Dr G
Senior Member
- Messages
- 2,485
- Location
- Northern California
Wow - thanks for all the responses, all very helpful!
Sound advice. I think because I play in a vacuum (not literally, that would be really tough... I just mean I dont play in any kind of band) I dont get any feedback other than my own and I am uber-critical.
If criticism isn’t credible, it’s best to ignore it - that includes self-criticism if is isn’t well founded.
Yes, I'm talking about embouchure but air support is critical too- good point.
Yes, I dont want to fixate on reed strength, or get competitive about it! And theres nothing to say my MP is ideal although I seem to get on with it OK. Up until 2 yrs back I played tenor (occasionally, badly, and with no focus at all) and used a Lawton 7* which I loved. I tried a Lawton with the alto and hated the sound - couldn't get on with it at all - so reverted to the Select Jazz. I have a Claude Lakey 5* which came with the sax which is quite edgy but I haven't used it. I'm trying to avoid changing too many things!
I am seeing a trend here. Are you playing more regularly now or still flailing about? I applaud that you are aware of a need to avoid changing too many things. Are you able to use only one mouthpiece on one horn until you have sorted out your reeds, embouchure, and air stream?
Spot-on. I dont want to spend forever fiddling around with my set-up and not focus on the musical output.
Amen and +1.
There you have it - stop critiquing and listen to your playing. If you are getting a good tone, go with it, and stop undermining your efforts with unfounded self-criticism and doubt. Celebrate your accomplishments.Thanks again to all - lots to think about, mostly along the lines of "just get on with it man" which is fair enough. I was kind of curious to know if my inability to blow a harder reed might point to some other issue, but theres a lot of variables and ideally I would spend more time practising.
Give a listen to John Prine’s “Dear Abby”. It was written for you.
