Beginner Saxes Sax Alto suggestions 2022

I would like to have a beautiful sound, but understand the sax alone won't do the magic =)
Quite. But the sax in poor working order can undermine a beginner without them even realising it with leaks etc. I reckon that's a big part of why brands like Yamaha can charge a premium and part of the tradeoff with bargain brands (as well as longevity); and why 2nd from a shop with servicing, as suggested above, is potentially, the best bet if you're not experienced etc.
 
Last edited:
Hello everyone,

I used to play Juniper a long (long) time ago and I wanted to play sax alto again almost from scratch I would say... but happy I'm taking this decision now.

Either way, I live in London and I'm looking for a new sax for beginners which is not expensive (less than 400 GBP if possible).

While using this forum I found many options as expected. I'd like to have a black/gold sax.

I saw the following:
- Sakkusu (sax.co.ouk)
- Thomann TAS 180
- Alto Saxophone by Gear4music
- Adolphe (not black though).

I would like a balanced sax as I'm not an expert to be honest.

Thank you much in advance for any suggestion.

All the best
I'd look for a Yamaha YAS-23. I owned one for 10 years at the same time I owned a Yamaha 875 Custom alto. While not up to the 875 Custom, in my humble opinion, it was a fine horn.
 
I'd look for a Yamaha YAS-23. I owned one for 10 years at the same time I owned a Yamaha 875 Custom alto. While not up to the 875 Custom, in my humble opinion, it was a fine horn.
This looks a good deal completely overhauled with a good mouthpiece and sling


Its not black and gold but the op my be better looking at quality over asthetics..
But i suppose the hearrt wants what the heart wants..
 
Wow, that's a beautiful one and at the level I can afford. Never heard of such brand, but I'm sure you wouldn't recommend if it's not good. If I buy this one where should I take it for a good repair service in London, pls?
 
This looks a good deal completely overhauled with a good mouthpiece and sling


Its not black and gold but the op my be better looking at quality over asthetics..
But i suppose the hearrt wants what the heart wants..
It does sound like a good deal indeed. Just the colour, but I may need to reconsider considering the opinions in this forum. I cannot swim against the current
 
Quite. But the sax in poor working order can undermine a beginner without them even realising it with leaks etc. I reckon that's a big part of why brands like Yamaha can charge a premium and part of the tradeoff with bargain brands (as well as longevity); and why 2nd from a shop with servicing, as suggested above, is potentially, the best bet if you're not expected etc.
Yes, learning from the best here. And start to changing my mindset
 
Think you will get frustrated not knowing if its you or the sax...if your going to enjoy the journey and can stretch to more it might serve you better and if you dont enjoy it ressle will be easier..
Thank you eb. Fair points which I agree with.
 
Thank you eb. Fair points which I agree with.
Only cheaper saxes seem black and gold..or the z which is a fantastic sax..i know we want what we want but at least if you start with a sax like the yam 25 you could promise yourself a z when youve been commited or reached a certain point..great for motivation and you have a chunk of money back re resale value...
 
If you absolutely must have black and gold at a low price, then you will have to get a cheap saxophone made in mainland China. These saxophones can be excellent, but the problem is that the manufacturers save money on quality control, so you can't be sure about the one you end up with. The way round this is to get one from a seller who checks the saxophone thoroughly. I'm not sure who is best for this.

But the Yamaha 25 that someone has pointed to on eBay above will be a much better instrument, even if it needs a bit of tweaking to get it into top shape. You should expect to take any instrument you buy to a repair person for a checkover and adjustment. Saxophones are surprisingly fragile.
 
Sax.co.uk will also do you a payment plan, end up costing more but opens up your options????

If you buy second hand, add a few £ for a service to your budget. And a mouthpiece, reeds, strap, cleaning kit.... I wish I'd taken up the harmonica now!
 
Hi Jonf, many thanks for the welcoming wishes and for the feedback. Great to hear you had experience with these saxes. I'll look more for Yamaha, but I couldn't find any black/gold which is critical for me (don't ask me why.. But kind of a dream). For the moment, the Thomann seems to be the best option so far even if importing to the UK.
If it absolutely has to be black, I'd go for the Sakkusu, as sax.co.uk have a London shop where you could take it for after sales service. Otherwise I would go for Thomann. Personally, I'd sacrifice aesthetic preferences for playing quality and get a Yamaha, but it's you who's buying, it's your money.

Out of interest, where in London are you based?
 
A problem with some (black) laquered saxes is that the laquer is not durable. You sometimes find black Yam, Yani, Jupiter .... that are delaquered. I have a black and gold "The NewKing" (Keilwerth) from 1968. Durable finish. Still in good shape and I use it quite often.
tnkgravyr2.jpg
 
Not all black saxophones are cheapies. Selmer do a black alto for £6.3k.
I went through a coloured phase. They seem like a good idea till you get one. I sold on the copper tenor and was very disappointed with the Artemis.
The black Selmers do look nice though.
 
A problem with some (black) laquered saxes is that the laquer is not durable. You sometimes find black Yam, Yani, Jupiter .... that are delaquered. I have a black and gold "The NewKing" (Keilwerth) from 1968. Durable finish. Still in good shape and I use it quite often.
View attachment 21017
The black on my Hanson is showing some 'speckles' of wear in places after ten years.
It's black and silver which is far cooler than black and gold and you get all the fun of polishing the silver which enables you to learn maintenance as the springs catch the cloth and twang off and an occasional bit of cork appears on the work surface.
 
If it absolutely has to be black, I'd go for the Sakkusu, as sax.co.uk have a London shop where you could take it for after sales service. Otherwise I would go for Thomann. Personally, I'd sacrifice aesthetic preferences for playing quality and get a Yamaha, but it's you who's buying, it's your money.

Out of interest, where in London are you based?
I understood your point, thank you. Near Ravenscourt park, why?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom