Classical Remco Jak - Bach

He has the tone I have always tried to work towards on soprano - pure, but without edge, and warm. To my ear there is something almost flute like about the sound, not at all oboe-ish. I have just listened to the clip with decent headphones, and he is in a class of his own.
 
I am going to be the fly in the ointment. Remco’s tone is fantastic. But having listened a lot to baroque performances by for example Brüggen, Herreweghe, Kuijken, Christie etc. I really cringe when I hear Remco’s take on Bach. He seems to throw away the last 50 years of evolution in baroque music performance.
 
Well, as Vic Reeves used to say - "now let's hear how that should have sounded..." - upload something to prove your point!

Personally I would give my right arm to play like Remco. But then that would only leave me with G to C#, so it might be a bit self defeating...
 
Having thought about this a little more deeply (maybe 5%) I wonder whether classical saxophonists' way of playing styles like baroque may be coloured by their playing so much french romantic music from the early 2oth century - Debussy, Satie, Faure etc. Their music is very appealing to sax players because of the strong single line melodies, but it might make them approach baroque music in a more emotional/romantic way...? Is that what you mean? Interesting to think about.
 
Yes, this could well be the case. I already thought Alfred Brendel's version of the Busoni transcription was an extremely romantic take:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqGQVAvtmHw


Have to say that I enjoy listening to Brendel, a lot.

As for a more modern (?) approach, here's a Koopman version on organ. Still trying to find a wind instrument performance of Nun komm' der Heiden Heiland to illustrate my point.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xhpnkqsfmTs


(Funny quote: the Dutch recorder player Walter van Hauwe said, "Bach didn't write for didgeridoo". I also feel the flow of Bach's music is more served by good phrasing and a well-placed breath, than by circular breathing. )
 
The original baritone saxophonist from the Amstel Quartet, Ties Mellema, once commented that most classical music written specifically for saxophone was written by B list composers, and even the occasional A list composers saved their best ideas for more established instruments. So saxophone quartets either end up re-arranging music originally intended for other instruments, or seeking original compositions. If you play something originally intended for strings, or organ, the unique sound of a saxophone ensemble will usually dictate a change in the style or feel of the music played, which is either a strength or weakness, depending on your view. Ties Mellema was of the view that playing saxophone professionally in the classical world was therefore a mixed blessing, and you had to take the criticism as well as the praise if you were going to play the music as the nature of the saxophone dictated.

I have to say that I find most saxophone quartets have a rather unsubtle, shrill, brassy sound, whereas the Amstel Quartet are in a class apart, having a more restrained, elegant tone and wonderful empathy with each other.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,449
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom