Playing the saxophone Sax playing after heart attack

Sounds like everything is heading in a positive direction and you are doing things right. Remember that moderation in all things is a sound path to follow and you will not go far wrong. Having said that, it's OK to push yourself so long as you do it sensibly!
Onwards and upwards, mon ami. Keep up the good work and look forward to a bright, and tuneful, future.
Regards.
Dave.
 
That is great news! So your temperature was 98.6 F! On a US fever thermometer, that is normal! Keep blowing but take it easy and relax! Hope it cools down over there, it is hot here too! 30 degrees C today.

There was some rain yesterday and today, but temps were still quite high, no lower than 33/35°C. That should be better in the days to come 🙂

So pleased to hear you are on the road to full recovery. 🙂

Jx

Thanks you very much 🙂

@Janosax ; bonjour : man I don't know what to say . " Health , existential , family and spiritual preoccupations are of course all in my mind "....that is an artist's quote man it is obvious you are just that and I know that to have what or who you love taken away is a devastating thing....
I am not a doctor so cannot offer any medical advice only that you follow the obvious by following said doctors and their regime .
In the future ; fresh air ; good diet ; the support of family and friends...add to that the inherent desire to get back ? Your spiritual self will guide you...
We should all count our blessings..
Keep us posted as to your recovery ; be positive
Yeah...Bon Chance man
Best
Ade
Great that you are playing...don't push it Jean...it will be counter productive...little by little !!

Thanks for the kind words. I don’t even realize it, but yes perhaps it’s an artist way of thinking. All I can say is that returning to sax playing is my current obsession, even more than my global health as I feel now so much better, I’m on the right way. I think I just want to feel alive 🙂

Sounds like everything is heading in a positive direction and you are doing things right. Remember that moderation in all things is a sound path to follow and you will not go far wrong. Having said that, it's OK to push yourself so long as you do it sensibly!
Onwards and upwards, mon ami. Keep up the good work and look forward to a bright, and tuneful, future.
Regards.
Dave.

I’m still quite moderate on my efforts, even if I check my capabilities. Thanks for the encouragements 🙂

I played sax again yesterday and today for 35 mn each day. I sweat a little bit as usual with heart pulse between 80 and 95 bpm with a few peaks above that. I recover to 60/70 bpm in less than 2 mn, the medication is here also quite efficient and offer a valid protection.
I’ve bought a connected watch to monitor my heart and it’s quite a good tool for that purpose, it’s even able to take ECG.
I use Legere 2 instead usual 2.25 and that helps too. I don’t push my playing loudness and energy too much, and take smalls 1 or 2 mn breaks here and there.

A fun thing is as I stopped playing sax for some weeks, my 5 brand new D’Addario Select reeds all have green mold now.... I played each of them perhaps one or two times in June, then stored them in Vandoren blue cases with some Listerine (on sponges). That has not worked well. I´ve bought Rejuvinate perhaps 10 years ago and had a similar bad experience. For me, it’s like a sign, I was ready to buy an expensive Reedgeek but I think I will only use Legere Signature like I did for last 3 years. I don’t want that green stuff in my lungs at all!!
I’m health conservative now!! 🙂
 
Last edited:
That has not worked well. I bought Rejuvinate perhaps 10 years ago and had similar bad experience. For me, it’s like a sign, I was ready to buy a Reedgeek but I think I will only use Legere Signature like 3 last years. I don’t want that green stuff in my lungs!!
That's interesting, I always let my reeds dry out in between playing.

Some members keep them in vodka

Jx
 
That's interesting, I always let my reeds dry out in between playing.

Some members keep them in vodka

Jx

This is what I’ve almost always done for years: let them dry in Lavoz opened cases for one day (to avoid mold and deformation) then store them in Vandoren closed cases (to avoid excessive dryness), without using special liquids at all (which seems to give mold in my case, must be my mouth flora I guess).

But this make me think there must always be some invisible bad stuff in reeds cane. There were some studies about that and it seems it can potentially be harmful on lungs. I never thought about that before, but synthetic reeds are at their advantage here.
 
Still playing 30 mn per day 4 or 5 times per week. Can’t really do more at the moment, but I will start medical heart training at the end of this month for three weeks.

One interesting thing as I monitor my heart with my watch, is that I noticed that my heart rate is around 80/100 bpm most of the time during sax playing (~70 at rest), increasing slightly during the 30 mn, but it goes up to 120 bpm while practicing scales. While improvising I use more energy than scales practicing but I stay in the 100 bpm range. This is very interesting and tend to show that very long breathes used with relatively fast scales practice is more demanding for heart. I’ve learned that this is because sax playing uses Valsalva maneuvers and other apnea breath mechanisms. An interesting long term approach for me should be to explore cardiac coherence skills used by freedivers to slow down heart during efforts.

Here is a small traduction of a discussion found on a french music playing medical forum:

You should know that the practice of a wind instrument corresponds to Valsalva maneuvers, and therefore has real hemodynamic consequences inducing effects on arterial pressure and heart rate. The Valsalva maneuver leads to an increase in chest pressure and a reduction in venous return in particular.

From Médecine des arts

Infos on Vasalva maneuver

And just for fun (that’s not so personal this is just data and I think it’s an interesting topic!!) a screenshot of one of my practice session, with higher heart rates at the end in light green during scale practice:

3BA9872E-D30E-454C-8FBD-22570C986538.png
 
Last edited:
Your practice session frequency and duration put a guy like me to shame! Great work!
It's interesting that your post is today as this marks the beginning of my seventh year with my replacement valve. I think we should both keep on blowing. There seems to be a number of health benefits to playing an instrument. I would guess that reed care is very important as things can grow in wood that might not be so healthful. One person commented a while ago that brushing one's teeth prior to practice is a good idea. I've been doing that ever since I read that one.
 
Interesting observations: I would guess none of us saxophonists are performing the valsalva manoeuvre while playing… though maybe when lifting that contrabass sax in its case… the airway is shut at the throat and pressure exerted behind - all coughs are valsalva manoeuvres - but when the air is stopped at the reed, the airway remains open - you’re not “straining at stool” (the classic no-no)
ps I haven’t checked my heart rate while practicing, but I’m pretty sure it shoots up doing those @&?£grrr Klose etudes - are you sure it’s not that scales stress you more than improvising?
 
Last edited:
Interesting observations: I would guess none of us saxophonists are performing the valsalva manoeuvre while playing… though maybe when lifting that contrabass sax in its case… the airway is shut at the throat and pressure exerted behind - all coughs are valsalva manoeuvres - but when the air is stopped at the reed, the airway remains open - you’re not “straining at stool” (the classic no-no)
ps I haven’t checked my heart rate while practicing, but I’m pretty sure it shoots up doing those @&?£grrr Klose etudes - are you sure it’s not that scales stress you more than improvising?

I practice sax scales since I’m 16, and I’m 44. I’m sure it’s not stress, this is breathe duration because I choose to play scales in 12 keys in a way which is physically demanding. For example I play D Ionian in sixteenth notes at 100/120 bpm from low D to palm D ascending/descending continuously 3 or 4 times/cycles without taking my breathe, and do this in 12 keys without making a break during at least 10/15 mn (I was used to sometimes practice scales one full hour with other exercices like arpeggios, chromaticisms...). This is really almost like apnea in my experience. You take inspiration very fast and make expiration slowly. This doesn’t leave lot of moments to breathe normally, this is why sax is for me much more physically demanding that most other activities. About Valsalva, the pressure exerced inside body is very important too, and even if mouth is open I suppose blowing a sax involves similar body/heart physical reactions to that maneuver, even if it’s not exactly the same (there is some resistance even at if at a lesser degree). In fact the first times I had very small pain in chest was after playing sax during two hours sessions, it was one month before my heart attack. Sax is not the culprit, but it’s physically demanding. I always knew it, but didn’t know why exactly. It also depend on sax player of course.
 
About Valsalva, the pressure exerted inside body is very important too, and even if mouth is open I suppose blowing a sax involves similar body/heart physical reactions to that maneuver, even if it’s not exactly the same (there is some resistance even at if at a lesser degree).
Ideally one’s heart specialist would also be a sax player, but in the meantime, here’s a bit more about valsalva - the risk is not where you might think:
1- strain to pick that log - valsalva, blood pressure rises (everything okay so far)
2- let the log go suddenly, big oof of breath out, blood pressure drops suddenly…
3 THEN the body thinks there’s a low blood pressure emergency and compensates, shooting the pressure waaay up, straining the heart…
The sort of ‘steady state’ pressure you describe is different from the on-off of trying to change a car tyre without a jack.
( I recommend offering the 3-part example to your consultant and asking “Rubbish or not?”)
Hope this is of some use… all the best

“Not a doctor”
From the end of what tv programme?
 
Ideally one’s heart specialist would also be a sax player, but in the meantime, here’s a bit more about valsalva - the risk is not where you might think:
1- strain to pick that log - valsalva, blood pressure rises (everything okay so far)
2- let the log go suddenly, big oof of breath out, blood pressure drops suddenly…
3 THEN the body thinks there’s a low blood pressure emergency and compensates, shooting the pressure waaay up, straining the heart…
The sort of ‘steady state’ pressure you describe is different from the on-off of trying to change a car tyre without a jack.
( I recommend offering the 3-part example to your consultant and asking “Rubbish or not?”)
Hope this is of some use… all the best

“Not a doctor”
From the end of what tv programme?

Fortunately, a sax player doesn’t have to be a heart specialist to play his sax 😉

You have to understand that my main concern is to play sax like before my heart attack, as much as possible, but I have some doubts about that because it’s so physical. My goal is to play sax looping alone on stage in front of people for one hour set, that will be demanding. I hope that dream is still possible today. Time and training will tell.

About Valsalva, I don’t really know anything about that. But I’m sure that sax playing involves some apnea skills, after all these years playing I know my body.

In the meantime I’ve found also this:

From science direct

Because of this, a musician with the condition develops dizziness playing his saxophone which requires repeated and prolonged Valsalva maneuvers.

Tuba players and Valsalva

Playing wind instruments requires expiratory efforts. Blowing low notes on a tuba means a low resistance to expiration while playing high notes requires a strenuous expiratory strain. The resulting high intrathoracic pressure may reproduce a Valsalva maneuver.


Another source mentioning saxophone

Valsalva maneuver is the performance of forced expiration against a closed glottis. Many activities of our daily lives such as straining during defecation or playing the saxophone entail performance of Valsalva maneuver. The key event occurring during the maneuver is increasing intrathoracic pressure leading to the reduction of preload to the heart. The reflex's cardiovascular changes during and post the maneuver are because of reduced preload engaging baroreflex and other compensatory reflex mechanisms.

Valsalva and brass playing

This one is interesting about articulation/tonging.

The Valsalva Maneuver is an automated response by the body to certain stimuli. The brass player takes a breath, but before playing can commence there is a momentary hesitation while the tongue moves up and locks in an upper position, causing a build up of air pressure in the mouth. The sensation of pressure triggers a tightening of the stomach muscles and contraction of the diaphragm: a situation where opposing sets of muscles are working against each other.

By curiosity I will ask my heart doctor. Perhaps I will end knowing more that average sax player about that topic🙂
 
Your practice session frequency and duration put a guy like me to shame! Great work!
It's interesting that your post is today as this marks the beginning of my seventh year with my replacement valve. I think we should both keep on blowing. There seems to be a number of health benefits to playing an instrument. I would guess that reed care is very important as things can grow in wood that might not be so healthful. One person commented a while ago that brushing one's teeth prior to practice is a good idea. I've been doing that ever since I read that one.

That’s a sign, you should play more because yes it’s good for health 🙂
 
Thanks to the Chief of Stuff, Pete Thomas.

It looks like everyone on this thread knows more about this than me.

I exercised a fair bit during the two year wait for the triple bypass. I was playing four days after the op, put that vid up here somewhere.

The need for surgery arose when I stopped taking statins after an article in a British broadsheet said they can be harmful/ of limited benefit. That was the stupidest thing I have ever done, (out of a lifetime of absolute asininity).

The only thing that might be useful, which everyone probably already knows: you can't out-train a bad diet. No one over fifty needs the amount of carbs they grew up on.

ps I've managed eleven and a half hours of three and two minute planks since March so...I still haven't beaten the pointless braggadacio problem. As the world record is eleven and a half hours in one go perhaps not much of a boast.
 
About Valsalva, the pressure exerced inside body is very important too, and even if mouth is open I suppose blowing a sax involves similar body/heart physical reactions to that maneuver, even if it’s not exactly the same (there is some resistance even at if at a lesser degree)
Yup

When you blow you increase pressure inside your chest. This reduces the rate of flow of blood through veins into the chest towards the heart... You might see this in the neck veins, for instance

To maintain blood pressure the heart beats faster and therefore works a little harder
 
Last edited:
"I'm not a doctor"...Peter Bergman's famous (infamous?) commercial from 1986 advertising a cough syrup! It's a commonly used joke even today! You can watch the commercial on YouTube.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,402
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom