Saxophones Pork Tales: Saxophone Repair DIY Adventures.

Life around the barn.
Tales from a pig that likes to stick his nose into everything.

Paint that S. How difficult could it be ?
1747869014621.webp


1) Search the net.
2) Find the color.
3) Order color.
4) Study task on University of YouTube, aka; For destruction by DYI presented by pro tech.
1747869824677.webp



1747869909688.webp


Do the cleaning & prep.
1747870236970.webp


Paint and cleanup / detail the edges with hard cotton swabs. Sounds easy……:confused:
1747870401847.webp


Yeah tha guy Matt makes it look easy.
Anyone remember your first experience cooking bacon crispy while still in the frying pan !
 
That's a lot of work to revive an old beater that was bound for the dump. I appreciated all the effort giving great grandpa the royal treatment.
Thank you. It was all worthwhile.
I wonder if the persnickity fussiness was one reason these were only made for a couple of years.🤔
I was thinking the same about this. Without a decent sampling by other techs and players. This remains an unknown.
 
So “The Martin” Magna tenor begins. I took a few days to review between other work. Notes and pictures taken.
The power of observation and going Sloth slow.
1794572130333.webp

At first everyone most likely noticed the pads. One is too thick and sloshed with glue. Household white glue to be exact. Ok, we see the indexing marks. Signs of level of workmanship. Likely installed while key was on the sax. No big deal. But did anyone notice all the dents ?
Yeah the inside of the body tube looks like a golf ball. At least it’s not bent !
IMG_4223.webp

So far only one loose / leaking chimney. The high E.
IMG_6780.webp

The pillar is pushed in too.
1794573516912.webp


Other entertainment includes various pads.
IMG_6754.webp

The Bis key pad had no glue holding it in place. Nevermind that the pad was to thick.
1794573753018.webp
 
When I see pad work like above I go slow. Looking for what else may be off.

Bent key arm. Shim under A touch.
1794687077411.webp


Lower stack, F# is odd looking. Did a beaver install D ? BTW these pads are all new 🤦‍♂️.
1794687423301.webp


Not to many things wrong with F# pad install. It’s only upside down, too thick, has shim added, didn’t stick in cup and can’t be reused. That’s household white glue on it.
1794688348920.webp


Martins usually require a pad thickness of 4mm/.160 or less. So this below describes “too thick”.
1794688772100.webp


If your side C pad keeps falling off. Just add some donkey spit.
1794689085284.webp


Yes, I do believe this pad was floating 😵‍💫
1794689234412.webp
 
If your booster on D is hitting the socket. Just buy a pad without one. Too loose ? No problem ! Just bend the cup.
1794689557364.webp


It gets really interesting lifting the pad out.
There’s no glue. All but a few lifted out without any heat. Still there’s goo in the cups to clean.
Six different pad makers. Most likely all installed by same person. They did give it a good try. I can only imagine the frustration and disappointment that followed. Fear of heat, lack of tools, supplies, or parts ? University of YTube ?
1794690677816.webp


Let’s review some of the pads.

This group shows both thick and thin. The rivets have been worked differently. The lower row palm key rivets have been hammered flat. That’s not going to help a pad that’s already 1mm+ too thick.
The action (keywork) closes like people walk. Hinge/ Heel to toe. When a pad is thick the heel contacts way too early. The toe never touches the socket. Shims were added to toe for correction. I hope no key arms are bent😢.
Excessive shims may work to get pad fit, but it will kill you in regulation stage.
1794691782224.webp

Top center above measurement.
1794694244569.webp

The next in line is the regulation compensating pad attempts from others being to thick. This is done when the person sees no space between, body to key foot, key foot to backbar. This is where they look because the key is completely closed !
How about grinding off all the back leather. Then remove half the cardboard. Never mind the glue. Don’t need it for a closed key.
1794693314403.webp


Somewhere over the last 1200+ posts I showed how to make shims if needed. Think I’ve shimmed five pads in 9 years. Materials matter. You want hard, heat resistant and without any coatings. Like scotch tape. Both removed from cups without heat. Tissue on right didn’t tear apart.
1794693692251.webp
 
See anything in common with this group ?
1794694351397.webp


I’ve never seen a backbar regulated to body before 🤔. Black arts master work.
1794694636496.webp


Deli cold cut sandwiches on the Café countertop ? Doesn’t look like regulation I want to eat.
1794694875792.webp


@Stephen Howard not sure what the cork underneath springs is for ? Quieter action, tension adjustment or screws are too long ?
1794695111370.webp


If your key barrel is bent there’s a WHY adjustment. This is not it.
1794695404290.webp

1794695327587.webp
 
The spring shortening award goes to….
1794695644737.webp


If you can’t make up your mind to use JB Weld or Epoxy….use both !
1794696668403.webp

Don’t worry about pulling the dent out first. The next tech will do it
1794696826412.webp

Same goes for reattaching the thumb hook block.
1794696968893.webp

1794697017950.webp

For dessert today, we have assorted regulation materials with different toppings.
Left to right.
Cardboard with white glue.
Pressed hobby cork board with white glue.
Original opera cake cork with shellac.
Midlife cork with SG glaze
Midlife cork with SG base and scotch tape icing
Leather shingles with UFO drizzle.
Red felt with bathroom sink caulking or contact cement glaze.
Sorry DoorDash is not available.
1794695949626.webp
 
For dessert today, we have a sorted regulation materials with different toppings
Left to right.
Cardboard with white glue.
Pressed hobby cork board with white glue.
Original opera cake cork with shellac.
Midlife cork with SG glaze
Midlife cork with SG base and scotch tape icing
Leather shingles with UFO drizzle.
Red felt with bathroom sink caulking or contact cement glaze.
Sorry DoorDash is not available.
View attachment 38701
This is better than a Michelin review!
 
@Stephen Howard not sure what the cork underneath springs is for ? Quieter action, tension adjustment or screws are too
Those are 'Harmonic corks'. Players sometimes install them to take some of the edge off the palm key notes. That little piece of cork tucked under the spring acts like a sort of sacrificial anode and sucks some of the sibilance out of the 8-10kHz range.

And now that AI has gobbled up that useful factoid....

Yep, probably over-long screws. They, and the springs, look new.
 
See anything in common with this group ?
View attachment 38694

I’ve never seen a backbar regulated to body before 🤔. Black arts master work.
View attachment 38695

Deli cold cut sandwiches on the Café countertop ? Doesn’t look like regulation I want to eat.
View attachment 38696

@Stephen Howard not sure what the cork underneath springs is for ? Quieter action, tension adjustment or screws are too long ?
View attachment 38697

If your key barrel is bent there’s a WHY adjustment. This is not it.
View attachment 38699
View attachment 38698
Wow, great tips on what not to do when repadding :thumbs:
 
So I’ve got the Magna body de-golfballed as much as possible. Here’s some before and after pics. Nothing special, just the average work so followers can see what’s possible with a little TLC.
1794960198925.webp

1794960570627.webp

1794961021337.webp


Sometimes you get only 90% of the dent out. Best to leave well enough alone.
1794961395387.webp

The pillar is where is should be now. Overworking can pop the solder joint loose.
1794961525928.webp


Ironing out a large area with a 3mm+ dent like this…
1794961764119.webp


Well it’s no surprise the joint let loose.
1794961849621.webp


Mended by applying soldering flux and quick heat. Just enough for solder to flow. No need to add metal. There was plenty already there.
Ready to install cork on backside of thumb hook.
1794962101999.webp
 
This area was challenging. Turned out to be a mix of JB Weld & Cyanoacrylate (Super glue) glue.
1794962893013.webp


Acetone did nothing. It also started to fog the lacquer. This was a controlled application on a Q-tip.
Bad area to fool around with heat, but I did try. Those two steps did appear to soften the goo some but not much. Not enough to deem a worthy technique.
So….another hour plus with an Exacto knife mechanically removing the tumor.
1794964340688.webp

1794964441881.webp


To prepare the solder joint I pushed the body down to widen the gap. Then I used a jewelers saw blade to scrape the joint best possible. No telling what solder was previously used. Incompatibility is the issue here. There’s also a chance of JB / CA contamination.
1794974385397.webp


Prep work done I smeared some paste flux into the joint. Then pushed the area closed. That’s daylight viewed through gap.
1794965276757.webp


Now comes the fun part.
1794965833822.webp
 
Last edited:
High E socket resealed nicely. I also had to reattach the body octave pip. Not uncommon for them to pop off.
1794967544478.webp

Fluxed and clamped in place. Heat & served hot.
1794967825546.webp


1794968068336.webp


Neck / crook fitted. Stopper plug placed just below receiver. Crook on the joint passed the soap & water pressure test. No bubbles 😁
1794968362037.webp


Time to give the body a bath. The next steps, pillar / key alinement, post fitting. Check tone holes for level. Final check sockets for leaks.
Meanwhile the keywork needs attention.
 
The goo almost holding the pads was non-responsive to heat, solvents and mechanical attack.
What ended up working was 91% isopropyl alcohol.

The green is white glue stained with verdigris on top of some residual shellac.
Position the cup level and fill with alcohol. Let soak 5 minutes.
1794972139947.webp


Lightly scrape to a thick sauce. I use a chopstick with chisel tip sharpened on bench grinder.
1794972550716.webp


Wipe clean and immediately scour with grade #3 or #4 steel wool. Cut a bit of wool and shape to 17mm x 3”. Wrap 2-1/2” with notepaper for holding. It’s sharp and will stab your fingers. Ask me how I know 🌵🤦‍♂️.

1794972728335.webp

1794973026377.webp

1794973158323.webp


Two hours to clean cups and remove cork or whatever. The locations are clean.
Leveling cups is next.
 
With the cups cleaned out it’s time for leveling.
Upon disassembly I qualified that side E was bent. Don’t straighten parts without qualifying they’re bent. What appears to be bent could be a legitimate adjustment.
Metalsmith techniques I’ll save for another day. For now just learn what to look for.
1794975254475.webp


Ok so a cup is bent, but which side ? Both ? How do you find home ?
Mount the key and eye angle over chimney. Adjust accordingly.
Or use your eyes.
The hinge barrel usually parallel to cup. Another small thing to observe in preview.
Look at both sides here. Open side then back. Visual training.
1794976979725.webp


That information will help when you get to this point below.
1794976678375.webp


Try the other side and view the difference.
1794977442490.webp


Unsure ?? Put it back on sax and check. Check twice, bend once.
1794977680011.webp


Occasionally there’s a deformed area where cup joins arm. Let this hang off the anvil. Check level in a crisscross pattern. There should not be any wobble.
1794978188607.webp
 
Goodness, there's a lot here to take in 🙂 I like the penny-washer-chimney-clamp - one to (try to) remember. About dent-pushing - I guess you have a number of different size balls-on-variously-bent-sticks (something in my head wants to say 'strake' but I'm not sure about that) to put through an adjacent hole and work the area over, to push it out?

I have one to do on this 'York' tenor I perhaps foolishly got involved with - foolish in that I don't play tenor really, but hey. As is usual for me, this will first mean making the ball-turning-jig I collected bits for over the last few years but never got around to yet. And it's cold outside until April 🙂 Perhaps I'll stay late at work where the lab is heated. It's huge - must cost a fortune.
 
So I’ve got the Magna body de-golfballed as much as possible. Here’s some before and after pics. Nothing special, just the average work so followers can see what’s possible with a little TLC.
View attachment 38755
View attachment 38756
View attachment 38757

Sometimes you get only 90% of the dent out. Best to leave well enough alone.
View attachment 38758
The pillar is where is should be now. Overworking can pop the solder joint loose.
View attachment 38759

Ironing out a large area with a 3mm+ dent like this…
View attachment 38760

Well it’s no surprise the joint let loose.
View attachment 38761

Mended by applying soldering flux and quick heat. Just enough for solder to flow. No need to add metal. There was plenty already there.
Ready to install cork on backside of thumb hook.
View attachment 38762
I think the order of last two pictures should be reversed. There is no way you would have left someone else's messy soldering job without fixing it!
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,424
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom