Beginner Saxes Sax Alto suggestions 2022

Prices all over the place -it clearly pays to shop around!:



£230 price difference between these two shops for an identical model.
 
Prices all over the place -it clearly pays to shop around!:



£230 price difference between these two shops for an identical model.
Are they the same?
The Music Shop one has 'Classic' on the bell and the sax.co.uk one doesn't appear to have allowing for my eyesight.
Then sax.co.uk does include a free DVD.
 
Are they the same?
The Music Shop one has 'Classic' on the bell and the sax.co.uk one doesn't appear to have allowing for my eyesight.
Then sax.co.uk does include a free DVD.

Music Room appear to be using an image of the older model of Classic, however the text description clearly states Classic II
 
30 years ago at school I had Weltklang Soloist stencil Alto that was horrible and had very bad ergonomics for me. So I have some experience of what I don't like.
For nearly 55 yeras ago I started to play on a used Conn Shooting Star alto. Three yeas later a bought an used Amati tenor as well. The joy and freedom to play the saxophone ( Rock & Roll Saxophone) was stronger than bad ergonomics. Of course, if a todays beginner saxes were available back then I would probably play one of the listed brands. Sometimes I think we are exaggerating the importance of the saxes.
 
For nearly 55 yeras ago I started to play on a used Conn Shooting Star alto. Three yeas later a bought an used Amati tenor as well. The joy and freedom to play the saxophone ( Rock & Roll Saxophone) was stronger than bad ergonomics. Of course, if a todays beginner saxes were available back then I would probably play one of the listed brands. Sometimes I think we are exaggerating the importance of the saxes.
I think you've got a point. My first sax was a Weltklang, provided by the school I attended. A few months later, my parents very generously bought me a Buescher, one of the 1970s ones. Objectively, neither are very good, compared to a decent modern sax. Now I play a Yanagisawa T992, which I like very much, and I much prefer to the Weltklang or Buescher (I still have the Buescher). However, if the only sax I could have was the Weltklang or the Buescher, it would still be far, far better than no sax at all. I'd still play, and I'd still enjoy playing.
 
I think you've got a point. My first sax was a Weltklang, provided by the school I attended. A few months later, my parents very generously bought me a Buescher, one of the 1970s ones. Objectively, neither are very good, compared to a decent modern sax. Now I play a Yanagisawa T992, which I like very much, and I much prefer to the Weltklang or Buescher (I still have the Buescher). However, if the only sax I could have was the Weltklang or the Buescher, it would still be far, far better than no sax at all. I'd still play, and I'd still enjoy playing.
On the other hand, my first alto was a 1970’s Buescher, and it almost put me off playing alto completely. It was only when I tried a Yamaha that I discovered that playing alto could actually be fun.
 
On the other hand, my first alto was a 1970’s Buescher, and it almost put me off playing alto completely. It was only when I tried a Yamaha that I discovered that playing alto could actually be fun.
I guess for me, even the Weltklang was such a relief compared to what I'd been used to - playing Mozart on the misery stick - that even that shonky old second hand sax was a joy to play. It also helped that, as a pretty accomplished clarinet player by the time I first picked up a sax, I was able to play it more or less immediately.
 
I agree with both the above points and if all saxophones were Weltklangs, I'd still be playing one.

As a child I played the Weltklang because it was all I had and I wouldn't have dreamed of asking for anything else as it was the most expensive thing I'd ever owned even though it was scruffy, a bit battered and well used. I used to get pain in my hands because of the key placement -right hand pinky keys C D# particularly. And it constantly needed a few bodges to keep it working properly.

My point is that now I'm an adult in charge of my own life and in a much better position financially than my parents ever were. I have far more choice available and the freedom to indulge myself as I please.

The very cheap £200 Far Eastern saxophones available online these days may appeal to someone starting out, but may not be the bargain they seem as these may or may not be serviceable instruments. But I don't think anyone would recommend as they are an unknown quantity.

OP has a very specific request to recommend a black and gold alto for £400 which narrows things considerably.
 
I agree with both the above points and if all saxophones were Weltklangs, I'd still be playing one.

As a child I played the Weltklang because it was all I had and I wouldn't have dreamed of asking for anything else as it was the most expensive thing I'd ever owned even though it was scruffy, a bit battered and well used. I used to get pain in my hands because of the key placement -right hand pinky keys C D# particularly. And it constantly needed a few bodges to keep it working properly.

My point is that now I'm an adult in charge of my own life and in a much better position financially than my parents ever were. I have far more choice available and the freedom to indulge myself as I please.

The very cheap £200 Far Eastern saxophones available online these days may appeal to someone starting out, but may not be the bargain they seem as these may or may not be serviceable instruments. But I don't think anyone would recommend as they are an unknown quantity.

OP has a very specific request to recommend a black and gold alto for £400 which narrows things considerably.
Nearest ive seen is a tj classic black and gold at hanson...£709 tho best deal i think..would come out serviced...could maybe spread the extra..at least its a known horn...
 
Here is the "Rainbow Series" from UMI. I guess it was a way to earn more money on the models that was going to be replaced. You just do some cosmetic changes in the end of the life cycle of a product. Like building cars.
rsett.JPG
rstva.JPG
 
Did you get your sax...
Hello eb and everyone,

I wanted to say a big thanks for your guidance. Every piece of advice from each of you was well well noted, thank you.

Yesterday, I went to sax.co.uk to try out some different brands based on your suggestions and I ended up investing on a Yamaha YAS 280. The difference between Yamaha and TJ/Sakkusu was very clear while playing them.

Yes, it is not black/gold as I wished for, but I had to take a decision on quality, easy-to-play and warranty. And the sound is super beautiful.

I will be now looking for a sax alto teacher around my area (W6 London). If you also have any suggestion please let me know. I must now learn how to play Andrea Bocelli - Can't Help Falling In Love within 7 days and surprise my wife!!!

Wish me luck and thank you again. As soon as I have some extra $$$ again I will donate to cafe, pls bear with me as this sax was over my budget.

All the best
Marcelo
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,135
Latest member
Recursive
Back
Top Bottom