Saxophone beginners Practicing one or more songs at a time?

Provided it's purposeful playing when practicing then I don't see it causing any harm.

My teacher said to me "practice makes permanent", as others have said it's no good playing something over, and over if it's not right. Once you've gotten a rhythm, or phrase stuck into your head or memory, it's difficult to break away from it to what should be right.

In my opinion this is where tutors come in, as they can identify what needs working. It's easy when playing solo to convince yourself it's right, or settle for something. A tutor will keep pushing for improvements.

Another reason to play a few different pieces is the keep the family and neighbours sane :rofl:
 
Once you've gotten a rhythm, or phrase stuck into your head or memory, it's difficult to break away from it to what should be right.

A tutor will keep pushing for improvements.
Say that again.
With my flute teacher, we - more or less - learn a new tune every two weeks.
I hold myself to learn meaning; by memory, in time etc. Then i upload a recording and we review ... And he complains and corrects and then, might suggest a better recording for next lesson...
... But, by then, I've probably over learned the piece and it's hard to fix things...
Sometimes I have to ask we put it on a backlog list so I'm I can forget it a bit.
 
. But, by then, I've probably over learned the piece and it's hard to fix things...
Development of an etcher-sketch (kids drawing toy; how do you spell it?) brain is important in music. Not so much if it carries into the rest of your life 🫣
 
Define "at a time"?

If your purpose is to really learn a song, committing it to memory, learning the chord changes and so on, then focusing on that single song will definitely help, perhaps even focusing on a smaller part of it.

But if the goal of the practise session, or sessions, is to develop some other part of saxophone playing then moving between songs isn't a problem. It all depends what your goal of the practise is (and there should be one!).

For example, maybe you want to work on your intonation - you could play a number of different songs that have larger intervallic leaps to different notes, and really drill into making sure you stay in tune after those leaps and adjusting to what you need to do to make that work.

Or perhaps you're practising a lick over a 2-5-1, then you can play multiple different songs but pick a point where you'll try and bring that specific lick in etc.

I do think that focusing a practise session on one thing is very beneficial, but it doesn't have to be one song.
 

Practicing one or more songs at a time?​

Of course, it's a dream scenario! It's natural and it's the way it should be. A beginner without enthusiasm, curiosity, willing to to play/practice often and a big interest for the music you are playing or learning to play ..... is not going to make it. We can all learn to read music and do other things that teachers, instructors, conductors .... tells us to do.
 
Everyone learns slightly differently and it varies at times and, you should do whatever works for you.

Otherwise, song memory is about brain engrams forging connections between memory recall and the physical actions of your fingers, hearing and, your sight if you're reading as well. Routine practice - repetition - enforces subconscious connections but, resting from one thing to another is where the auto memory gets solidified over time.

Think of it like learning to drive a car or routine tasks where you ultimately do them without thinking. The memory recall triggers are personal to you and the triggers might be chord changes and sequencies and, recognising patterns is also a key to music learning and, all songs are comprised of repeated patterns - look for patterns.

The tougher task can be having to learn the same things in different keys including moving from alto to tenor. Playing with other musicians or live is where it all comes together and it still always amazes me how we can just play songs after long periods of not covering them once the band kicks off! So again, it's about triggers ... play, repeat, copy as many times as suits and then rest.

I find that cycling three songs is about as much as I can manage at a time these days. Sometimes I'll just work one (until I get bored). Oh, and don't worry about it!
 
Last edited:
It's certainly OK. The greater question is what works for you?

The other question - if I were your tutor, is "What are your barriers?". Is it reading the notes? Associating fingerings with notes? Are you creating tension when you see notes? You may benefit from developing your technique and musical vocabulary to remove some of the limits in your playing.

If this remains a barrier after two years, I suggest you work with a tutor to get beyond these barriers.
Sure the barriers at the moment are being tackled one by one. And they are less in nummers then a frw months ago.

It is interesting to hear that many of you sax players talk about playing the notes slowly, it takes some patience on my part.

Mostly I want to play a piece quickly. I definitely need to work on this. Thanks to all of you for all the pointers and ideas. I really enjoy blowing and making so much beautiful noise.
 
Sure the barriers at the moment are being tackled one by one. And they are less in nummers then a frw months ago.

It is interesting to hear that many of you sax players talk about playing the notes slowly, it takes some patience on my part.

Mostly I want to play a piece quickly. I definitely need to work on this. Thanks to all of you for all the pointers and ideas. I really enjoy blowing and making so much beautiful noise.
We all want to get up to speed in a hurry because we often need to practice at tempo because, for example, we're performing the song next week! :happydance: But then we have to slow down to get it right, or more importantly, get the timing and phrasing right. Sometimes we adapt it to the way we feel it. I've listened to so many of the old great players doing it their way. So yes, slow down to get it right then it falls under the fingers and gets faster.
 
🙂 🙂 Came in from the garden today after a couple of hours with the tenor (sunny here btw) Autumn Leaves (with a Stan Getz introduction), Tom Waite's (Picture in a Frame), J.S. Bach (Jethro Tull version of Bourree') Beatles, Blue Sky, You don't know what love is, Beatrice (a la Joe Henderson), Summertime (Sonny Rollins/Coleman Hawkins version), Then had a rather nice Chardonnay!! Regards..🙂🙂
 
🙂 🙂 Came in from the garden today after a couple of hours with the tenor (sunny here btw) Autumn Leaves (with a Stan Getz introduction), ........🙂🙂
For me that is the way AL should be played, slow and languid, happy-sad, bitter-sweet.
The community band I've joined do it swing style d=160 which is OK but I prefer it slower e.g. Cannonball Adderley and Miles Davis on Something Else. Might be an alto but still lovely.

Tom Waits, love him.
 
Slow is much harder than quick. The length of each note is more clearly defined and so any discrepancies are highlighted. Producing a consistent tone becomes important. The pauses are more dramatic and breathing has to be planned.

We learn to play it. Then we learn to play it quick, but we really own it when we master playing it slow.

Sometimes boring but always rewarding.
 
Slow is much harder than quick. The length of each note is more clearly defined and so any discrepancies are highlighted. Producing a consistent tone becomes important. The pauses are more dramatic and breathing has to be planned.

We learn to play it. Then we learn to play it quick, but we really own it when we master playing it slow.

Sometimes boring but always rewarding.
I agree. V slow and v quick are the problems
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,362
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom