Playing the saxophone Reed Strength - am I a bit of a weed?

Wow - thanks for all the responses, all very helpful!

Sound advice. I think because I play in a vacuum (not literally, that would be really tough... I just mean I dont play in any kind of band) I dont get any feedback other than my own and I am uber-critical.

If criticism isn’t credible, it’s best to ignore it - that includes self-criticism if is isn’t well founded.

Yes, I'm talking about embouchure but air support is critical too- good point.

Yes, I dont want to fixate on reed strength, or get competitive about it! And theres nothing to say my MP is ideal although I seem to get on with it OK. Up until 2 yrs back I played tenor (occasionally, badly, and with no focus at all) and used a Lawton 7* which I loved. I tried a Lawton with the alto and hated the sound - couldn't get on with it at all - so reverted to the Select Jazz. I have a Claude Lakey 5* which came with the sax which is quite edgy but I haven't used it. I'm trying to avoid changing too many things!

I am seeing a trend here. Are you playing more regularly now or still flailing about? I applaud that you are aware of a need to avoid changing too many things. Are you able to use only one mouthpiece on one horn until you have sorted out your reeds, embouchure, and air stream?

Spot-on. I dont want to spend forever fiddling around with my set-up and not focus on the musical output.

Amen and +1.

Thanks again to all - lots to think about, mostly along the lines of "just get on with it man" which is fair enough. I was kind of curious to know if my inability to blow a harder reed might point to some other issue, but theres a lot of variables and ideally I would spend more time practising.
There you have it - stop critiquing and listen to your playing. If you are getting a good tone, go with it, and stop undermining your efforts with unfounded self-criticism and doubt. Celebrate your accomplishments.

Give a listen to John Prine’s “Dear Abby”. It was written for you.

View: https://youtu.be/EF8S5XB-eYs
 
His guardala was 113 tip opening and he went to a #2 reed after a operation on his throat as he had a tear in it’s wall , which was aggravated by blowing to hard ,
He also said he preferred the #2 as he could control his sound easier and didn’t have to push so hard
But as we all know at the end of the day it’s a personnel choice what works for you
I:e mouthpiece reed size even saxophone
 
Yes, he attributed much of this to the early days and playing in the band Dreams.

The book about him that came out about a year (or is it two??) ago is quite a read.

Speaking of Guardala, it’s amazing that none of the mouthpieces that came out (supposedly being what he played on) were anything like his mouthpiece.

Again, I think that the initial move to the Guardala was fuelled by needing an easier blowing setup.

His extensive EWI use was because he thought that his throat problem would cause him to give up sax playing. I think this was quite early on in the ‘80’s - incredible what would have been missed had that been the case.
 
If criticism isn’t credible, it’s best to ignore it - that includes self-criticism if is isn’t well founded.



I am seeing a trend here. Are you playing more regularly now or still flailing about? I applaud that you are aware of a need to avoid changing too many things. Are you able to use only one mouthpiece on one horn until you have sorted out your reeds, embouchure, and air stream?



Amen and +1.


There you have it - stop critiquing and listen to your playing. If you are getting a good tone, go with it, and stop undermining your efforts with unfounded self-criticism and doubt. Celebrate your accomplishments.

Give a listen to John Prine’s “Dear Abby”. It was written for you.

View: https://youtu.be/EF8S5XB-eYs
Yes. Self-criticism can be the most cruel and damaging if not tempered properly by reality.

For some, it propels them to greatness but it can be really bad if you don’t recognise when your little Elf on your shoulder is riding you too hard. It’s as bad as having a particularly weak self-critique, which can also keep you sat in the station rather than getting on the train and moving on.

As people say, if you’re pretty happy with what you hear then there is no need to overthink it (all the time). Always be guided by the sound.
 
Plas Johnson plays Rico #2 or plasticover #2,5 baritone reeds on a Berg Larsen 130/0 tenor mouthpiece.

Lenny Pickett plays Vandoren blue box #3 bass clarinet reeds on a Berg Larsen 130/0 tenor mouthpiece.

Don't be afraid to test new things. Trust your own ears and do your own things. From 1985 to 1998 I didn't had anyone, except my wife and children, to listen to me. I was playing/honking on my own. Good or bad? They didn't like to have me in a horn section. Just too much of everything. But on the other side I did pretty well as the only blues and rock sax player on a hobby level .... . I played the sax to please myself and having a good time. If others enjoyed it as well, was just an extra bonus.
 
After a severe personal critique and wearing metaphorical sack cloth and ashes, I find it uplifting to go see a local band. It resets my ear about the demands on myself from perfection to acceptable.
This is the difficulty isn’t - where does the yardstick measurement start and where do we want to be placed upon it.
 
If all teachers use the same pedagogy and methods and we all have the same idea how a sax should sound .... what a boring sax world. Same type of mouthpiece, soft reeds, Yamaha sax, tuner on the sax .... we are maybe there soon?
 
His guardala was 113 tip opening and he went to a #2 reed after a operation on his throat as he had a tear in it’s wall , which was aggravated by blowing to hard ,
He also said he preferred the #2 as he could control his sound easier and didn’t have to push so hard
But as we all know at the end of the day it’s a personnel choice what works for you
I:e mouthpiece reed size even saxophone

Yep.

It makes one wonder why there are any reeds other than #2 in the world.

On the other hand, Ernie Watts plays a 1 1/2 Plasticover. Grover played on a #5.

Mouthpiece maker Ron Coelho designed around a 2 1/2…(regardless of tip size, as I recall)

Yes, there are weeds to be had, but let it be driven by personal experience. If your sound is good, don’t mess with changing reed strength just because someone else does. They may be playing a mouthpiece with a different tip opening, different chamber, etc., and have a different embouchure, as well as different expectations of resistance and response.

If you don’t yet have an idea of a good sound, spend some time and effort listening to others to refine your ideas of what sound you aspire to. Always listen.
 
I play rather hard reeds because I have a tight and firm grip around my mouthpiece. I'm not relaxed when I play but I'm not biting. A soft reed is closing the the airstream for me. And without airstream no tone. If I look at a used and undamaged reed my reeds are slightly banana shaped even if I keep them in a holder. A hard reed stay in shape longer for me. I know, I should learn to play relaxed and nice. To play pretty was/is not my thing.
 
Dave Guardala worked with Brecker to produce an easier blowing mouthpiece than his Link - the resistance causing pain to his herniated larynx which would cause his neck to inflate when he blew. He had surgery but it didn’t work. It was caused by simply blowing too hard on gigs to be heard over a loud back line.
This was the only reason he changed from the Link.
Apparently Guardala first added a wedge - presumably a baffle - to his Link, allowing him to back off a bit, but the neck problem recurred.
As mentioned before, he played on Dukoff’s before Guardala designed the mouthpiece for him.
The clip on YouTube with Brecker on his own on a studio session shows just how hard he blew (though not always of course). I was shocked the first time I saw it.

View: https://youtu.be/9WFZD9mgVvw?feature=shared
 
Remember how people have often said that a high baffle was a crutch? As recounted here, the high baffle in Brecker’s Guardala was literally an assistive medical device.

The point remains that each person needs to find what works for them. Prescribing a #2 reed for everyone is musical malpractice.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom