearly rectum".

It's all Ha ha until they drop a baby A-bomb on your rear end and fry your sphincter to KFC standards. I only mention this because if playing the sax was the same as straining to poop I would have to stop eating solid food.

So my contention is that there is not connection between those two activities although your heart may get some exercise doing either. Hell, when I strain to poop, sometimes my sternum zipper still pops loud enough to be heard by others. This after almost 4 years now. So I think my heart can withstand that pressure as well as the pressure of playing sax simply because in the last year and a half of playing I have built up my chops to be able to blow a open tip high baffle mpc with a 3.5 reed for a couple of hours while freely improvising.

One thing I want to suggest to you Janosax is to get one of these breathing devices they usually give heart patients. I mean the one below with the tube to inhale and exhale on to raise the little balls in their columns. In one direction you inhale to raise them and then turn it over and have to exhale to do it. When you can do it with no straining in both ways and keep the balls at the top for a long time, I guarantee it will help your sax practice. However, it may be that you are already able to do that in which case just work on extending the time you keep them floating.

I had one of those and couldn't do anything at first but once I started healing that was the best exercise for my lungs there was. I didn't start back on sax until I could lift those balls to the top and keep them there for a decent amount of time. Even so, I only played on my most closed mpcs with soft reeds at the start and worked my way back up to where I was before I had what I now recognize were the warning signs of the impending HA. Too bad I didn't how to recognize them at the time.+
View attachment 16383

So poetic!! Thanks a lot for that post!! You have to blow hard with higher energy level to feel the connection. Diaphragm is passive while pushing air outside of body, only abdominal and dorsal muscles compress visceral to create vertical thrust against diaphragm and then lungs. This can lead to the opposite trust direction at the same time, but you have have to play your sax with intensive and expressive energy to feel it 🙂 I myself experienced that only when younger/less experienced player and when I was more in « free jazz » high energy playing.
 
Last edited:
So poetic!! Thanks a lot for that post!! You have to blow hard with higher energy level to feel the connection. Diaphragm is passive while pushing air outside of body, only abdominal and dorsal muscles compress visceral to create vertical thrust against diaphragm and then lungs. This can lead to the opposite trust direction at the same time, but you have have to play your sax with intensive and expressive energy to feel it 🙂 I myself experienced that only when younger/less experienced player and when I was more in « free jazz » high energy playing.
The other day I had an experience that proved to me that contrary to what I thought, my blood pressure doesn't rise during the more intense and forceful moments on the throne. It so happened that I had just attached my blood pressure meter to my arm when the message came that it was either run to the throne-room immediately or be wearing the output where I was.

So I ran there and as I was pushing out digestive byproducts I took my BP. I figured it would be high due to the pressure of straining I was exerting, but no! In fact, it was almost as low as it gets at 117/70. I've been down as low as 107/60 when resting and taking my BP. However, my pulse was up at 110 with that activity, so that means my heart rate was up but not the BP during the brown act. Now I'll have to take my BP when I am blowing tenor and alto to see what happens with those activities.

BTW, I think it apt to mention that what you said about playing free jazz would seem to prove what many critics used to say about it being nothing but loose Sh¡te. :doh:

.
 
Given the primary target was to the rear; did they irradiate your dangly bits out of spite?
Yeah, good question. I never asked about that, but it seems to me...in hindsight (sic)....that they could have provided me with a lead lined Co€k Sock to isolate my heritage from the nuclear bomb. Instead, they turned me into a serving of human Prairie Oysters served with a fried giant prawn. 😡😱:confused2:
 
The other day I had an experience that proved to me that contrary to what I thought, my blood pressure doesn't rise during the more intense and forceful moments on the throne. It so happened that I had just attached my blood pressure meter to my arm when the message came that it was either run to the throne-room immediately or be wearing the output where I was.

So I ran there and as I was pushing out digestive byproducts I took my BP. I figured it would be high due to the pressure of straining I was exerting, but no! In fact, it was almost as low as it gets at 117/70. I've been down as low as 107/60 when resting and taking my BP. However, my pulse was up at 110 with that activity, so that means my heart rate was up but not the BP during the brown act. Now I'll have to take my BP when I am blowing tenor and alto to see what happens with those activities.

BTW, I think it apt to mention that what you said about playing free jazz would seem to prove what many critics used to say about it being nothing but loose Sh¡te. :doh:

.
Those critics are not musicians, most of the time.
 
Yeah, good question. I never asked about that, but it seems to me...in hindsight (sic)....that they could have provided me with a lead lined Co€k Sock to isolate my heritage from the nuclear bomb. Instead, they turned me into a serving of human Prairie Oysters served with a fried giant prawn. 😡😱:confused2:
Or maybe the meat and two veg are used as fleshy lenses to split the beam onto three rectal targets
 
The other day I had an experience that proved to me that contrary to what I thought, my blood pressure doesn't rise during the more intense and forceful moments on the throne. It so happened that I had just attached my blood pressure meter to my arm when the message came that it was either run to the throne-room immediately or be wearing the output where I was.

So I ran there and as I was pushing out digestive byproducts I took my BP. I figured it would be high due to the pressure of straining I was exerting, but no! In fact, it was almost as low as it gets at 117/70. I've been down as low as 107/60 when resting and taking my BP. However, my pulse was up at 110 with that activity, so that means my heart rate was up but not the BP during the brown act. Now I'll have to take my BP when I am blowing tenor and alto to see what happens with those activities.

BTW, I think it apt to mention that what you said about playing free jazz would seem to prove what many critics used to say about it being nothing but loose Sh¡te. :doh:

.
TMI

I have visions I could live without!!

Thank goodness you didn't video it for posterity or posterior 🙂

Jx
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,401
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom