Theory & Impro Practicing Improvisation

This meant (for me) a whole lot of 'tape playing, stopping, rewinding and re-playing'.
A creative person is helping out to "practice improvising". I have always been open for new inputs. When I was playing football, working as chef, playing the saxophone, building ....... . I learned songs by recording, reel to reel, a song 8-10 times from the radio/grammophone. Less rewinding ..... . I also took down the speed on the reel to reel and played it an octave lower on sax. It helped me because lots of songs were in concert E and A, even concert B. I got used to play in F#/C#, B/F#, C#/G# without knowing what I did. I learned that later. My sax became best friends with the electric guitar. I played sax in a guitar style. This was a slow way to learn. The new technique/equipment is better but I often meet players that are good players but I think thier tone/sound is too mainstream.

When I moved to countryside I became a better player. I could play more sax. No neighbors within a distance of 800 meters. Is the way we live holding back sax players? I think so. The more I play the better I get. I like J.T. Brown (too early or too late with a heavy vibrato) and slide guitar.
 
  • Some people feel that improvised music should be free from pre-conceived ideas and be spontaneous, in-the moment.
  • Others feel that practicing licks and patterns (“all 12 keys!”) and doing transcribing is very important and is key to successful improvisation.
This seems to be basically describing two different genres, as opposed to improvising in general, or improvising in one specific genre.

The first point might apply to so-called free or avant garde jazz (or music).

Second point generally applies to mainstream jazz, blues, rock country, pop im pro which in nearly all cases has an underlying chord/harmonic structure - the simplest being one chord or a two-chord repeated vamp that you may get in funk or modal jazz typically.

I've been involved with both/all and I never minded admitting that when I was studying or doing jazz/blues impro it was not "pure" impro as I always had that structure to fit into and very often a "vocabulary" of existing licks or patterns which I used either because I couldn't think of anything else spontaneous or just to make it sound more authentic or generic.

What I do think is the less complex a harmonic structure, then the more genuinely creative I can be because I tend to think purely about melody - e.g. if there's just one chord the issue of wrong notes is not an issue because (a) I have an idea (almost subconsciously) of the notes that won't be wrong because I might know a basic scale or two that I can frame the melody with (but not exclusively)

Totally free music is of course very different because in that case I may or may not be thinking about melody, may be basing what I play around texture or other abstract concepts. Often it may be constrained by being reaction to other performers I am hearing.

But then also a lot of what people might call free music can very often have structure. For a while I was working with Maggie Nicols which was billed as, or assumed to be, free jazz but it was rare for a piece to have no pre conceived structure.
 
EDIT
This was in response to Mike M (post #13) about playing too many notes. For some reason the quote didn’t copy.

Whilst the point you make about playing too many (fast) notes could be about ego, in my experience it isn’t. It’s the simple fact that of them having little clue about any part of improvising over music which has lots of structure. Harmonic, melodic, time, arrangement and style / genre structures, plus playing in an engaging / perhaps emotive manner.

It’s “rabbit in the headlights” waffle. A fairly normal thing too and most of us will have succumbed unless a better - developed musical brain has been attained already.
 
I’ve been thinking lately about melody and mainstream jazz improvisation. Pete’s recent thread about patterns also kind of gets in there. This thread is about “practicing improvisation”, which I do a lot, but my practice also includes pattern work.

At Monday’s jam, the first tune called was Caravan by Duke and Juan Tizol. I’ve played this tune for years, but hadn’t in a long time. There have been a couple recent videos on it, for example Sarah Hanahan playing over the RealPlay track (an advertisement, essentially). I like her playing, but this improvisation left me cold because it was one dimensional. Lots of “outside” stuff, and very athletic playing, but it did seem more like “practice” than “performance”.

Many jazz solos these days have this one dimensional feel to them. I listen a lot, and many younger players leave me cold. (I am not the first to make this observation…) But when I listen to the old bebop masters, I don’t get this feeling. Why is that?

My opinion is it’s melody. Compelling improvisation is compelling because it is musical, meaning rhythm and melody and harmony are all working together. I’ve been consciously trying to work on melodic playing lately, which for me involves a couple of concepts which I will outline in separate posts. These are kind of like a marriage between “modal thinking” and “bebop thinking”.
What I do think is the less complex a harmonic structure, then the more genuinely creative I can be because I tend to think purely about melody - e.g. if there's just one chord the issue of wrong notes is not an issue because (a) I have an idea (almost subconsciously) of the notes that won't be wrong because I might know a basic scale or two that I can frame the melody with (but not exclusively)
This captures the essence of this idea of melding modal ideas with structured harmony ideas. More to follow…
 
“Play the pretty notes”. This idea is from a quote of Charlie Parker’s, I don’t remember the exact quote, but I sure do remember the idea. It resonates with me because of an experience I had as a teenager learning to improvise.

When I first started playing jazz, modal playing was a big thing. “So What” and “Impressions” were in regular rotation on jazz radio, and one or the other would surely get called at any jam session. So of course I started practicing the Dorian Mode. (In capital letters, because it was the Big Thing.) But as I worked on this, my ear kept telling me that “home” was the note a whole step below the root. That is, I’d play D Dorian, but my ear kept telling me that C was the root. No surprise there, since I had already spent many hours working on major scales on clarinet; I was studying clarinet in the traditional way with a private teacher.

I realized I had to train my ear to hear D as the root. So I would play a long tone of D, then play another note in the mode. Then play D again. Repeat many times, move on to another note, until I could relate every note in D Dorian to D, and not automatically relate it to C major. Then play a scale exercise in D Dorian. As soon as I started hearing C as the root, go back to the long note drill. And of course repeat in the other 11 keys…

This was teenage me trying to figure out this modal thing. It took many months before I was really comfortable with the Dorian mode.

I found that each note in a mode had a “flavor”, a feeling to it, as it related to the root, and to the rest of the notes in the mode. So I could use that as a tool when I was improvising. And as I listened to the masters play on these modal tunes, I could hear what they were doing in terms of these flavors.

As an example of what I mean, consider the difference between D major and D Dorian. The difference is that F and C, the 3rd and 7th, are a half step lower in Dorian. All the other notes are the same. But they don’t SOUND the same. B has a different feeling in D Dorian than in D major.

Grabbing on to this concept was a key to me being able to play freely and feel at home in any mode. Each note in the mode has a character all its own, which is slightly different from its feeling in other modes with the same root.

This concept can be used to generate melodic tension and resolution when playing in a mode. This is one way that improvisors can create interesting solos.

As an example consider the head to So What - the bass plays a melodic line, and the rest of the band says “So What” in response. “So” is an Em7 chord, “What” is Dm7. That’s harmonic motion, and it makes the rhythmic phrase more interesting and compelling.

So when improvising a solo over D Dorian, I can create a similar sense of movement by choosing notes from Em7, followed by notes from Dm7. Play E minor pentatonic for a while, then D minor pentatonic. Or just lay on the B for a while, followed by the A.

This is a way to find compelling melodic material while staying strictly in the mode. Implying a kind of harmonic motion within a seemingly static expanse of Dm7. Emphasizing the flavor of a particular note in the mode, then commenting on it by emphasizing a different note.
 
Back to Caravan. This is a kind of modal tune, because it’s a long expanse of C7 - or C7 alt., with the various extensions being chosen as one’s instincts dictate.

I spent some time yesterday working on patterns with this concept and stumbled upon a way to conceptualize them that I will pursue for a while in the next week or two. Hopefully I’ll get to play Caravan again at a jam or gig, or some other tune with a long section of a dominant chord.

Warning - this is technical or nerdy, so if you’re not interested, just skip it.

Concept 1 - use the F harmonic minor scale but omit the F and G and play Gb instead. This becomes like a C altered scale, but omits the Eb, so it’s a six note scale. Playing common scale patterns on these six notes (diads, triads, “fourth” intervals, “seventh” intervals) has for me some compelling sounds. I’ll be working on this scale for a while I suspect.

Concept 2 - From the above scale, omit the C. This is now a Gb “dominant pentatonic”. Gb-Ab-Bb-Db-Fb. (Or F#-G#-A#-C#-E if you prefer to think in sharps.) Common pentatonic approaches work well with this. Another way to think of this is that Gb/F# is the tritone substitution for C.

This dominant pentatonic is something I’ve played a lot, Trane was fond of this scale, and used it often in a Mixolydian context (go listen to Bessie’s Blues). It’s basically a major pentatonic scale, with the 6th replaced by the flat 7th.

Both of these approaches worked well over this extended C7-whatever chord in Caravan, and it’s a very refreshing release when arriving at the Fm chord. Especially if you play the F melodic minor scale, all those altered tensions resolve very nicely.

The 6-note scale I happened upon yesterday is interesting, and I think it would work well in a major context too. C7-blahblahblah moving to F maj7. Or over a Gm7-C7. It sounds,”out”, but in a good way.
 
Another concept that’s been rattling around, related to the modal motion concept, and the dominant-discombobulated concept, is the idea of thinking modally when playing a tune with structured harmony. Like a bebop tune, or a standard.

Take “Have You Met Miss Jones”. The A section is in F, there are a couple secondary dominants in there, a lot of ii-Vs, and some jazz players take a 1 measure excursion into Gb in the 7th bar of the first A. What if we just treated the entire A section like a big long F maj7 chord? Ignore the harmony completey, and play a nice melodic phrase in F?

Or, maybe create some motion by using the approach I outlined above for improvising over So What. Play a pleasing melody in F major for 6 bars, but in bars 7 and 8 of the A section emphasize Gm7. In other words, think modally but follow the broad strokes of outlined by the functional harmony.

Pete’s comment above on playing more freely in a modal tune fits here. Maybe this is a way to get some freedom into your playing over a tune where we all usually just “play the changes”. Play a couple choruses following the changes, then go into a modal approach as a contrast. You might end up hitting notes that fit the changes, but you aren’t thinking that way you’re just thinking about playing something pretty. (Or not, as your aesthetic goes…)

This is the last of the thoughts that have been spinning around in my music brain for the last month or so. I post this stuff as a way to capture what I’ve been thinking, and hope they spark some ideas in other folks in this wonderful community.
 
I figure Caravan is like free space on the A section, to contrast by hitting the bop hard on the B section. I'll start in C, but it might be diminished, it might be anything that strikes me, but almost every time I get I start diminished it goes onto a thing that's sort of like interval study: half steps separated by m3's. That wants to slide around in different tonalities, sure by half step, but by anything that comes out. It'll be C-B-G#-G and C#-C-B-G#-G-F#. Then Eb-D-Db-Bb-A-Ab. Kinda makes me want to be a snake charmer. Other times it'll be centered on whatever parallel 4ths and tritones come out, sliding them around too. But I always hit the bop on the B. Most times the rhythm section picks up on this and time feel will float on the A too, everyone hitting the B Bop together. (see what I did there, how clever! Spontaneously, improvised if you will.)

Other times, everyone might say "Caravan again?!" So we play something else.
🙂

I find free players tend to play similar skronks a lot, it's not as if every spleech is unique. I'll skronk myself from time to time. On purpose even, some of them I even practice, but THAT DOES NOT MAKE THEM A PATTERN! That's a joke y'all, don't get mad.
 
Many jazz solos these days have this one dimensional feel to them. I listen a lot, and many younger players leave me cold. (I am not the first to make this observation…) But when I listen to the old bebop masters, I don’t get this feeling. Why is that?
Learning by reverse engineering.

It seems a lot of pedagogy is based on analysis that looks for formulae rather than looking at the melodic genius.

A small example might be looking at one or two bars of something Bird played, adding all the notes together and inventing the “bebop scale.” Bird wasn’t thinking “I’ll use the bebop scale here” he just added a chromatic note to make the melodic fragment remove beautifully.

Same with the so-called altered scale - the masters just knew how and when to add the cool notes.

Stuff gets analysed to death.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,499
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom