Beginner Saxes Sax Alto suggestions 2022

Sax.co.uk will also do you a payment plan, end up costing more but opens up your options????

If you buy second hand, add a few £ for a service to your budget. And a mouthpiece, reeds, strap, cleaning kit.... I wish I'd taken up the harmonica now!

Yes, payment plan could help. How much does it usually cost for a service i.e. review the sax, change one thing or another?
 
The black on my Hanson is showing some 'speckles' of wear in places after ten years.
It's black and silver which is far cooler than black and gold and you get all the fun of polishing the silver which enables you to learn maintenance as the springs catch the cloth and twang off and an occasional bit of cork appears on the work surface.
Kevgermany (former mod here at CS) told me that Keilwerth black/gold saxes were electroplated with black nickel. I guess it's a little bit more durable?? I have owned some black laquered saxes. Jupiter was ok but LA Sax was not good. I was an early one so maybe they became better later.?
 
Hi Jonf, many thanks for the welcoming wishes and for the feedback. Great to hear you had experience with these saxes. I'll look more for Yamaha, but I couldn't find any black/gold which is critical for me (don't ask me why.. But kind of a dream). For the moment, the Thomann seems to be the best option so far even if importing to the UK.
As long as you understand that the parameter of a black colored sax with gold keys is influencing what is available to you in your price range....in a negative way.

IOW, you are dismissing better, reputed (used) horns which will perform better and be more reliable, for the sake of owning a black (budget priced) sax. If you are comfortable with that decision, that's fine, then it's likely you will know what to expect down the road without any disappointments...

In regards to used, as I said, get seller to confirm it is in play shape or your money back; if they will not, then set aside 150quid or so to have the horn serviced once received, and still buy it only with a return policy should any potentially needed servicing cost more than around that.
 
Kevgermany (former mod here at CS) told me that Keilwerth black/gold saxes were electroplated with black nickel. I guess it's a little bit more durable?? I have owned some black laquered saxes. Jupiter was ok but LA Sax was not good. I was an early one so maybe they became better later.?
Less so than the company is the finish method.

Black nickel is excellent, as it's a plating. It's also not found on budget saxes, I don't think.

Black lacquer...is lacquer. So it wears like lacquer, so the horn is eventually gonna look bad...the 'eventually' period...dependent upon how good the factory lacq job really is.
 
Black lacquer...is lacquer. So it wears like lacquer, so the horn is eventually gonna look bad...the 'eventually' period...dependent upon how good the factory lacq job really is.
These days, on cheaper saxes, it's probably not even lacquer, in the cellulose sense. It'll be polyurethane, which can be fairly durable if it's been properly applied to a totally grease free metal. If not, it can peel off in large flakes, which looks even worse than lacquer breakdown. I've seen this on a red lacquered sax - it looked awful.
 
A used Trevor James might fit the bill a lot of their instruments come in the black and gold @reckor is looking for and they do tend to be nickel plated rather than painted or lacquered

Example on Gumtree - I have no connection with the seller

 
A used Trevor James might fit the bill a lot of their instruments come in the black and gold @reckor is looking for and they do tend to be nickel plated rather than painted or lacquered

Example on Gumtree - I have no connection with the seller

It seems Trevor James is a good brand. Thanks for this one, the person also says Fully Serviced which is good.

The top 11 best saxophone brands are: (found on the internet)

  1. Henri Selmer Paris
  2. Yanagisawa
  3. Keilwerth
  4. Yamaha
  5. Jupiter
  6. P. Mauriat
  7. Borgani
  8. Trevor James
  9. Eastman
  10. Antigua Winds
  11. Cannonball Saxophones
 
I asked the same for another member, but how much does it usually cost for a service i.e. review the sax, change one thing or another?
I go to dawkes in Maidenhead the do a check for £30 and for that they will do what tweeking they can in 30 mins..anything serious they will give you a price and an appointment..they check for leaks and rebed / replace a couple of pads etc..I am not sure about sax.co.uk but going by Dawkes a reasonable guess would be £60 an hour..
 
I go to dawkes in Maidenhead the do a check for £30 and for that they will do what tweeking they can in 30 mins..anything serious they will give you a price and an appointment..they check for leaks and rebed / replace a couple of pads etc..I am not sure about sax.co.uk but going by Dawkes a reasonable guess would be £60 an hour..
Thank you eb, super helpful
 
Think that overhauled yas 25 looked a good bet but good luck with whatever you choose...dont forget the confussius saying sax is not about how it looks but how it feels that creates the sound...;-)..enjoy your journey more difficult choices to come...
 
Yes, payment plan could help. How much does it usually cost for a service i.e. review the sax, change one thing or another?
If you buy from Sax.co.uk get a new one (I like the Trevor James Classic II), they will do a full check and reset after a year I think. As for servicing, it really depends, I have a chap who will do a strip, clean, corks, felts, springs and action set-up for £65, he'll do pads for extra but not much, but he does it for fun more than a business, I've heard people pay upwards over £300 for a basic service (not including replacement parts).

There is always talk around the TJ sax's, I'm no expert and I don't make a living playing but, I have found my Classic II to be a great sax from beginner onwards. Yes, if money would allow I'd go Yamaha as an upgrade but if you're just starting out or getting back after many years, in my opinion, a new TJ will be worth the bit extra than chancing your arm on a second hand model. Only my opinion though
 
I've only ever played a handful of different saxophones. Both my tenor and alto are Trevor James SR models -which is an advanced student model. Id like to try some others in the future just to see, but to be honest, I don't think I could ever expect to be a good enough player for them to hold me back.

I got back in to playing again at the start of lockdown so wasn't able to go to go and try any. I bought the alto ex demo online from a shop in December 2020.

30 years ago at school I had Weltklang Soloist stencil Alto that was horrible and had very bad ergonomics for me. So I have some experience of what I don't like.

I bought the tenor second hand more recently. It had not been played much but hadn't been looked after. I spent a good day and a half cleaning it as best I could before taking it to a technician for some work:

Striped, cleaned & lubricated, a bent key straightened, 1 pad replaced, some felts and corks and set up for £82. It now plays very nicely.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,135
Latest member
Recursive
Back
Top Bottom