sax mouthpieces

peter_forshaw

Member
Messages
11
Hi Folks
Just a few thoughts on mouthpieces. I have found with any hobby I have indulged in that there is always someone trying to make money by trying to convince you that you need this gadget or that gizmo to be a success, so now I am wondering about the need for all the many kinds of mouthpieces that seem to be available. I know that, as a beginner I needn't worry myself too much on this matter, but do all you experienced players spend a fortune on trying out different kinds of pieces available, to get that "perfect sound"? I have a copy of Pete`s instruction DVD and he is able to play a variety of different styles and sounds with what appears to be an ordinary plastic piece. Maybe Pete will come back and confirm this. I seem to be plodding on fine with my cheap Yamaha mouthpiece, although I do notice a difference between my leather and metal ligature, and i do confess to buying a metal mouthpiece, and it does give a nice jazzy sound, but does it matter whether your mouthpiece is plastic, ru bber, bakelite, bone, china or whatever? Surely a good player should be able to play any style on any mouthpiece. Look forward to your response.
regards
Pete Forshaw, or as you all seem to have CB type handles call me Hornblower, unless somebody else has claimed that one!
 
I think most professionals and players look for the mouthpiece that lets them get their sound through the best. That being the easiest.

Unfortunately I think a lot of the 'mouthpiece hype' is due to many players purchasing mouthpieces believing that it will give them a 'be bop' tone or a 'lush' tone irrespective of what they sound like at the moment and what their embouchure can handle and needs to develop.

I've bought a few mouthpieces in the past which have been terrible, but at the time I thought they were exactly what I needed. The case in particular is with my Walstein tenor. I loved the feel of the sax and how it played but I had a harsh edge to it which I didn't like. The only mouthpiece I found got rid of this was a metal link 6* which I bought promptly.

It was stiff up the top and stuffy at the bottom and only came to life when blown by a jet engine.

A year later and I was very fed up with it so tried a Yamaha 4C which I got a much better sound out of and easier and better in tune. Which is what made me realize that to reach my highest potential I need a mouthpiece that lets me play, not one that plays for me. So the search began.

I'd always preferred Ebonite pieces and larger mouthpieces so I almost ruled out metal exclusively. I'd found Yanigasawa pieces to suit me really well on alto so tried some on tenor and they came 2nd place but the Vandoren T75 pipped it to the post because of it's ease of blowing.

Looking back now 3.5 years on from when I first picked up a saxophone I wish I'd had the knowledge to do a few things different.

1. Purchase a known/recommended brand saxophone based on the key layout and the instinctive feeling I got from it.

2. Buy a Yamaha 4 or 5c and stick with just that one mouthpiece for a long time.

I'd be very happy to play on a Yamaha 4c right now, I just prefer the refinement of the Vandoren and the more comfortable feel in the mouth, for me.

So in summary, I'd say that a good player should be able to get everything needed in terms of different tones/styles from a suitable 'standard' mouthpiece.
Professional recording is slightly different, you may want to use something a bit more tailored to the specific style, just to focus in on one particular aspect to make the job a bit more easier, but at the sacrifice at something else (but obviously not needed for the recording).
 
Peter Forshaw wrote:
CB type handles

Now there's a blast from the past.
I'm sure that others will agree that mpc's are a very personal choice, my choice is a Runyon Quantum with an Eddie Daniels lig.
I played with a loud rock band before moving on to a rock and roll band. I love to achieve a scream and I find the quantum helps me. They are loud and crass when required, you know, "in ya face", but you can also tease a nice subtone or two as well.
These mpc's are recommended if you play with amplified guitarists, they do tend to cut through the noise.
I hope you enjoy your path from mpc shop to mpc shop. It's all good fun
 
Peter Forshaw wrote:
I have a copy of Pete`s instruction DVD and he is able to play a variety of different styles and sounds with what appears to be an ordinary plastic piece.

I think the mouthpiece on the DVD is a vandoren java A45, quite a standard mouthpiece.

I now use a custom made mouthpiece (RPC) , which is not very different to a Vandoren, if I lost the RPC I'd probably use a Vandoren again.
 
Pete Thomas wrote:
Peter Forshaw wrote:
I have a copy of Pete`s instruction DVD and he is able to play a variety of different styles and sounds with what appears to be an ordinary plastic piece.

I think the mouthpiece on the DVD is a vandoren java A45, quite a standard mouthpiece.

I now use a custom made mouthpiece (RPC) , which is not very different to a Vandoren, if I lost the RPC I'd probably use a Vandoren again.

Ok thanks Pete for info
 
Thanks Linky, Taz, and Pete for the info, very informative. I'll give it a few more months and see if the Yamaha 5C still ok. Being a poor old pensioner my budget is a little tight, and by the time I have the perfect combination, i'll probably be to old to play anyway!
I take 'old git' as my inspiration .
Seems to be a shortage of teachers in Dorset, but when I find one maybe he/she will put me straight.
 
Peter Forshaw wrote:
but does it matter whether your mouthpiece is plastic, ru bber, bakelite, bone, china or whatever? Surely a good player should be able to play any style on any mouthpiece.

You have sort of answered your own question.
With in reason, that does sum it up.

The issue is, how many do you try before you find the one(s) thats right for you.
First of all this means you have to recognise that it has all the character, feel and flexability to name but a few that will make a mouthpiece a winner for you.
I went through at least these phases,
Fashion,
elegance,
volume,
Inherent sound traits associated with certain genres,
I went round and round...possibly I'm not done yet, I don't know (because I'm no master) but I hope so.

NOW
My mouthpieces per horn give me more 'saxlicker' than brightness, darkness, warmth or edge and I do the rest.
Incidently I hate the look of my tenor set up!! RPC with a standard BG lig...yuck :x
But I wouldn't trade it for anything else I've tried.
 
I think Saxlicker has hit on an important point there - you can go round and round trying to find 'the one' mouthpiece, and what you're looking for is the one piece that will allow you to come through with the most ease and comfort of playing, the one that will get you closest to the sound that you hear in your head.

Of course, it could be anything from the cheapest on up, but you have to try so blummen many 😉 and you have to try and not be swayed too much by what other people use, because a) they are using what works for them and it may not suit you or b) they're also still looking for 'the one' :S and you don't have to feel at all ashamed about your mpc, whatever it is, if you like it. Same goes for reed choice.
 
Trust the old one's to complain. You need ambition Peter, go out and mug a few teenagers, then you will be able to buy the hand made Guardala for a mere fifteen hundred dollars on SOTW.
One thing is guaranteed, the novelty will wear off.
 
Peter: just my tuppenceworth. Some good ideas here already.

As the mouthpiece is the 'voice' of the horn, the vocal chords if you will, it is important that you have one that fits your own 'body image' and more importantly: the type of music and situations you wish to play in. However, there is no such thing as the "perfect" mouthpiece as we all want and require different things of the instrument.

I've tried a whole wheelbarrow load over the years, and have often made some exciting discoveries just by experiementing. Some, that I'd hoped would be the 'answer' turned out to be very dissapointing, and some which I'd have otherwise overlooked became 'old freinds'. But the importance of having the 'right one FOR YOU' cannot be stressed enough. Most of the great players settled on a piece and stuck with it, often as it was their 'safety zone' but also because they knew it would do what they needed it to do. Charlie Parker might have cashed in a few horns at the pawnbrokers, but he never let his mouthpiece go! he felt that it was all he needed.

The way that I started, was to research the 'set-up' of various players I liked the sound of, and see what they used. This then became a question I'd ask players at gigs. Just so I could build a mental 'sound map' of how these different things performed. But the most important difference I've found, is that many are made with emphasis on certain qualities. I.E. they will be designed to sound 'dark' or 'full bodied' but sacrifice the ability to play very high notes with any great ease or quality. Others are made specifically to play extreme high notes, but sometimes can't handle the deeper ones very well. Many modern mouthpieces are just built for volume, to cut through an amplified band for example. This is why you need to decide what sort of music you want to create on the saxophone, before choosing a mouthpiece. It's a great idea to find a shop where you can have a 'play' with a few - old and new - just to get a feel of what works. Though, don't ask the price first! just look for the sound.

If you have been satisfied by the one you have (or has been suggested some other humble alternative) then just work with that. Mouthpiece manufacturers KNOW that us sax players have a secret insecurity about mouthpieces, and boy, do they play on it! - as the song used to say: "Don't believe the hype" (least not til you've borrowed or tried one!)
 
Thanks for all the advice guys.
I think i'll stick with the Yammy I've go for now, only been playing for about eight months, and if the notes don't sound better, and low notes on the tenor don't come any easier after a few more months, then perhaps i'll try other mpc's. I can see the advantage of being able to try various mpc's in a shop, could save an awful lot of expense.

Seems mpcs are the big everlasting subject with sax blowing.
I am also a radio amateur, and with that hobby the ongoing subject is always aerials, or antennas. Lots of others saying they get their signal out better and further with such and such an array of wires. So you build or buy that system and find it doesnt work for you, it depends on your situation, geographical, height surroundings etc. in that hobby KISS approach always seems to be best (and cheaper). See the comparisons?

Next time i'm on ebay and I see a mpc going cheap, I might take a gamble and bid. At least I can put it back on if it don't work!
 
Peter,
That Yamaha is the G5RV of mouthpieces. Never heard a bad word against one but finding a better one is like trying to set up a 360 degree array of Beverages whilst living in a Council High Rise.
 
I *think* I have got over the mouthpiece GAS, having realised that I sound very little different (and not necessarily 'better') on my very expensive JJDV and my relatively inexpensive Jumbo Java.

I like to think that, as I improve as a player, I'll 'get more' from the JJDV, but I do realise there just ain't no substitoot for practice!
 
old git wrote:
Peter,
That Yamaha is the G5RV of mouthpieces. Never heard a bad word against one but finding a better one is like trying to set up a 360 degree array of Beverages whilst living in a Council High Rise.

why do i feel my qrp rig has just got me accross the pond?
someone on my frequency at last!
 
Peter, I've bought a few mouthpieces on ebay, it's quite a good way to experiment on the cheap, and I've always got something from those cheapies at the time. On the other hand, I still haven't got over the need to move on, although I am now down to 2 or maybe 3 favourites :S
 
Radio Hams and saxophones, what a mixture...

73's de Phil VK4IIO, was G4IIO, now in Brisbane and enjoying playing the tenor sax in warmer weather, even in winter!
 
old git wrote:
Peter,
QRP? Hmm.

PW Territory? Hmm.

You're not the Lewis Carrol of Dobbsie are you? >:)

Not been on air for years, now it's all sax. The neighbours not moaning about high visual impact, but high audio impact now. Maybe i'll go back to painting!
 
PhilHowe wrote:
Radio Hams and saxophones, what a mixture...

73's de Phil VK4IIO, was G4IIO, now in Brisbane and enjoying playing the tenor sax in warmer weather, even in winter!
Hi Phil
In VK land, envy you the weather. Would arrange a sched but don't think me QRP would make it, although it has been known!
Pete T might be getting worried this turning into a ham site!
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,507
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom